% generated by scripts/07_make_numbers.py — do not edit \newcommand{\nFiles}{278} \newcommand{\nPDF}{277} \newcommand{\nIncluded}{276} \newcommand{\nExcluded}{2} \newcommand{\nYearSeventeen}{63} \newcommand{\nYearEighteen}{65} \newcommand{\nYearNineteen}{74} \newcommand{\nYearTwenty}{74} \newcommand{\nTypeArticle}{263} \newcommand{\nTypeCorrigendumOrReplication}{8} \newcommand{\nTypePresidentialAddress}{4} \newcommand{\nTypeRetractedArticle}{1} \newcommand{\nCrossrefOk}{276} \newcommand{\pagesTotal}{11{,}735} \newcommand{\pagesMedian}{43} \newcommand{\sizeMB}{231} \newcommand{\parseMeanConf}{0.951} \newcommand{\parseLowConf}{3} \newcommand{\parseMedianNWordsBody}{10965} \newcommand{\parseMedianNTables}{8} \newcommand{\parseMedianNFigures}{4} \newcommand{\parseMedianNEquations}{10} \newcommand{\parseMedianNReferences}{52} \newcommand{\parseMedianNFootnotes}{37} \newcommand{\parseMedianAbstractWords}{101} \newcommand{\parseMedianNSections}{5} \newcommand{\qaNSample}{26} \newcommand{\qaSectionsExact}{85} \newcommand{\qaTablesExact}{77} \newcommand{\qaTablesWithinOne}{96} \newcommand{\qaFiguresExact}{92} \newcommand{\qaEquationsExact}{8} \newcommand{\qaEquationsWithinTenPct}{35} \newcommand{\qaReferencesWithinTenPct}{92} \newcommand{\qaAbstractAgree}{100} \newcommand{\qaTitleVsCrossrefGeNinetyAllDocs}{99} \newcommand{\qaTitleNAllDocs}{276} \newcommand{\nAnnotated}{276} \newcommand{\nAnnValid}{276} \newcommand{\nGenreEmpirical}{142} \newcommand{\nGenreMixedTheoryEmpirical}{75} \newcommand{\nGenreTheoretical}{40} \newcommand{\nGenreReplicationOrCorrection}{9} \newcommand{\nGenreMethodologicalEconometric}{7} \newcommand{\nGenreSurveyOrAddress}{3} \newcommand{\nSubAssetPricing}{93} \newcommand{\nSubCorporateFinance}{48} \newcommand{\nSubFinancialIntermediationBanking}{34} \newcommand{\nSubHouseholdFinance}{27} \newcommand{\nSubMarketMicrostructure}{24} \newcommand{\nSubBehavioralFinance}{15} \newcommand{\nSubMacroFinance}{12} \newcommand{\nSubEntrepreneurialFinancePrivateEquity}{11} \newcommand{\nSubInternationalFinance}{8} \newcommand{\nSubFinancialEconometrics}{4} \newcommand{\roleAgreementMedian}{1.00} \newcommand{\roadmapAgree}{97} \newcommand{\contribAgree}{62} \newcommand{\annCostUSD}{20.62} \newcommand{\annCostPerDoc}{0.075} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllN}{221} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllHasRobustnessSectionShare}{26} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllHasRobustnessShare}{26} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllHasLiteratureSectionShare}{17} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllHasLiteratureShare}{17} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllHasAppendixShare}{50} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllHasInternetAppendixShare}{89} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNWordsBodyMed}{11009} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNWordsBodyQa}{10035} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNWordsBodyQb}{12407} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroWordsMed}{1804} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroWordsQa}{1568} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroWordsQb}{2132} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroParagraphsMed}{7} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroParagraphsQa}{6} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroParagraphsQb}{9} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroShareMed}{0.16} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroShareQa}{0.14} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllIntroShareQb}{0.19} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNTablesMed}{8} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNTablesQa}{6} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNTablesQb}{11} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNEquationsMed}{10} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNEquationsQa}{4} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNEquationsQb}{23} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNReferencesMed}{52} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNReferencesQa}{41} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNReferencesQb}{64} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllConclusionShareMed}{0.03} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllConclusionShareQa}{0.02} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllConclusionShareQb}{0.05} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllPagesMed}{43} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllPagesQa}{38} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllPagesQb}{47} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbstractWordsMed}{101} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbstractWordsQa}{96} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbstractWordsQb}{104} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNSectionsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNSectionsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNSectionsQb}{6} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNFiguresMed}{4} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNFiguresQa}{2} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNFiguresQb}{7} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNFootnotesMed}{37} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNFootnotesQa}{29} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNFootnotesQb}{48} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNSubsectionsMed}{14} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNSubsectionsQa}{10} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNSubsectionsQb}{19} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNWordsAppendixMed}{0} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNWordsAppendixQa}{0} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllNWordsAppendixQb}{1599} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbsQuestion}{70} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbsGap}{14} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbsMethod}{83} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbsResults}{99} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbsMagnitude}{24} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllAbsContribution}{69} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllRoadmap}{63} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllRoadmapRegex}{60} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllContribPos}{0.58} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllContribPosQa}{0.13} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllContribPosQb}{0.78} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllCausal}{3.0} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllEconSig}{79} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllConclBounded}{82} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllConclOpen}{37} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllFirstMoveShare}{89} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllRobustLoc}{mixed} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllRobustLocShare}{37} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllSE}{unclear} \newcommand{\profCorpusAllSEShare}{62} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllN}{173} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllHasRobustnessSectionShare}{24} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllHasRobustnessShare}{24} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllHasLiteratureSectionShare}{18} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllHasLiteratureShare}{18} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllHasAppendixShare}{43} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllHasInternetAppendixShare}{94} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNWordsBodyMed}{11009} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNWordsBodyQa}{10052} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNWordsBodyQb}{12194} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroWordsMed}{1804} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroWordsQa}{1588} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroWordsQb}{2116} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroParagraphsMed}{7} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroParagraphsQa}{6} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroParagraphsQb}{9} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroShareMed}{0.17} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroShareQa}{0.14} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllIntroShareQb}{0.19} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNTablesMed}{9} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNTablesQa}{7} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNTablesQb}{11} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNEquationsMed}{7} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNEquationsQa}{2} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNEquationsQb}{15} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNReferencesMed}{53} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNReferencesQa}{43} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNReferencesQb}{64} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllConclusionShareMed}{0.03} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllConclusionShareQa}{0.02} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllConclusionShareQb}{0.05} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllPagesMed}{43} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllPagesQa}{39} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllPagesQb}{47} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbstractWordsMed}{100} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbstractWordsQa}{96} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbstractWordsQb}{104} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNSectionsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNSectionsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNSectionsQb}{6} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNFiguresMed}{4} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNFiguresQa}{2} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNFiguresQb}{6} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNFootnotesMed}{36} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNFootnotesQa}{28} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNFootnotesQb}{43} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNSubsectionsMed}{13} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNSubsectionsQa}{10} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNSubsectionsQb}{18} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNWordsAppendixMed}{0} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNWordsAppendixQa}{0} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllNWordsAppendixQb}{510} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbsQuestion}{72} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbsGap}{12} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbsMethod}{83} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbsResults}{100} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbsMagnitude}{29} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllAbsContribution}{65} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllRoadmap}{65} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllRoadmapRegex}{64} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllContribPos}{0.62} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllContribPosQa}{0.20} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllContribPosQb}{0.80} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllCausal}{3.0} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllEconSig}{92} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllConclBounded}{83} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllConclOpen}{39} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllFirstMoveShare}{90} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllRobustLoc}{mixed} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllRobustLocShare}{42} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllSE}{unclear} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAllSEShare}{78} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingN}{58} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingHasRobustnessSectionShare}{26} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingHasRobustnessShare}{26} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingHasLiteratureSectionShare}{9} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingHasLiteratureShare}{9} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingHasAppendixShare}{53} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingHasInternetAppendixShare}{91} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNWordsBodyMed}{10920} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNWordsBodyQa}{9901} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNWordsBodyQb}{12250} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroWordsMed}{1729} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroWordsQa}{1526} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroWordsQb}{2160} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroParagraphsMed}{8} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroParagraphsQa}{6} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroParagraphsQb}{10} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroShareMed}{0.16} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroShareQa}{0.14} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingIntroShareQb}{0.18} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNTablesMed}{10} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNTablesQa}{8} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNTablesQb}{11} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNEquationsMed}{14} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNEquationsQa}{9} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNEquationsQb}{25} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNReferencesMed}{53} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNReferencesQa}{44} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNReferencesQb}{68} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingConclusionShareMed}{0.03} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingConclusionShareQa}{0.02} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingConclusionShareQb}{0.04} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingPagesMed}{42} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingPagesQa}{38} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingPagesQb}{48} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbstractWordsMed}{100} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbstractWordsQa}{93} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbstractWordsQb}{103} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNSectionsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNSectionsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNSectionsQb}{6} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNFiguresMed}{4} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNFiguresQa}{2} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNFiguresQb}{7} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNFootnotesMed}{35} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNFootnotesQa}{27} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNFootnotesQb}{43} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNSubsectionsMed}{13} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNSubsectionsQa}{10} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNSubsectionsQb}{18} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNWordsAppendixMed}{22} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNWordsAppendixQa}{0} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingNWordsAppendixQb}{1430} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbsQuestion}{66} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbsGap}{12} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbsMethod}{84} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbsResults}{100} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbsMagnitude}{21} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingAbsContribution}{69} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingRoadmap}{67} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingRoadmapRegex}{64} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingContribPos}{0.60} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingContribPosQa}{0.18} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingContribPosQb}{0.80} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingCausal}{2.0} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingEconSig}{93} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingConclBounded}{79} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingConclOpen}{40} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingFirstMoveShare}{84} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingRobustLoc}{mixed} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingRobustLocShare}{43} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingSE}{unclear} \newcommand{\profEmpiricalAssetPricingSEShare}{67} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceN}{28} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceHasRobustnessSectionShare}{29} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceHasRobustnessShare}{29} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceHasLiteratureSectionShare}{18} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceHasLiteratureShare}{18} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceHasAppendixShare}{25} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceHasInternetAppendixShare}{89} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNWordsBodyMed}{11150} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNWordsBodyQa}{10415} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNWordsBodyQb}{11550} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroWordsMed}{1927} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroWordsQa}{1738} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroWordsQb}{2119} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroParagraphsMed}{8} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroParagraphsQa}{6} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroParagraphsQb}{11} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroShareMed}{0.17} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroShareQa}{0.15} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceIntroShareQb}{0.20} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNTablesMed}{10} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNTablesQa}{8} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNTablesQb}{12} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNEquationsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNEquationsQa}{2} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNEquationsQb}{8} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNReferencesMed}{50} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNReferencesQa}{36} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNReferencesQb}{59} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceConclusionShareMed}{0.04} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceConclusionShareQa}{0.03} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceConclusionShareQb}{0.06} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinancePagesMed}{42} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinancePagesQa}{39} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinancePagesQb}{46} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbstractWordsMed}{100} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbstractWordsQa}{97} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbstractWordsQb}{103} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNSectionsMed}{6} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNSectionsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNSectionsQb}{6} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNFiguresMed}{3} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNFiguresQa}{2} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNFiguresQb}{5} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNFootnotesMed}{36} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNFootnotesQa}{27} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNFootnotesQb}{41} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNSubsectionsMed}{12} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNSubsectionsQa}{10} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNSubsectionsQb}{19} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNWordsAppendixMed}{0} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNWordsAppendixQa}{0} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceNWordsAppendixQb}{6} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbsQuestion}{57} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbsGap}{11} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbsMethod}{79} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbsResults}{100} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbsMagnitude}{29} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceAbsContribution}{71} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceRoadmap}{57} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceRoadmapRegex}{57} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceContribPos}{0.78} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceContribPosQa}{0.64} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceContribPosQb}{0.86} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceCausal}{3.0} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceEconSig}{93} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceConclBounded}{89} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceConclOpen}{29} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceFirstMoveShare}{93} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceRobustLoc}{mixed} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceRobustLocShare}{46} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceSE}{unclear} \newcommand{\profCorporateFinanceSEShare}{96} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceN}{32} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceHasRobustnessSectionShare}{44} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceHasRobustnessShare}{44} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceHasLiteratureSectionShare}{19} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceHasLiteratureShare}{19} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceHasAppendixShare}{88} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceHasInternetAppendixShare}{72} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNWordsBodyMed}{11064} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNWordsBodyQa}{10315} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNWordsBodyQb}{13576} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroWordsMed}{1896} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroWordsQa}{1673} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroWordsQb}{2359} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroParagraphsMed}{8} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroParagraphsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroParagraphsQb}{9} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroShareMed}{0.16} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroShareQa}{0.13} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceIntroShareQb}{0.22} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNTablesMed}{0} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNTablesQa}{0} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNTablesQb}{2} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNEquationsMed}{36} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNEquationsQa}{22} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNEquationsQb}{63} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNReferencesMed}{45} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNReferencesQa}{38} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNReferencesQb}{64} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceConclusionShareMed}{0.03} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceConclusionShareQa}{0.01} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceConclusionShareQb}{0.04} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinancePagesMed}{45} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinancePagesQa}{38} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinancePagesQb}{50} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbstractWordsMed}{102} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbstractWordsQa}{96} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbstractWordsQb}{104} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNSectionsMed}{6} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNSectionsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNSectionsQb}{6} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNFiguresMed}{4} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNFiguresQa}{3} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNFiguresQb}{7} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNFootnotesMed}{50} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNFootnotesQa}{40} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNFootnotesQb}{64} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNSubsectionsMed}{17} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNSubsectionsQa}{11} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNSubsectionsQb}{28} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNWordsAppendixMed}{3030} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNWordsAppendixQa}{2434} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceNWordsAppendixQb}{4518} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbsQuestion}{72} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbsGap}{0} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbsMethod}{88} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbsResults}{100} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbsMagnitude}{0} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceAbsContribution}{81} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceRoadmap}{53} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceRoadmapRegex}{50} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceContribPos}{0.40} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceContribPosQa}{0.00} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceContribPosQb}{0.66} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceCausal}{1.0} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceEconSig}{25} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceConclBounded}{81} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceConclOpen}{28} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceFirstMoveShare}{88} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceRobustLoc}{none seen} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceRobustLocShare}{41} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceSE}{none} \newcommand{\profTheoreticalFinanceSEShare}{100} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsN}{8} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsHasRobustnessSectionShare}{25} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsHasRobustnessShare}{25} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsHasLiteratureSectionShare}{0} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsHasLiteratureShare}{0} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsHasAppendixShare}{50} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsHasInternetAppendixShare}{75} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNWordsBodyMed}{12412} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNWordsBodyQa}{9017} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNWordsBodyQb}{14125} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroWordsMed}{1512} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroWordsQa}{1001} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroWordsQb}{2292} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroParagraphsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroParagraphsQa}{4} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroParagraphsQb}{9} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroShareMed}{0.13} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroShareQa}{0.10} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsIntroShareQb}{0.17} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNTablesMed}{6} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNTablesQa}{4} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNTablesQb}{6} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNEquationsMed}{22} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNEquationsQa}{8} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNEquationsQb}{37} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNReferencesMed}{52} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNReferencesQa}{39} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNReferencesQb}{67} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsConclusionShareMed}{0.04} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsConclusionShareQa}{0.03} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsConclusionShareQb}{0.04} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsPagesMed}{44} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsPagesQa}{40} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsPagesQb}{46} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbstractWordsMed}{109} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbstractWordsQa}{98} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbstractWordsQb}{120} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNSectionsMed}{4} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNSectionsQa}{4} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNSectionsQb}{7} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNFiguresMed}{4} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNFiguresQa}{2} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNFiguresQb}{8} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNFootnotesMed}{38} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNFootnotesQa}{33} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNFootnotesQb}{48} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNSubsectionsMed}{14} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNSubsectionsQa}{9} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNSubsectionsQb}{17} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNWordsAppendixMed}{84} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNWordsAppendixQa}{0} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsNWordsAppendixQb}{1060} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbsQuestion}{62} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbsGap}{62} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbsMethod}{88} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbsResults}{100} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbsMagnitude}{12} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsAbsContribution}{100} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsRoadmap}{62} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsRoadmapRegex}{50} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsContribPos}{0.45} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsContribPosQa}{0.15} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsContribPosQb}{0.54} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsCausal}{1.0} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsEconSig}{50} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsConclBounded}{75} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsConclOpen}{25} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsFirstMoveShare}{88} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsRobustLoc}{within results} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsRobustLocShare}{50} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsSE}{none} \newcommand{\profFinancialEconometricsSEShare}{62} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingN}{21} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingHasRobustnessSectionShare}{19} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingHasRobustnessShare}{19} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingHasLiteratureSectionShare}{29} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingHasLiteratureShare}{29} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingHasAppendixShare}{52} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingHasInternetAppendixShare}{100} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNWordsBodyMed}{11218} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNWordsBodyQa}{10601} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNWordsBodyQb}{11678} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroWordsMed}{1728} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroWordsQa}{1653} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroWordsQb}{2069} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroParagraphsMed}{6} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroParagraphsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroParagraphsQb}{8} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroShareMed}{0.16} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroShareQa}{0.14} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingIntroShareQb}{0.18} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNTablesMed}{10} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNTablesQa}{7} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNTablesQb}{12} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNEquationsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNEquationsQa}{2} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNEquationsQb}{7} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNReferencesMed}{49} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNReferencesQa}{45} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNReferencesQb}{59} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingConclusionShareMed}{0.04} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingConclusionShareQa}{0.03} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingConclusionShareQb}{0.05} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingPagesMed}{43} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingPagesQa}{41} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingPagesQb}{44} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbstractWordsMed}{101} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbstractWordsQa}{100} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbstractWordsQb}{111} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNSectionsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNSectionsQa}{4} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNSectionsQb}{6} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNFiguresMed}{3} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNFiguresQa}{2} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNFiguresQb}{6} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNFootnotesMed}{37} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNFootnotesQa}{30} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNFootnotesQb}{47} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNSubsectionsMed}{14} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNSubsectionsQa}{10} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNSubsectionsQb}{16} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNWordsAppendixMed}{21} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNWordsAppendixQa}{0} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingNWordsAppendixQb}{23} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbsQuestion}{76} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbsGap}{10} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbsMethod}{81} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbsResults}{100} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbsMagnitude}{38} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingAbsContribution}{62} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingRoadmap}{71} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingRoadmapRegex}{67} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingContribPos}{0.67} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingContribPosQa}{0.46} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingContribPosQb}{0.75} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingCausal}{3.0} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingEconSig}{100} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingConclBounded}{86} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingConclOpen}{38} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingFirstMoveShare}{95} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingRobustLoc}{mixed} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingRobustLocShare}{57} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingSE}{unclear} \newcommand{\profFinancialIntermediationBankingSEShare}{90} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceN}{32} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceHasRobustnessSectionShare}{22} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceHasRobustnessShare}{22} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceHasLiteratureSectionShare}{25} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceHasLiteratureShare}{25} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceHasAppendixShare}{34} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceHasInternetAppendixShare}{97} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNWordsBodyMed}{10576} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNWordsBodyQa}{9716} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNWordsBodyQb}{12794} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroWordsMed}{1830} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroWordsQa}{1598} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroWordsQb}{2063} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroParagraphsMed}{7} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroParagraphsQa}{7} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroParagraphsQb}{10} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroShareMed}{0.17} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroShareQa}{0.16} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceIntroShareQb}{0.19} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNTablesMed}{8} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNTablesQa}{6} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNTablesQb}{11} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNEquationsMed}{2} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNEquationsQa}{0} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNEquationsQb}{7} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNReferencesMed}{56} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNReferencesQa}{45} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNReferencesQb}{68} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceConclusionShareMed}{0.04} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceConclusionShareQa}{0.03} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceConclusionShareQb}{0.05} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinancePagesMed}{42} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinancePagesQa}{40} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinancePagesQb}{45} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbstractWordsMed}{100} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbstractWordsQa}{97} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbstractWordsQb}{104} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNSectionsMed}{5} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNSectionsQa}{5} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNSectionsQb}{6} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNFiguresMed}{4} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNFiguresQa}{2} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNFiguresQb}{7} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNFootnotesMed}{33} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNFootnotesQa}{28} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNFootnotesQb}{42} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNSubsectionsMed}{12} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNSubsectionsQa}{9} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNSubsectionsQb}{17} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNWordsAppendixMed}{0} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNWordsAppendixQa}{0} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceNWordsAppendixQb}{21} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbsQuestion}{84} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbsGap}{6} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbsMethod}{91} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbsResults}{100} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbsMagnitude}{38} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceAbsContribution}{47} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceRoadmap}{72} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceRoadmapRegex}{72} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceContribPos}{0.46} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceContribPosQa}{0.02} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceContribPosQb}{0.69} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceCausal}{3.0} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceEconSig}{94} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceConclBounded}{81} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceConclOpen}{50} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceFirstMove}{motivation} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceFirstMoveShare}{94} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceRobustLoc}{mixed} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceRobustLocShare}{34} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceSE}{unclear} \newcommand{\profHouseholdBehavioralFinanceSEShare}{69} \newcommand{\idxUnits}{9{,}642} \newcommand{\idxDocs}{276} \newcommand{\idxDocsAnn}{276} \newcommand{\idxDim}{384} \newcommand{\idxUnitSectionOpening}{2{,}165} \newcommand{\idxUnitTableNotes}{2{,}105} \newcommand{\idxUnitIntroMove}{1{,}908} \newcommand{\idxUnitClaimEvidence}{1{,}762} \newcommand{\idxUnitFigureCaption}{1{,}150} \newcommand{\idxUnitDocumentSummary}{276} \newcommand{\idxUnitIdentification}{276} \newcommand{\nTrain}{221} \newcommand{\nHeldout}{55} \newcommand{\nHeldoutAuthorOverlap}{20} \newcommand{\apiCalls}{601} \newcommand{\apiSpendUSD}{50.92} \newcommand{\apiSpendAnnotation}{20.58} \newcommand{\apiSpendWrite}{19.53} \newcommand{\apiSpendReferee}{8.23} \newcommand{\apiSpendReview}{0.19} \newcommand{\apiSpendAnnotationretry}{0.96} \newcommand{\apiSpendJudge}{1.44} \newcommand{\bmRuns}{199} \newcommand{\bmRunsOk}{199} \newcommand{\bmJudgments}{33} \newcommand{\bmAClarity}{5.67} \newcommand{\bmAArgumentLogic}{5.04} \newcommand{\bmAContributionPositioning}{4.12} \newcommand{\bmAMethodologicalRigor}{4.17} \newcommand{\bmAFidelity}{5.83} \newcommand{\bmAUsefulness}{4.83} \newcommand{\bmANInventedFacts}{0.79} \newcommand{\bmAN}{24} \newcommand{\bmBClarity}{5.67} \newcommand{\bmBArgumentLogic}{5.17} \newcommand{\bmBContributionPositioning}{4.38} \newcommand{\bmBMethodologicalRigor}{4.54} \newcommand{\bmBFidelity}{5.21} \newcommand{\bmBUsefulness}{4.88} \newcommand{\bmBNInventedFacts}{1.54} \newcommand{\bmBN}{24} \newcommand{\bmCClarity}{5.71} \newcommand{\bmCArgumentLogic}{5.42} \newcommand{\bmCContributionPositioning}{4.67} \newcommand{\bmCMethodologicalRigor}{4.58} \newcommand{\bmCFidelity}{5.29} \newcommand{\bmCUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmCNInventedFacts}{1.33} \newcommand{\bmCN}{24} \newcommand{\bmDClarity}{5.71} \newcommand{\bmDArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmDContributionPositioning}{4.46} \newcommand{\bmDMethodologicalRigor}{4.88} \newcommand{\bmDFidelity}{5.62} \newcommand{\bmDUsefulness}{5.04} \newcommand{\bmDNInventedFacts}{1.08} \newcommand{\bmDN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEClarity}{5.62} \newcommand{\bmEArgumentLogic}{5.96} \newcommand{\bmEContributionPositioning}{4.62} \newcommand{\bmEMethodologicalRigor}{6.21} \newcommand{\bmEFidelity}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmEUsefulness}{5.29} \newcommand{\bmENInventedFacts}{0.42} \newcommand{\bmEN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBClarityDiff}{+0.04} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBClarityLo}{-0.41} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBClarityHi}{0.28} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBClarityP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBClarityN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.33} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBArgumentLogicLo}{-0.22} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBArgumentLogicHi}{0.66} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBArgumentLogicP}{0.448} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBArgumentLogicN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBContributionPositioningDiff}{+0.08} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBContributionPositioningLo}{-0.41} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBContributionPositioningHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBContributionPositioningP}{0.967} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBContributionPositioningN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBUsefulnessDiff}{+0.17} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBUsefulnessLo}{-0.50} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBUsefulnessHi}{0.69} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBUsefulnessP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHDvsBUsefulnessN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCClarityDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCClarityLo}{-0.28} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCClarityHi}{0.25} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCClarityP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCClarityN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.08} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCArgumentLogicLo}{-0.44} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCArgumentLogicHi}{0.47} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCArgumentLogicP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCArgumentLogicN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCContributionPositioningDiff}{-0.21} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCContributionPositioningLo}{-0.72} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCContributionPositioningHi}{0.16} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCContributionPositioningP}{0.611} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCContributionPositioningN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCUsefulnessDiff}{+0.04} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCUsefulnessLo}{-0.50} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCUsefulnessHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCUsefulnessP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHDvsCUsefulnessN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDMethodologicalRigorDiff}{+1.33} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDMethodologicalRigorLo}{1.00} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDMethodologicalRigorHi}{1.84} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDMethodologicalRigorP}{0.000} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDMethodologicalRigorN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDFidelityDiff}{+0.62} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDFidelityLo}{0.31} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDFidelityHi}{1.03} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDFidelityP}{0.004} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDFidelityN}{24} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDUsefulnessDiff}{+0.25} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDUsefulnessLo}{-0.03} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDUsefulnessHi}{0.66} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDUsefulnessP}{0.109} \newcommand{\bmHEvsDUsefulnessN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsAClarityDiff}{-0.04} \newcommand{\bmEvsAClarityLo}{-0.41} \newcommand{\bmEvsAClarityHi}{0.28} \newcommand{\bmEvsAClarityP}{0.781} \newcommand{\bmEvsAClarityN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsAArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.92} \newcommand{\bmEvsAArgumentLogicLo}{0.41} \newcommand{\bmEvsAArgumentLogicHi}{1.44} \newcommand{\bmEvsAArgumentLogicP}{0.004} \newcommand{\bmEvsAArgumentLogicN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsAContributionPositioningDiff}{+0.50} \newcommand{\bmEvsAContributionPositioningLo}{0.12} \newcommand{\bmEvsAContributionPositioningHi}{0.91} \newcommand{\bmEvsAContributionPositioningP}{0.056} \newcommand{\bmEvsAContributionPositioningN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsAMethodologicalRigorDiff}{+2.04} \newcommand{\bmEvsAMethodologicalRigorLo}{1.44} \newcommand{\bmEvsAMethodologicalRigorHi}{2.62} \newcommand{\bmEvsAMethodologicalRigorP}{0.000} \newcommand{\bmEvsAMethodologicalRigorN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsAFidelityDiff}{+0.42} \newcommand{\bmEvsAFidelityLo}{0.16} \newcommand{\bmEvsAFidelityHi}{0.78} \newcommand{\bmEvsAFidelityP}{0.050} \newcommand{\bmEvsAFidelityN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsAUsefulnessDiff}{+0.46} \newcommand{\bmEvsAUsefulnessLo}{-0.09} \newcommand{\bmEvsAUsefulnessHi}{1.03} \newcommand{\bmEvsAUsefulnessP}{0.167} \newcommand{\bmEvsAUsefulnessN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsBClarityDiff}{-0.04} \newcommand{\bmEvsBClarityLo}{-0.41} \newcommand{\bmEvsBClarityHi}{0.25} \newcommand{\bmEvsBClarityP}{0.813} \newcommand{\bmEvsBClarityN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsBArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.79} \newcommand{\bmEvsBArgumentLogicLo}{0.41} \newcommand{\bmEvsBArgumentLogicHi}{1.06} \newcommand{\bmEvsBArgumentLogicP}{0.002} \newcommand{\bmEvsBArgumentLogicN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsBContributionPositioningDiff}{+0.25} \newcommand{\bmEvsBContributionPositioningLo}{-0.12} \newcommand{\bmEvsBContributionPositioningHi}{0.69} \newcommand{\bmEvsBContributionPositioningP}{0.544} \newcommand{\bmEvsBContributionPositioningN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsBMethodologicalRigorDiff}{+1.67} \newcommand{\bmEvsBMethodologicalRigorLo}{1.12} \newcommand{\bmEvsBMethodologicalRigorHi}{2.19} \newcommand{\bmEvsBMethodologicalRigorP}{0.001} \newcommand{\bmEvsBMethodologicalRigorN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsBFidelityDiff}{+1.04} \newcommand{\bmEvsBFidelityLo}{0.78} \newcommand{\bmEvsBFidelityHi}{1.44} \newcommand{\bmEvsBFidelityP}{0.001} \newcommand{\bmEvsBFidelityN}{24} \newcommand{\bmEvsBUsefulnessDiff}{+0.42} \newcommand{\bmEvsBUsefulnessLo}{-0.12} \newcommand{\bmEvsBUsefulnessHi}{0.97} \newcommand{\bmEvsBUsefulnessP}{0.359} \newcommand{\bmEvsBUsefulnessN}{24} \newcommand{\bmSecAPreservedRate}{0.199} \newcommand{\bmSecANewNumbers}{1.58} \newcommand{\bmSecANUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecANUnsupportedClaims}{1.17} \newcommand{\bmSecAMaxOverlapShare}{0.041} \newcommand{\bmSecATodoPlaceholders}{12.29} \newcommand{\bmSecANWords}{769.33} \newcommand{\bmSecACostUsd}{0.076} \newcommand{\bmSecALatencyS}{33.67} \newcommand{\bmSecAN}{24.00} \newcommand{\bmSecBPreservedRate}{0.276} \newcommand{\bmSecBNewNumbers}{1.21} \newcommand{\bmSecBNUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecBNUnsupportedClaims}{1.79} \newcommand{\bmSecBMaxOverlapShare}{0.043} \newcommand{\bmSecBTodoPlaceholders}{15.46} \newcommand{\bmSecBNWords}{828.42} \newcommand{\bmSecBCostUsd}{0.081} \newcommand{\bmSecBLatencyS}{36.12} \newcommand{\bmSecBN}{24.00} \newcommand{\bmSecCPreservedRate}{0.244} \newcommand{\bmSecCNewNumbers}{1.46} \newcommand{\bmSecCNUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecCNUnsupportedClaims}{1.50} \newcommand{\bmSecCMaxOverlapShare}{0.033} \newcommand{\bmSecCTodoPlaceholders}{12.62} \newcommand{\bmSecCNWords}{844.62} \newcommand{\bmSecCCostUsd}{0.087} \newcommand{\bmSecCLatencyS}{37.61} \newcommand{\bmSecCN}{24.00} \newcommand{\bmSecDPreservedRate}{0.238} \newcommand{\bmSecDNewNumbers}{1.83} \newcommand{\bmSecDNUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecDNUnsupportedClaims}{1.46} \newcommand{\bmSecDMaxOverlapShare}{0.032} \newcommand{\bmSecDTodoPlaceholders}{12.46} \newcommand{\bmSecDNWords}{847.50} \newcommand{\bmSecDCostUsd}{0.095} \newcommand{\bmSecDLatencyS}{38.20} \newcommand{\bmSecDN}{24.00} \newcommand{\bmSecEPreservedRate}{0.302} \newcommand{\bmSecENewNumbers}{0.71} \newcommand{\bmSecENUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENUnsupportedClaims}{0.88} \newcommand{\bmSecEMaxOverlapShare}{0.048} \newcommand{\bmSecETodoPlaceholders}{12.25} \newcommand{\bmSecENWords}{981.25} \newcommand{\bmSecECostUsd}{0.202} \newcommand{\bmSecELatencyS}{80.06} \newcommand{\bmSecEN}{24.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckPreservedRate}{0.400} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckNewNumbers}{1.94} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckNUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckNUnsupportedClaims}{1.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckMaxOverlapShare}{0.025} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckTodoPlaceholders}{12.88} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckNWords}{909.06} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckCostUsd}{0.197} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckLatencyS}{77.61} \newcommand{\bmSecENoFactcheckN}{16.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfilePreservedRate}{0.364} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileNewNumbers}{0.62} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileNUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileNUnsupportedClaims}{1.12} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileMaxOverlapShare}{0.030} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileTodoPlaceholders}{13.06} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileNWords}{931.50} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileCostUsd}{0.194} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileLatencyS}{77.19} \newcommand{\bmSecENoProfileN}{16.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereePreservedRate}{0.221} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeNewNumbers}{1.44} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeNUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeNUnsupportedClaims}{0.94} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeMaxOverlapShare}{0.041} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeTodoPlaceholders}{12.12} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeNWords}{790.81} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeCostUsd}{0.097} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeLatencyS}{39.50} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRefereeN}{16.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalPreservedRate}{0.305} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalNewNumbers}{0.94} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalNUnverifiableCitations}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalNUnsupportedClaims}{0.75} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalMaxOverlapShare}{0.047} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalTodoPlaceholders}{14.31} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalNWords}{897.94} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalCostUsd}{0.195} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalLatencyS}{78.02} \newcommand{\bmSecENoRetrievalN}{16.00} \newcommand{\bmOverlapMax}{0.360} \newcommand{\bmOverlapBelow}{57} \newcommand{\bmOverlapOtherMax}{0.006} \newcommand{\bmOverlapOtherBelow}{100} \newcommand{\bmOverlapOtherMean}{0.0006} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapDraftIntroduction}{0.018} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapExplainSpecification}{0.012} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapFlagCausalClaims}{0.038} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapImproveAbstract}{0.117} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapImproveTable}{0.035} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapInterpretResults}{0.012} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapRefereeReport}{0.006} \newcommand{\bmSelfOverlapRewriteLiterature}{0.063} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalClarityDiff}{-0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalClarityLo}{-0.38} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalClarityHi}{0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalClarityP}{0.317} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.19} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalArgumentLogicLo}{-0.06} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalArgumentLogicHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalArgumentLogicP}{0.180} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalContributionPositioningDiff}{-0.06} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalContributionPositioningLo}{-0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalContributionPositioningHi}{0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalContributionPositioningP}{0.564} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalMethodologicalRigorDiff}{+0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalMethodologicalRigorLo}{-0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalMethodologicalRigorHi}{0.38} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalMethodologicalRigorP}{0.414} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalFidelityDiff}{+0.06} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalFidelityLo}{-0.31} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalFidelityHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalFidelityP}{0.739} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalUsefulnessDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalUsefulnessLo}{-0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalUsefulnessHi}{0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRetrievalUsefulnessP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileClarityDiff}{-0.19} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileClarityLo}{-0.56} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileClarityHi}{0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileClarityP}{0.317} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.06} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileArgumentLogicLo}{-0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileArgumentLogicHi}{0.38} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileArgumentLogicP}{0.705} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileContributionPositioningDiff}{-0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileContributionPositioningLo}{-0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileContributionPositioningHi}{0.19} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileContributionPositioningP}{0.414} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileMethodologicalRigorDiff}{+0.06} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileMethodologicalRigorLo}{-0.31} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileMethodologicalRigorHi}{0.50} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileMethodologicalRigorP}{0.763} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileFidelityDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileFidelityLo}{-0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileFidelityHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileFidelityP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileUsefulnessDiff}{-0.06} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileUsefulnessLo}{-0.31} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileUsefulnessHi}{0.19} \newcommand{\bmAbENoProfileUsefulnessP}{0.655} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeClarityDiff}{-0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeClarityLo}{-0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeClarityHi}{0.19} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeClarityP}{0.414} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.69} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeArgumentLogicLo}{0.31} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeArgumentLogicHi}{1.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeArgumentLogicP}{0.008} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeContributionPositioningDiff}{+0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeContributionPositioningLo}{-0.06} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeContributionPositioningHi}{0.56} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeContributionPositioningP}{0.157} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeMethodologicalRigorDiff}{+1.62} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeMethodologicalRigorLo}{1.00} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeMethodologicalRigorHi}{2.19} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeMethodologicalRigorP}{0.001} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeFidelityDiff}{+0.50} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeFidelityLo}{0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeFidelityHi}{0.81} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeFidelityP}{0.021} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeUsefulnessDiff}{+0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeUsefulnessLo}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeUsefulnessHi}{0.94} \newcommand{\bmAbENoRefereeUsefulnessP}{0.083} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckClarityDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckClarityLo}{-0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckClarityHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckClarityP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckArgumentLogicDiff}{+0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckArgumentLogicLo}{-0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckArgumentLogicHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckArgumentLogicP}{0.480} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckContributionPositioningDiff}{+0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckContributionPositioningLo}{-0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckContributionPositioningHi}{0.38} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckContributionPositioningP}{0.317} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckMethodologicalRigorDiff}{+0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckMethodologicalRigorLo}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckMethodologicalRigorHi}{0.50} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckMethodologicalRigorP}{0.102} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckFidelityDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckFidelityLo}{-0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckFidelityHi}{0.25} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckFidelityP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckUsefulnessDiff}{+0.12} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckUsefulnessLo}{-0.19} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckUsefulnessHi}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmAbENoFactcheckUsefulnessP}{0.480} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnverifiableCitationsDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnverifiableCitationsLo}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnverifiableCitationsHi}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnverifiableCitationsP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnsupportedClaimsDiff}{-0.29} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnsupportedClaimsLo}{-0.88} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnsupportedClaimsHi}{0.47} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANUnsupportedClaimsP}{0.225} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANewNumbersDiff}{-0.88} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANewNumbersLo}{-1.94} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANewNumbersHi}{-0.03} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsANewNumbersP}{0.041} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnverifiableCitationsDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnverifiableCitationsLo}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnverifiableCitationsHi}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnverifiableCitationsP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnsupportedClaimsDiff}{-0.92} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnsupportedClaimsLo}{-1.69} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnsupportedClaimsHi}{0.12} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNUnsupportedClaimsP}{0.050} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNewNumbersDiff}{-0.50} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNewNumbersLo}{-1.12} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNewNumbersHi}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsBNewNumbersP}{0.084} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnverifiableCitationsDiff}{+0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnverifiableCitationsLo}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnverifiableCitationsHi}{0.00} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnverifiableCitationsP}{1.000} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnsupportedClaimsDiff}{-0.62} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnsupportedClaimsLo}{-1.28} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnsupportedClaimsHi}{0.22} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNUnsupportedClaimsP}{0.072} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNewNumbersDiff}{-0.75} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNewNumbersLo}{-1.34} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNewNumbersHi}{-0.25} \newcommand{\bmHFourEvsCNewNumbersP}{0.026} \newcommand{\bmOodAClarity}{5.67} \newcommand{\bmOodAArgumentLogic}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodAContributionPositioning}{3.67} \newcommand{\bmOodAMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmOodAFidelity}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodAUsefulness}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmOodBClarity}{5.67} \newcommand{\bmOodBArgumentLogic}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodBContributionPositioning}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmOodBMethodologicalRigor}{3.67} \newcommand{\bmOodBFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmOodBUsefulness}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmOodCClarity}{6.33} \newcommand{\bmOodCArgumentLogic}{5.67} \newcommand{\bmOodCContributionPositioning}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodCMethodologicalRigor}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmOodCFidelity}{4.67} \newcommand{\bmOodCUsefulness}{5.67} \newcommand{\bmOodDClarity}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodDArgumentLogic}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodDContributionPositioning}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmOodDMethodologicalRigor}{4.33} \newcommand{\bmOodDFidelity}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodDUsefulness}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmOodEClarity}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodEArgumentLogic}{5.33} \newcommand{\bmOodEContributionPositioning}{3.67} \newcommand{\bmOodEMethodologicalRigor}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmOodEFidelity}{4.67} \newcommand{\bmOodEUsefulness}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmJudgeRhoClarity}{0.71} \newcommand{\bmJudgeMadClarity}{0.18} \newcommand{\bmJudgeRhoArgumentLogic}{0.60} \newcommand{\bmJudgeMadArgumentLogic}{0.38} \newcommand{\bmJudgeRhoContributionPositioning}{0.91} \newcommand{\bmJudgeMadContributionPositioning}{0.30} \newcommand{\bmJudgeRhoMethodologicalRigor}{0.89} \newcommand{\bmJudgeMadMethodologicalRigor}{0.28} \newcommand{\bmJudgeRhoFidelity}{0.74} \newcommand{\bmJudgeMadFidelity}{0.44} \newcommand{\bmJudgeRhoUsefulness}{0.82} \newcommand{\bmJudgeMadUsefulness}{0.24} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionAClarity}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionAArgumentLogic}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionAContributionPositioning}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionAMethodologicalRigor}{4.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionAFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionAUsefulness}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionBClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionBArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionBContributionPositioning}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionBMethodologicalRigor}{4.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionBFidelity}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionBUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionCClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionCArgumentLogic}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionCContributionPositioning}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionCMethodologicalRigor}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionCFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionCUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionDClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionDArgumentLogic}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionDContributionPositioning}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionDMethodologicalRigor}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionDFidelity}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionDUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionEClarity}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionEArgumentLogic}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionEContributionPositioning}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionEMethodologicalRigor}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionEFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskDraftIntroductionEUsefulness}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationAClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationAArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationAContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationAMethodologicalRigor}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationAFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationAUsefulness}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationBClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationBArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationBContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationBMethodologicalRigor}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationBFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationBUsefulness}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationCClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationCArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationCContributionPositioning}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationCMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationCFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationCUsefulness}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationDClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationDArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationDContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationDMethodologicalRigor}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationDFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationDUsefulness}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationEClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationEArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationEContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationEMethodologicalRigor}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationEFidelity}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskExplainSpecificationEUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsAClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsAArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsAContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsAMethodologicalRigor}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsAFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsAUsefulness}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsBClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsBArgumentLogic}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsBContributionPositioning}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsBMethodologicalRigor}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsBFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsBUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsCClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsCArgumentLogic}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsCContributionPositioning}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsCMethodologicalRigor}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsCFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsCUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsDClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsDArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsDContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsDMethodologicalRigor}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsDFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsDUsefulness}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsEClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsEArgumentLogic}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsEContributionPositioning}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsEMethodologicalRigor}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsEFidelity}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskFlagCausalClaimsEUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractAClarity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractAArgumentLogic}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractAContributionPositioning}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractAMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractAFidelity}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractAUsefulness}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractBClarity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractBArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractBContributionPositioning}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractBMethodologicalRigor}{4.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractBFidelity}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractBUsefulness}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractCClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractCArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractCContributionPositioning}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractCMethodologicalRigor}{4.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractCFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractCUsefulness}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractDClarity}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractDArgumentLogic}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractDContributionPositioning}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractDMethodologicalRigor}{4.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractDFidelity}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractDUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractEClarity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractEArgumentLogic}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractEContributionPositioning}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractEMethodologicalRigor}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractEFidelity}{6.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveAbstractEUsefulness}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableAClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableAArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableAContributionPositioning}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableAMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableAFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableAUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableBClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableBArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableBContributionPositioning}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableBMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableBFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableBUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableCClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableCArgumentLogic}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableCContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableCMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableCFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableCUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableDClarity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableDArgumentLogic}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableDContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableDMethodologicalRigor}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableDFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableDUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableEClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableEArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableEContributionPositioning}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableEMethodologicalRigor}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableEFidelity}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskImproveTableEUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsAClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsAArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsAContributionPositioning}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsAMethodologicalRigor}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsAFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsAUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsBClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsBArgumentLogic}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsBContributionPositioning}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsBMethodologicalRigor}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsBFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsBUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsCClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsCArgumentLogic}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsCContributionPositioning}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsCMethodologicalRigor}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsCFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsCUsefulness}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsDClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsDArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsDContributionPositioning}{4.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsDMethodologicalRigor}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsDFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsDUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsEClarity}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsEArgumentLogic}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsEContributionPositioning}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsEMethodologicalRigor}{6.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsEFidelity}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskInterpretResultsEUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportAClarity}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportAArgumentLogic}{4.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportAContributionPositioning}{3.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportAMethodologicalRigor}{3.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportAFidelity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportAUsefulness}{3.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportBClarity}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportBArgumentLogic}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportBContributionPositioning}{3.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportBMethodologicalRigor}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportBFidelity}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportBUsefulness}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportCClarity}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportCArgumentLogic}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportCContributionPositioning}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportCMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportCFidelity}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportCUsefulness}{3.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportDClarity}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportDArgumentLogic}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportDContributionPositioning}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportDMethodologicalRigor}{5.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportDFidelity}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportDUsefulness}{5.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportEClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportEArgumentLogic}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportEContributionPositioning}{4.75} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportEMethodologicalRigor}{6.25} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportEFidelity}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRefereeReportEUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureAClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureAArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureAContributionPositioning}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureAMethodologicalRigor}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureAFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureAUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureBClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureBArgumentLogic}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureBContributionPositioning}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureBMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureBFidelity}{3.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureBUsefulness}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureCClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureCArgumentLogic}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureCContributionPositioning}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureCMethodologicalRigor}{4.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureCFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureCUsefulness}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureDClarity}{6.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureDArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureDContributionPositioning}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureDMethodologicalRigor}{4.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureDFidelity}{5.00} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureDUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureEClarity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureEArgumentLogic}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureEContributionPositioning}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureEMethodologicalRigor}{6.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureEFidelity}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmTaskRewriteLiteratureEUsefulness}{5.50} \newcommand{\bmJudgePairs}{50} \newcommand{\bmJudgeMAD}{0.30}