{ "runs_main": 6048, "runs_ablation": 584, "cells_main": 756, "institution_loss_shares": [ { "regime": "central", "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5, "welfare_loss": 1.0, "bits_loss": 1.0, "success_loss": 1.0, "n_cells": 108 }, { "regime": "central", "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0, "welfare_loss": 0.5, "bits_loss": 0.75, "success_loss": 0.0, "n_cells": 108 }, { "regime": "federated", "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5, "welfare_loss": 0.7963, "bits_loss": 0.9537, "success_loss": 0.7778, "n_cells": 108 }, { "regime": "federated", "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0, "welfare_loss": 0.5, "bits_loss": 0.537, "success_loss": 0.0, "n_cells": 108 }, { "regime": "norms", "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0, "welfare_loss": 0.0648, "bits_loss": 1.0, "success_loss": 0.0, "n_cells": 108 }, { "regime": "records", "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0, "welfare_loss": 0.0, "bits_loss": 0.5, "success_loss": 0.0, "n_cells": 108 } ], "theorem_checks": { "T1_code_shorter_than_raw_when_H_le_log2s_minus_1": true, "T1_cells_where_code_longer_than_raw": [ { "s": 64, "zipf": 0.5, "H_p_bits": 5.781, "L_code_bits": 6.236, "L_raw_bits": 6.0 } ], "T1_entropy_le_code_lt_entropy_plus_1": true, "T3_post_shock_extra_bits_per_recipient_norms_vs_KL": { "mean_extra_bits_per_recipient": 1.895726362235342, "mean_KL": 1.979594637192137, "within_KL_pm_1": true } } } regime admin_capacity_ratio n_pairs share_lower_bits_per_success share_lower_bits_incl_setup share_higher_success share_higher_welfare mean_d_bits_per_success mean_d_success mean_d_welfare norms 2.0 864 0.997 0.000 0.993 0.900 -5.454 0.032 1.513 records 2.0 864 0.712 0.500 1.000 1.000 -43.568 0.434 25.671 central 0.5 864 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 2450.858 -0.493 -32.080 central 2.0 864 0.330 0.247 1.000 0.500 19.546 0.409 9.651 federated 0.5 864 0.093 0.042 0.222 0.179 692.894 -0.293 -22.414 federated 2.0 864 0.499 0.463 1.000 0.500 -4.610 0.412 10.491 shock_type regime admin_capacity_ratio d_success_mean d_bits_mean kl_q_p_bits_mean distribution central 0.5 0.000 6.286 1.03 distribution central 2.0 0.000 6.286 1.03 distribution federated 0.5 0.000 4.224 1.03 distribution federated 2.0 0.000 4.224 1.03 distribution none 2.0 0.000 0.000 1.03 distribution norms 2.0 0.000 1.031 1.03 distribution records 2.0 0.000 1.049 1.03 network central 0.5 0.000 0.031 0.00 network central 2.0 -0.074 0.031 0.00 network federated 0.5 -0.019 0.565 0.00 network federated 2.0 -0.075 0.565 0.00 network none 2.0 -0.004 0.000 0.00 network norms 2.0 -0.004 0.001 0.00 network records 2.0 -0.070 -0.003 0.00 { "reference": { "central": { "success_rate": 0.997, "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 82.815, "welfare_per_agent": 42.6682 }, "federated": { "success_rate": 1.0, "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 53.2697, "welfare_per_agent": 43.6894 }, "none": { "success_rate": 0.9178, "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 15.2547, "welfare_per_agent": 55.0433 }, "norms": { "success_rate": 0.9603, "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 23.7302, "welfare_per_agent": 57.2665 }, "records": { "success_rate": 1.0, "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 24.809, "welfare_per_agent": 59.3009 } }, "records_without_verification": { "success_rate": 0.9603, "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 25.8128, "welfare_per_agent": 57.1857 }, "norms_adaptation": { "0": { "d_bits": 0.0349, "success_post": 0.9634, "kl_q_p_bits": 1.9796 }, "10": { "d_bits": 1.9173, "success_post": 0.9634, "kl_q_p_bits": 1.9796 }, "1000": { "d_bits": 3.7915, "success_post": 0.9634, "kl_q_p_bits": 1.9796 } }, "breakeven_norms_wins_bits": { "s=16,zipf=0.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=64,zipf=0.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=64,zipf=0.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=10,learn=0.0": true, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=10,learn=200.0": false, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=10,learn=1000.0": false, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=40,learn=0.0": true, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=40,learn=1000.0": false, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=160,learn=0.0": true, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=160,learn=200.0": false, "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=160,learn=1000.0": false, "s=64,zipf=1.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=64,zipf=2.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=256,zipf=0.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=10,learn=200.0": false, "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=10,learn=1000.0": false, "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false, "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=40,learn=1000.0": false, "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=160,learn=200.0": true, "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=160,learn=1000.0": false }, "heterogeneity_eps": { "eps=0.05,none": { "success_rate": 0.9835, "fail_decode_share": 0.0165 }, "eps=0.05,norms": { "success_rate": 0.9603, "fail_decode_share": 0.0397 }, "eps=0.25,none": { "success_rate": 0.9178, "fail_decode_share": 0.0822 }, "eps=0.25,norms": { "success_rate": 0.9603, "fail_decode_share": 0.0397 }, "eps=0.6,none": { "success_rate": 0.8077, "fail_decode_share": 0.1923 }, "eps=0.6,norms": { "success_rate": 0.9603, "fail_decode_share": 0.0397 } }, "federated_branching": { "4": { "success_rate": 0.9303, "msgs_per_task": 8.8566, "root_load_mean": 47.6688 }, "8": { "success_rate": 0.9871, "msgs_per_task": 6.6146, "root_load_mean": 41.8192 }, "16": { "success_rate": 0.9959, "msgs_per_task": 6.2688, "root_load_mean": 208.7415 } }, "coding_gain": { "s=16,zipf=0.0": { "H": 4.0, "L_code": 4.0, "L_raw": 4.0, "bits_per_task": 10.0 }, "s=64,zipf=0.0": { "H": 6.0