SPB Git

Repository Public

FEATURE-PARITY-MATRIX.md 11.1 KB

# SP Note Next Generation — feature parity matrix (state at delivery, 2026-11-19)

Versions: Web/backend 3.0.0 (in production) · macOS 2.0.0 (4) (notarised, installed) · iOS/iPadOS 2.0.0 (2) (uploaded to App Store Connect) · shared Swift core 2.0.0.

Legend — ✅ implemented and verified by a test that ran (unit, hosted, UI or live against the integration server) · ◐ implemented, partly verified or with a stated limit · ○ implemented, not exercised (needs a real device, a signed build or real pointer/touch input) · — absent. "Verified" never means "used by a person on a device": see TEST-PLAN.md §6 for what only the owner can check. iPadOS shares the iOS binary; its column is given only where it differs.

Before = state at the audit (web 2.0.0, macOS 1.0.2, iOS 1.0.0).

# 1. Notes and editor

Feature Backend Web macOS iOS iPadOS Before → action taken
ProseMirror JSON canonical, lossless round trip, unknown nodes preserved ✅ ✅ (new: content check + read-only on unknown schema) ✅ ✅ = Web could blank a page containing unknown nodes → fixed (P0)
Paragraphs, headings, lists, tasks, quotes, callouts, code, tables, images, files, math, mentions ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = existing, kept
Slash menu n/a ✅ ✅ ✅ (new) = absent on iOS → added
Markdown typing shortcuts n/a ✅ ✅ ✅ (new) = absent on iOS → added
Rich tasks (due, priority, linked task row) ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
Callout kinds decision / question / hypothesis + kind picker ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
Toggles and footnotes: create ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = natives could only display → added
Mermaid diagram ✅ export/index ✅ render + stored preview ◐ source editor + stored preview (no native renderer: no JS engine allowed) ◐ same = new
Drawing (spn-ink-1) ✅ ✅ pointer editor ◐ view ✅; mouse ink editor ○ ✅ conversion PencilKit ⇄ ink tested; real strokes ○ Pencil ○ iOS had image + companion file → new shared format, old drawings kept
Chart (bar, line, area, pie, scatter; live from a database) ✅ ✅ ✅ Swift Charts ✅ = new
Living view (queryView) ✅ /api/query ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
Citation + bibliography ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = new (APA only on natives)
PDF block with annotations ✅ ✅ highlights + notes verified; ink/zoom ○ ◐ mapping tested; interactive view ○ ◐ mapping tested (rotations); Pencil ink ○ Pencil ○ new
Block reference / transclusion ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
Runnable code ✅ stores output ✅ sandboxed, no network, kill on loop ◐ shows code + last output; no execution by design ◐ same = new
Voice note (audio) ✅ ✅ record, pause/resume, transcript seek ◐ model tested; microphone ○ ◐ one simulator recording; real microphone ○ = new
Canvas link card ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
AI result block with sources ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = existed (aiBlock), extended
Syntax colouring in code n/a ✅ ✅ ✅ (new) = absent on iOS → added
Table editing n/a ✅ in place ◐ grid sheet ◐ grid sheet = unchanged (limit kept)
Morphing toolbar, Living Pages, Reduce Motion n/a ✅ ✅ ◐ decisions tested, not watched in motion = new

# 2. Organisation, capture, tasks

Feature Backend Web macOS iOS iPadOS Before → action
Page tree / folders, tags, pin, favourite, archive, trash, restore ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = existing; tag counts, purge, cycles fixed server-side
Quick capture (text, idea, link, image, PDF, audio, screenshot, document, selection) ✅ ✅ ◐ quick note panel: model tested; global hotkey, drag & drop ○ ◐ 8 modes; camera/scanner ○ = extended
Capture reaches the server inbox when made offline ✅ (new: inboxAt on page create) ✅ ✅ ✅ live test = iOS captures became plain notes → fixed
Inbox triage with undo ✅ ✅ ✅ (own screen, offline) ✅ (own screen, offline) = natives listed only → added
Smart inbox AI suggestions (on demand, applied selectively) ✅ ✅ — (app keeps its offline inbox screen) — (same) = new on web; not surfaced in the native inbox screens
Global tasks list, due, priority ✅ feed + client ids ✅ ✅ offline outbox ✅ offline outbox, live test = absent natively → added
Task due notifications n/a — ○ ○ = new, never delivered on a device
Share extension / PWA share target n/a ✅ share target ○ Services menu ✅ lands in inbox = iOS fixed (was plain notes)
Widgets n/a n/a — ◐ rendered; interactive task widget; redacted when locked; real Home Screen ○ = lock leak fixed
Siri / App Intents, Spotlight n/a n/a ○ Spotlight ○ = extended, device-only

# 3. Databases

Feature Backend Web macOS iOS iPadOS Before → action
Table, board, list, gallery, calendar, timeline views ✅ ✅ ✅ opened on live data ✅ opened on live data (compact = cards) ✅ natives had a read-only banner → native screen
Filters (AND/OR), sorts, grouping, saved views ✅ SQL engine ✅ ✅ ✅ = engine moved to SQL (first page 105 → 6 ms on 20 000 rows)
Inline editing, keyboard navigation, bulk actions, undo/redo ✅ ✅ ◐ row edit; no relation/file/AI cell editing, no column resize ◐ sheet edit = new on web; partial natively
Relations, rollups, formulas ✅ ✅ ◐ displayed with server values ◐ same = rollups completed, formula errors per cell
Smart (AI) properties: config, runs log, protected hand edits ✅ ✅ — — = web only
Offline n/a ◐ "not kept on this device" state ◐ readable from cache, written online ◐ same = by design (SPEC §6)
CSV import/export, row templates ✅ ✅ — — = web only

# 4. Knowledge: graph, timeline, health, brief

Feature Backend Web macOS iOS iPadOS Before → action
Graph views: global, local, project, chronological, concepts, documents, references ✅ ✅ ✅ opened on live data ✅ opened ✅ 2 views on web only → 7 everywhere
Typed relations (create, edit, accept / reject AI suggestions) ✅ ✅ ◐ view-model tested; not driven by hand ◐ same = new
Graph intelligence: central pages, orphans, clusters, topics, duplicates ✅ deterministic ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
AI analysis: contradictions, open questions ◐ job + validation tested with a fake model; never run with a real model ◐ UI tested on fixtures ◐ ◐ = new; needs one real run by the owner
Thought Constellation ✅ projection of real embeddings ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ new (Labs)
Knowledge Timeline (real events only; back-filled ones marked) ✅ journal ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
Knowledge Time Machine + restore ✅ ✅ ◐ opened; restore not driven ◐ same = new
Knowledge Health ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = new
Daily Brief (AI summary only on request) ✅ ✅ (new Home) ✅ ✅ = new
Semantic Zoom (synopsis AI-marked, outline, full) ✅ ✅ ◐ wired, logic tested ✅ opened = new
Backlinks ✅ ✅ ✅ inspector ✅ = absent natively → added
Infinite canvas ✅ versioned, feed ✅ 10 card kinds, merge on conflict, 60 fps at 1 000 cards ◐ opened on live data; gestures not driven ◐ opened; list mode; Pencil hook ○ ◐ new; merge identical web/Swift on 60 shared cases

# 5. AI

Feature Backend Web macOS iOS iPadOS Before → action
Ask My Knowledge with scope and verified block citations ✅ ✅ ◐ opened; no message sent in tests ◐ same = citations now anchor the best block and are clickable natively
Contextual actions (15 existing + coherence, questions, links, synthesis, structure) ✅ ✅ ◐ existing actions tested; new ones through the same path ◐ same = extended
Providers: OpenAI, Anthropic ✅ ✅ via server via server = kept; routing table unchanged
Providers: OpenRouter, MacLustr local (OpenAI-compatible) ◐ adapter tested against a fake server; no key configured, never called live ◐ listed as unavailable ◐ ◐ = new; needs keys
Model selector with creator logos, route, context, price, availability ✅ ✅ ◐ wired ✅ opened = new (13 logos from simple-icons; others use a neutral mark)
Agents with proposals and approval ✅ ✅ — — = unchanged, web only
Transcription ✅ one real run (whisper-1) ✅ ○ ◐ server path; on-device speech ○ = new
Research workspace, DOI/BibTeX, LaTeX export ✅ ✅ ✅ opened ✅ opened = natives had nothing → references screen; LaTeX zip web only

# 6. Sync, offline, account

Feature Backend Web macOS iOS iPadOS Before → action
Change feed for pages + attachments ✅ ✅ (now used) ✅ ✅ = existing
Change feed for tasks, databases, edges, references, canvases, concepts ✅ ✅ tasks ✅ ✅ = new
Offline read / create / edit notes n/a ✅ (new replica + journal) ✅ ✅ live scenario = web kept only drafts → full replica
Conflict handling without silent loss ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅ = existing; extended to canvases
Offline images n/a ◐ 10 MB each, 100 MB queued ✅ ✅ = new on web
Passkeys (WebAuthn, server-verified), sessions, device management ✅ ✅ ○ in the signed build ○ on a device = already delivered in 2.0; unchanged
Store-open failure is a blocking error (no silent in-memory store) n/a n/a ✅ ✅ = data-safety defect → fixed
Local store migration v1 → v2 with backup n/a n/a ✅ on a copy of real 1.0.2 data ✅ incl. widget + share extension = new
Universal links /p/<id> ✅ AASA n/a — ○ entitlement + parser tested = new
Command center (⌘K) n/a ✅ ✅ ◐ touch entry ◐ ⌘K; Escape not reproduced in simulator new
Multi-window, menus, keyboard shortcuts n/a ✅ side pane ○ n/a ○ iPad .commands added

# 7. What is not delivered (and why)

  • Native execution of code blocks and native rendering of Mermaid: a JavaScript engine is excluded from the native apps on purpose; both show the stored result/preview and edit the source.
  • Smart-inbox suggestions, agents, smart database properties, CSV, bulk import: web only.
  • End-to-end encryption: not offered, not claimed.
  • Real-time multi-cursor collaboration (CRDT): not introduced; single-owner product, block-level merge kept.
  • OpenRouter and MacLustr local models: architecture in place, no keys configured, nothing benchmarked, so they are not routed automatically.
Files main
Menu

Theme