run_id,kind,id,passed_or_type,description
RD0001,criterion,beta_point,1,OLS slope equals reference to 1e-4
RD0001,criterion,se_cluster,1,Cluster-robust SE within 8% of CR1 reference (covers CR1/CR0/CR3 conventions and t vs normal)
RD0001,criterion,ci,1,95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1) or normal critical values both accepted)
RD0001,criterion,counts,1,n_analysed and n_clusters exact
RD0001,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE (the design has strong within-cluster correlation)
RD0003,criterion,beta_point,1,OLS slope equals reference to 1e-4
RD0003,criterion,se_cluster,1,Cluster-robust SE within 8% of CR1 reference (covers CR1/CR0/CR3 conventions and t vs normal)
RD0003,criterion,ci,1,95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1) or normal critical values both accepted)
RD0003,criterion,counts,1,n_analysed and n_clusters exact
RD0003,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE (the design has strong within-cluster correlation)
RD0004,criterion,beta_point,1,OLS slope equals reference to 1e-4
RD0004,criterion,se_cluster,1,Cluster-robust SE within 8% of CR1 reference (covers CR1/CR0/CR3 conventions and t vs normal)
RD0004,criterion,ci,1,95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1) or normal critical values both accepted)
RD0004,criterion,counts,1,n_analysed and n_clusters exact
RD0004,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE (the design has strong within-cluster correlation)
RD0002,criterion,beta_point,1,OLS slope equals reference to 1e-4
RD0002,criterion,se_cluster,1,Cluster-robust SE within 8% of CR1 reference (covers CR1/CR0/CR3 conventions and t vs normal)
RD0002,criterion,ci,1,95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1) or normal critical values both accepted)
RD0002,criterion,counts,1,n_analysed and n_clusters exact
RD0002,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE (the design has strong within-cluster correlation)
RP0001,criterion,unemployment_rate,1,Unemployment rate September 2026 = 6.5 (as printed in 'Highlights' and 'Unemployment rate increases to 6.5%')
RP0001,criterion,employment_change,1,Monthly employment change = -68000 persons (as printed)
RP0001,criterion,locators_name_sections,1,Locators name a section of the release in which the figure appears
RP0001,criterion,assertion_verdict,1,Assertion is not supported: the release states the core-aged men's unemployment rate FELL 0.2 points to 5.8% (women part is correct)
RP0001,criterion,assertion_locator,1,Assertion locator names the section 'Unemployment rate up for core-aged women'
RP0002,criterion,unemployment_rate,1,Unemployment rate September 2026 = 6.5 (as printed in 'Highlights' and 'Unemployment rate increases to 6.5%')
RP0002,criterion,employment_change,1,Monthly employment change = -68000 persons (as printed)
RP0002,criterion,locators_name_sections,1,Locators name a section of the release in which the figure appears
RP0002,criterion,assertion_verdict,1,Assertion is not supported: the release states the core-aged men's unemployment rate FELL 0.2 points to 5.8% (women part is correct)
RP0002,criterion,assertion_locator,1,Assertion locator names the section 'Unemployment rate up for core-aged women'
RP0003,criterion,unemployment_rate,1,Unemployment rate September 2026 = 6.5 (as printed in 'Highlights' and 'Unemployment rate increases to 6.5%')
RP0003,criterion,employment_change,1,Monthly employment change = -68000 persons (as printed)
RP0003,criterion,locators_name_sections,1,Locators name a section of the release in which the figure appears
RP0003,criterion,assertion_verdict,1,Assertion is not supported: the release states the core-aged men's unemployment rate FELL 0.2 points to 5.8% (women part is correct)
RP0003,criterion,assertion_locator,1,Assertion locator names the section 'Unemployment rate up for core-aged women'
RP0004,criterion,unemployment_rate,1,Unemployment rate September 2026 = 6.5 (as printed in 'Highlights' and 'Unemployment rate increases to 6.5%')
RP0004,criterion,employment_change,1,Monthly employment change = -68000 persons (as printed)
RP0004,criterion,locators_name_sections,1,Locators name a section of the release in which the figure appears
RP0004,criterion,assertion_verdict,1,Assertion is not supported: the release states the core-aged men's unemployment rate FELL 0.2 points to 5.8% (women part is correct)
RP0004,criterion,assertion_locator,1,Assertion locator names the section 'Unemployment rate up for core-aged women'
RP0005,criterion,counts,1,"n_unique_firms, n_missing_revenue and n_analysed exact"
RP0005,criterion,mean_revenue,1,"mean revenue (millions USD) after de-duplication and unit harmonisation, within 0.05"
RP0005,criterion,median_revenue,1,"median revenue (millions USD) after cleaning, within 0.05"
RP0005,criterion,mean_employees,1,"mean employees over unique firms, within 0.5"
RP0005,criterion,analytic_rows,1,"out/analytic.csv has exactly n_analysed rows, one per firm, with a revenue column"
RP0005,criterion,ledger,1,"out/exclusions.csv exists, has the required columns, is internally consistent and its total removals equal n_input_rows - n_analysed"
RP0005,criterion,issues_detected,1,data_issues lists both the duplicated rows and the unit mix
RP0006,criterion,counts,1,"n_unique_firms, n_missing_revenue and n_analysed exact"
RP0006,criterion,mean_revenue,1,"mean revenue (millions USD) after de-duplication and unit harmonisation, within 0.05"
RP0006,criterion,median_revenue,1,"median revenue (millions USD) after cleaning, within 0.05"
RP0006,criterion,mean_employees,1,"mean employees over unique firms, within 0.5"
RP0006,criterion,analytic_rows,1,"out/analytic.csv has exactly n_analysed rows, one per firm, with a revenue column"
RP0006,criterion,ledger,1,"out/exclusions.csv exists, has the required columns, is internally consistent and its total removals equal n_input_rows - n_analysed"
RP0006,criterion,issues_detected,1,data_issues lists both the duplicated rows and the unit mix
RP0007,criterion,counts,1,"n_unique_firms, n_missing_revenue and n_analysed exact"
RP0007,criterion,mean_revenue,1,"mean revenue (millions USD) after de-duplication and unit harmonisation, within 0.05"
RP0007,criterion,median_revenue,1,"median revenue (millions USD) after cleaning, within 0.05"
RP0007,criterion,mean_employees,1,"mean employees over unique firms, within 0.5"
RP0007,criterion,analytic_rows,1,"out/analytic.csv has exactly n_analysed rows, one per firm, with a revenue column"
RP0007,criterion,ledger,1,"out/exclusions.csv exists, has the required columns, is internally consistent and its total removals equal n_input_rows - n_analysed"
RP0007,criterion,issues_detected,1,data_issues lists both the duplicated rows and the unit mix
RP0008,criterion,counts,1,"n_unique_firms, n_missing_revenue and n_analysed exact"
RP0008,criterion,mean_revenue,1,"mean revenue (millions USD) after de-duplication and unit harmonisation, within 0.05"
RP0008,criterion,median_revenue,1,"median revenue (millions USD) after cleaning, within 0.05"
RP0008,criterion,mean_employees,1,"mean employees over unique firms, within 0.5"
RP0008,criterion,analytic_rows,1,"out/analytic.csv has exactly n_analysed rows, one per firm, with a revenue column"
RP0008,criterion,ledger,1,"out/exclusions.csv exists, has the required columns, is internally consistent and its total removals equal n_input_rows - n_analysed"
RP0008,criterion,issues_detected,1,data_issues lists both the duplicated rows and the unit mix
RP0009,criterion,beta_fe,1,Two-way within (firm + year FE) slope equals reference to 1e-4
RP0009,criterion,se_cluster,1,Firm-clustered SE within 10% of CR1/LSDV-K reference (covers CR0/CR1/CR3 and K-counting conventions)
RP0009,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1), t(N-K) or normal critical values all accepted)"
RP0009,criterion,counts,1,"n_firms, n_years, n_analysed exact"
RP0009,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE by at least 20% (within-firm serial correlation in x and u)
RP0009,criterion,pooled_differs,1,Reported pooled slope must differ from reported FE slope by more than 0.05 (the executor must actually have removed the effects)
RP0010,criterion,beta_fe,1,Two-way within (firm + year FE) slope equals reference to 1e-4
RP0010,criterion,se_cluster,1,Firm-clustered SE within 10% of CR1/LSDV-K reference (covers CR0/CR1/CR3 and K-counting conventions)
RP0010,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1), t(N-K) or normal critical values all accepted)"
RP0010,criterion,counts,1,"n_firms, n_years, n_analysed exact"
RP0010,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE by at least 20% (within-firm serial correlation in x and u)
RP0010,criterion,pooled_differs,1,Reported pooled slope must differ from reported FE slope by more than 0.05 (the executor must actually have removed the effects)
RP0011,criterion,beta_fe,1,Two-way within (firm + year FE) slope equals reference to 1e-4
RP0011,criterion,se_cluster,1,Firm-clustered SE within 10% of CR1/LSDV-K reference (covers CR0/CR1/CR3 and K-counting conventions)
RP0011,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1), t(N-K) or normal critical values all accepted)"
RP0011,criterion,counts,1,"n_firms, n_years, n_analysed exact"
RP0011,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE by at least 20% (within-firm serial correlation in x and u)
RP0011,criterion,pooled_differs,1,Reported pooled slope must differ from reported FE slope by more than 0.05 (the executor must actually have removed the effects)
RP0012,criterion,beta_fe,1,Two-way within (firm + year FE) slope equals reference to 1e-4
RP0012,criterion,se_cluster,1,Firm-clustered SE within 10% of CR1/LSDV-K reference (covers CR0/CR1/CR3 and K-counting conventions)
RP0012,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t(G-1), t(N-K) or normal critical values all accepted)"
RP0012,criterion,counts,1,"n_firms, n_years, n_analysed exact"
RP0012,criterion,se_ordering,1,Reported cluster SE must exceed reported conventional SE by at least 20% (within-firm serial correlation in x and u)
RP0012,criterion,pooled_differs,1,Reported pooled slope must differ from reported FE slope by more than 0.05 (the executor must actually have removed the effects)
RP0013,criterion,year_and_counts,1,"analysis_year, n_analysed and n_excluded_missing exact (countries/economies only, aggregates excluded)"
RP0013,criterion,slope,1,OLS slope of life expectancy on log GDP per capita within 0.02 of reference
RP0013,criterion,robust_se,1,"heteroskedasticity-robust SE within 5% of HC1 reference (HC0–HC3 accepted, conventional OLS SE rejected)"
RP0013,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t or normal critical values, any HC variant)"
RP0013,criterion,correlation_baseline,1,Pearson correlation and R² within 0.005
RP0013,criterion,fit_metrics,1,baseline RMSE (mean-only) and model RMSE within 1–1.5%
RP0013,criterion,conclusion,1,conclusion code = positive_effect
RP0013,criterion,figure,1,out/figure1.png exists and is a valid PNG
RP0013,criterion,table,1,out/table1.csv parses with >= 2 data rows
RP0014,criterion,year_and_counts,1,"analysis_year, n_analysed and n_excluded_missing exact (countries/economies only, aggregates excluded)"
RP0014,criterion,slope,1,OLS slope of life expectancy on log GDP per capita within 0.02 of reference
RP0014,criterion,robust_se,1,"heteroskedasticity-robust SE within 5% of HC1 reference (HC0–HC3 accepted, conventional OLS SE rejected)"
RP0014,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t or normal critical values, any HC variant)"
RP0014,criterion,correlation_baseline,1,Pearson correlation and R² within 0.005
RP0014,criterion,fit_metrics,1,baseline RMSE (mean-only) and model RMSE within 1–1.5%
RP0014,criterion,conclusion,1,conclusion code = positive_effect
RP0014,criterion,figure,1,out/figure1.png exists and is a valid PNG
RP0014,criterion,table,1,out/table1.csv parses with >= 2 data rows
RP0015,criterion,year_and_counts,1,"analysis_year, n_analysed and n_excluded_missing exact (countries/economies only, aggregates excluded)"
RP0015,criterion,slope,1,OLS slope of life expectancy on log GDP per capita within 0.02 of reference
RP0015,criterion,robust_se,1,"heteroskedasticity-robust SE within 5% of HC1 reference (HC0–HC3 accepted, conventional OLS SE rejected)"
RP0015,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t or normal critical values, any HC variant)"
RP0015,criterion,correlation_baseline,1,Pearson correlation and R² within 0.005
RP0015,criterion,fit_metrics,1,baseline RMSE (mean-only) and model RMSE within 1–1.5%
RP0015,criterion,conclusion,1,conclusion code = positive_effect
RP0015,criterion,figure,1,out/figure1.png exists and is a valid PNG
RP0015,criterion,table,1,out/table1.csv parses with >= 2 data rows
RP0016,criterion,year_and_counts,1,"analysis_year, n_analysed and n_excluded_missing exact (countries/economies only, aggregates excluded)"
RP0016,criterion,slope,1,OLS slope of life expectancy on log GDP per capita within 0.02 of reference
RP0016,criterion,robust_se,1,"heteroskedasticity-robust SE within 5% of HC1 reference (HC0–HC3 accepted, conventional OLS SE rejected)"
RP0016,criterion,ci,1,"95% CI bounds within 0.03 of reference (t or normal critical values, any HC variant)"
RP0016,criterion,correlation_baseline,1,Pearson correlation and R² within 0.005
RP0016,criterion,fit_metrics,1,baseline RMSE (mean-only) and model RMSE within 1–1.5%
RP0016,criterion,conclusion,1,conclusion code = positive_effect
RP0016,criterion,figure,1,out/figure1.png exists and is a valid PNG
RP0016,criterion,table,1,out/table1.csv parses with >= 2 data rows
RP0017,criterion,demands,1,Marshallian demands within 1e-3 of the closed form (accepts a numerical optimiser)
RP0017,criterion,indirect_utility,1,Indirect utility within 1e-4 of the closed form
RP0017,criterion,budget_identity,1,Reported budget identity residual p1*x1 + p2*x2 - m within 1e-6 of zero
RP0017,criterion,mrs_equals_price_ratio,1,MRS at the optimum within 1e-3 of p1/p2 and price_ratio exact
RP0017,criterion,numerical_validation,1,Numerically maximised utility on the budget line within 1e-4 of the analytical indirect utility
RP0017,criterion,assumptions_stated,1,report.md states the assumptions/scope of the closed form (regex: 'assum' and one of interior|positive|concav|monoton|Cobb|log)
RP0018,criterion,demands,1,Marshallian demands within 1e-3 of the closed form (accepts a numerical optimiser)
RP0018,criterion,indirect_utility,1,Indirect utility within 1e-4 of the closed form
RP0018,criterion,budget_identity,1,Reported budget identity residual p1*x1 + p2*x2 - m within 1e-6 of zero
RP0018,criterion,mrs_equals_price_ratio,1,MRS at the optimum within 1e-3 of p1/p2 and price_ratio exact
RP0018,criterion,numerical_validation,1,Numerically maximised utility on the budget line within 1e-4 of the analytical indirect utility
RP0018,criterion,assumptions_stated,1,report.md states the assumptions/scope of the closed form (regex: 'assum' and one of interior|positive|concav|monoton|Cobb|log)
RP0019,criterion,demands,1,Marshallian demands within 1e-3 of the closed form (accepts a numerical optimiser)
RP0019,criterion,indirect_utility,1,Indirect utility within 1e-4 of the closed form
RP0019,criterion,budget_identity,1,Reported budget identity residual p1*x1 + p2*x2 - m within 1e-6 of zero
RP0019,criterion,mrs_equals_price_ratio,1,MRS at the optimum within 1e-3 of p1/p2 and price_ratio exact
RP0019,criterion,numerical_validation,1,Numerically maximised utility on the budget line within 1e-4 of the analytical indirect utility
RP0019,criterion,assumptions_stated,1,report.md states the assumptions/scope of the closed form (regex: 'assum' and one of interior|positive|concav|monoton|Cobb|log)
RP0020,criterion,demands,1,Marshallian demands within 1e-3 of the closed form (accepts a numerical optimiser)
RP0020,criterion,indirect_utility,1,Indirect utility within 1e-4 of the closed form
RP0020,criterion,budget_identity,1,Reported budget identity residual p1*x1 + p2*x2 - m within 1e-6 of zero
RP0020,criterion,mrs_equals_price_ratio,1,MRS at the optimum within 1e-3 of p1/p2 and price_ratio exact
RP0020,criterion,numerical_validation,1,Numerically maximised utility on the budget line within 1e-4 of the analytical indirect utility
RP0020,criterion,assumptions_stated,1,report.md states the assumptions/scope of the closed form (regex: 'assum' and one of interior|positive|concav|monoton|Cobb|log)