Icon design
The ORIX Sheet icon is generated by code, not drawn in an editor:
design/icon/make-icons.swift (212 lines, AppKit + CoreGraphics) draws five concepts, the final
1024 px master, a contact sheet and the ten PNG sizes of the macOS asset catalog.
Related: brand guidelines, design system, distribution (the DMG background reuses the same plate).
What is and is not recorded
The brief for this document asks for the evaluation of the five concepts against six criteria (originality, recognizability, balance, small-size legibility, family consistency, contrast). No scores, ranking or written evaluation exist in the repository. What exists is:
- the generator script, whose comments state the idea of each concept and the reason for the final choice in one sentence ("Final — refinement of concept 1: thicker ring opened by the sheet's row/column axes, larger cells, the active cell carries the selection handle. Reads at 16 px as 'ring + bright square'.");
- the rendered images, including a contact sheet built for the comparison: each concept at 300 px and, underneath, at 64, 32 and 16 px.
The sections below therefore describe what the script draws and what the images show. The per-criterion table is an examination of those images made for this document on 2026-11-21; it is a qualitative reading, not a record of the original decision, and no numeric score is given.
The contact sheet
![]()
Left to right: concepts 1 to 5, then the final icon. The file is a copy of
design/icon/concepts-sheet.png (1840 × 450 px, background #F4F5FA, the light canvas token).
Common construction
Every concept sits on the same plate (plate() in the script):
| Element | Value |
|---|---|
| Canvas | 1024 × 1024 px, sRGB, transparent outside the plate |
| Plate | 824 × 824 px rounded square centred in the canvas, corner radius 186 px |
| Plate fill | vertical gradient #1B2A4A (top) → #0B0F1E (bottom) over a #0B1020 base |
| Glow | radial, centre (330, 800), radius 560 px, 75 % → 0 % opacity; colour #1E5A78 (concepts 1, 3, 4, final), #2A3F8A (concept 2), #1E6A78 (concept 5) |
| Drop shadow | offset 10 px down, blur 24 px, black at 35 % |
| Edge | 3 px white stroke at 10 % |
| Brand gradient | #22D3EE → #3B9BF5 (at 55 %) → #6366F1, top-left to bottom-right of the shape's bounding box |
Source: design/icon/make-icons.swift (plate, brand).
#22D3EE is the dark-mode accent token of the application; the plate colours are icon-only and
are not tokens (see design system).
The five concepts
| # | File | Idea (script comment) | What is drawn |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | concept-1-ring-sheet.png |
ORIX "O" whose counter is a 3×3 sheet; one cell is the active cell | gradient ring 536 px across, 62 px thick; nine 78 px cells with 16 px gaps; centre cell solid white, top row at 42 % and the others at 26 % of #EAF6FF |
| 2 | concept-2-data-matrix.png |
abstract data matrix: 5×5 dots with a diagonal intensity ramp | twenty-five 92 px rounded squares, opacity rising from 18 % (bottom-left) to 100 % (top-right) |
| 3 | concept-3-precision-table.png |
precision table: header band, hairline rules and measurement ticks | translucent table with a gradient header band 96 px high, three horizontal and two vertical 6 px rules, thirteen cyan ruler ticks under the table |
| 4 | concept-4-chart-cells.png |
chart + grid monogram: rising bars made of cells | 4×4 grid of 112 px cells; columns filled to heights 1, 2, 3, 4 with the gradient, the rest at 8 % white |
| 5 | concept-5-layered-sheets.png |
layered sheets inside the ORIX ring | gradient ring 552 px across, 46 px thick; three stacked white sheets at 22 %, 48 % and 100 % opacity, the front one ruled into cells |
Source: design/icon/make-icons.swift (concept1 … concept5); files in design/icon/, each 512 × 512 px.
Reading of the images against the six criteria
Qualitative observations from the contact sheet. "Small sizes" refers to the 64 / 32 / 16 px row.
| Criterion | 1 Ring + sheet | 2 Data matrix | 3 Precision table | 4 Chart cells | 5 Layered sheets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Originality | ring and grid combined in one mark | a plain dot matrix; nothing ties it to this product | a literal table; the ruler ticks are the only distinctive element | a familiar "bars" chart motif built from cells | ring plus a document stack; the stack is a common motif |
| Recognizability as a spreadsheet | the 3×3 grid with one selected cell reads as a sheet | reads as a generic grid or keypad | the most literal: header, rows, columns | reads as a chart first, a sheet second | the ruled front sheet reads as a document or table |
| Balance | radially symmetric, centred | uniform texture, weight shifts to the top-right with the opacity ramp | top-heavy (bright header band), ticks close to the bottom edge | weight on the right and bottom (staircase) | stack offset down-left inside a centred ring |
| Small-size legibility | at 16 px a ring with a bright centre remains | at 16 px the dots merge into a dark square | rules and ticks disappear at 16 px; the header band remains as a line | the staircase survives at 32 px, is faint at 16 px | ring and white block remain; the ruling is lost |
| Family consistency | uses the ORIX "O" ring and the brand gradient | brand gradient only, no ring | gradient only in the header band | brand gradient only, no ring | uses the ring and gradient |
| Contrast | white active cell on navy; pale cells are low-contrast by design | lower-left dots nearly merge with the plate | 6 px half-opacity rules are faint on the translucent table | filled cells strong; empty cells at 8 % barely visible | solid white sheet has the strongest contrast of the five |
Source: visual examination of design/icon/concepts-sheet.png on 2026-11-21. No measurement
(contrast ratio, legibility test with users) was made, and none is recorded in the repository.
What the images support: the two ring concepts (1 and 5) are the only ones that keep a recognisable silhouette in the 16 px rendering, and of those two, concept 1 keeps the spreadsheet idea (grid plus active cell) inside the ring rather than a document stack. This agrees with the script's own comment that the final is a refinement of concept 1 chosen to read at 16 px as "ring + bright square". Whether the six criteria were weighed in this way when the choice was made is not documented.
The final icon
![]()
finalIcon() changes concept 1 as follows:
| Property | Concept 1 | Final |
|---|---|---|
| Ring outer diameter | 536 px | 564 px |
| Ring thickness | 62 px | 70 px |
| Cell side / gap | 78 px / 16 px | 84 px / 15 px |
| Cell corner radius | 18 px | 19 px |
| Surrounding cells | #EAF6FF, top row 42 %, others 26 % |
#DDF3FF, top row and left column 40 %, others 22 % |
| Active cell | white | white with a cyan glow (#22D3EE at 85 %, blur 34 px) |
| Selection handle | none | 30 px cyan square (#22D3EE, radius 8) on a 42 px #101A30 backing, at the bottom-right corner of the active cell |
Source: design/icon/make-icons.swift (concept1, finalIcon).
The brighter top row and left column stand for the header row and header column of a sheet; the handle is the fill handle of the selected cell. In the script comment the ring is described as "opened by the sheet's row/column axes"; the drawing code does not cut the ring — it is a closed annulus (two ellipses with even-odd clipping), and the rendered master shows a closed ring. The comment and the code disagree on that point.
Generated files
swift design/icon/make-icons.swift design/iconwrites, into the directory given as argument:
| Output | Size |
|---|---|
concept-1-…png to concept-5-…png |
512 × 512 px (drawn at 1024, downsampled with high interpolation) |
orix-sheet-icon-1024.png |
1024 × 1024 px master |
concepts-sheet.png |
1840 × 450 px contact sheet |
AppIcon.appiconset/ |
icon_16x16.png … icon_512x512@2x.png (16, 32, 128, 256, 512 pt at 1x and 2x) and Contents.json |
Source: design/icon/make-icons.swift; pixel sizes confirmed with sips -g pixelWidth -g pixelHeight.
Facts about the generated set:
- All ten sizes are downsampled from the single 1024 px master. There is no size-specific artwork: the 16 px icon is the full drawing scaled down, not a simplified variant.
- The asset catalog used by the build is
App/Resources/Assets.xcassets/AppIcon.appiconset. The script writes todesign/icon/AppIcon.appiconset; the copy into the app's catalog is a manual step that the script does not perform. On 2026-11-21 the two sets are byte-identical for the files compared (cmponicon_16x16.pngand on the 1024 px master vsicon_512x512@2x.png). - The same icon is declared as the document icon of
.orixsheetfiles (UTTypeIconFile=AppIconinApp/Resources/Info.plist); there is no separate document icon. - The script is deterministic (no random input); re-running it regenerates every file.
Not done
- No dark/tinted/clear icon variants for newer macOS icon styles, no
.icon(Icon Composer) file. - No monochrome or template version for menus or the toolbar.
- No measured contrast for the icon and no legibility test beyond the contact sheet.