spb/wp11_uqo

1model,mdape,ci_lo,ci_hi,boot_se,diff_vs_ref,diff_lo,diff_hi,diff_vs_d4,diff_d4_lo,diff_d4_hi,dm_ape_vs_a6_t,dm_ape_vs_a6_p,dm_ape_vs_a6_diff,dm_sqlog_vs_a6_t,dm_sqlog_vs_a6_p,dm_sqlog_vs_a6_diff,dm_ape_vs_d4_t,dm_ape_vs_d4_p,dm_ape_vs_d4_diff,dm_sqlog_vs_d4_t,dm_sqlog_vs_d4_p,dm_sqlog_vs_d4_diff,n_clusters2A1 Linear (levels),18.247735441468322,16.9113510560629,19.60250248921421,0.6798156719309989,0.6261197244962204,0.13177818927938997,1.1288670458109282,3.8594347603829835,2.3810890282818233,5.572402821114919,12.297632954401742,0.0,0.04763272174323981,7.51790454474203,5.573319583618286e-14,0.03800362499584921,10.403881445314044,0.0,0.077883337364094,11.88110067074241,0.0,0.05565758751930701,10913A2 Semi-log,19.034569938583708,17.948468947394765,20.177409718978527,0.5933974925595471,1.4129542216116064,1.0925363990812282,1.8335429697484,4.6462692574983695,3.410686792542463,6.182775708649027,10.174542669661014,0.0,0.01868639690108518,8.898715388706915,0.0,0.014651037656963798,5.814778194584789,6.071433578114238e-09,0.04893701252193937,4.763341767974322,1.9041293313204477e-06,0.03230500018042161,10914A3 Log-log,18.00422814105048,17.07752319183666,18.977226098783678,0.5097956635710524,0.3826124240783777,0.28563151196801645,0.48671649465618905,3.6159274599651408,2.268004875035067,5.04018984221415,4.640377326082088,3.477735786239222e-06,0.0045275418294466125,3.28780657498537,0.001009711859182305,0.0034236450171746756,3.7605346164843136,0.00016955060891321594,0.034778157450300794,3.1024469169219993,0.0019192796548725966,0.02107760754063249,10915A4 Box-Cox,18.567718342220903,17.46589758655213,19.707557217076772,0.5895493292913278,0.9461026252488018,0.6659357616138547,1.3168750827110465,4.179417661135565,2.9293738028577057,5.753351071060692,10.694909755887176,0.0,0.02209720357737525,10.463728364076685,0.0,0.014164675553688949,6.2558305116106006,3.954059302202495e-10,0.05234781919822943,5.180699999292202,2.2105477048839361e-07,0.03181863807714676,10916A5 Semi-log + quadratics,19.15743025152905,18.201941036517315,20.15445926287562,0.5026923733244107,1.5358145345569483,1.1398198349247033,2.1391093582834935,4.769129570443711,3.684746880089903,5.930644511229821,5.530637638741666,3.190688269150144e-08,0.020611399936517463,6.846564545749681,7.564393555981042e-12,0.014815415541661218,8.696091789215284,0.0,0.050862015557371645,7.103680897159478,1.2148060335448463e-12,0.03246937806511903,10917A6 Semi-log + splines,17.6216157169721,16.733927881204792,18.583767461456866,0.4920101568426174,,,,3.233315035886763,1.8746102788184382,4.657062294398633,,,,,,,3.5997911983137305,0.0003184728086869093,0.030250615620854186,3.021002919921985,0.002519389304698194,0.017653962523457807,10918B1 No time effects,22.038141454991422,21.08712269256635,23.267211253160106,0.5612291624566031,4.41652573801932,3.4200841630827816,5.582948377502827,7.649840773906083,6.748344719706512,8.338009838204949,8.206346390560523,2.220446049250313e-16,0.05102875894811877,7.860550382221196,3.774758283725532e-15,0.035094269474690284,19.848983759841108,0.0,0.08127937456897295,17.415570392509096,0.0,0.0527482319981481,10919B2 Year FE,19.12497097548873,18.135266091728134,20.16483252720224,0.5420996135180365,1.5033552585166277,1.0652509808425514,2.1819410747332237,4.736670294403391,3.6133353152983663,5.9326990304884655,6.124427672343136,9.101013276335834e-10,0.021186535000105613,7.1455155771433745,8.966161146872764e-13,0.015029091960441074,8.76902162424838,0.0,0.0514371506209598,7.29281506461723,3.035349749325178e-13,0.03268305448389889,109110B3 Quarter FE,19.15743025152905,18.201941036517315,20.15445926287562,0.5026923733244107,1.5358145345569483,1.1398198349247033,2.1391093582834935,4.769129570443711,3.684746880089903,5.930644511229821,5.530637638741666,3.190688269150144e-08,0.020611399936517463,6.846564545749681,7.564393555981042e-12,0.014815415541661218,8.696091789215284,0.0,0.050862015557371645,7.103680897159478,1.2148060335448463e-12,0.03246937806511903,109111B4 Month FE,19.342062726308214,18.41666765136561,20.381917170225584,0.5186977109248657,1.7204470093361124,1.2291247555472724,2.4534949420758574,4.953762045222875,3.8934157966761633,6.07316437462031,5.731933731822563,9.929206790104672e-09,0.02226419942360097,6.544042648781664,5.987765838710857e-11,0.0159157064518399,9.414342745938619,0.0,0.052514815044455154,7.726539400085093,1.1102230246251565e-14,0.033569668975297715,109112C1 No spatial controls,28.785665634746415,27.341346218160815,30.074976710188,0.7025099701791481,11.164049917774314,10.142872490107974,12.280345112224204,14.397364953661077,12.691537820133453,15.890935706600027,7.742609666008332,9.769962616701378e-15,0.12949228285346864,15.131594441078725,0.0,0.09526765737788669,14.938137987865796,0.0,0.15974289847432283,13.859739811417462,0.0,0.1129216199013445,109113C2 Municipality FE,19.15743025152905,18.201941036517315,20.15445926287562,0.5026923733244107,1.5358145345569483,1.1398198349247033,2.1391093582834935,4.769129570443711,3.684746880089903,5.930644511229821,5.530637638741666,3.190688269150144e-08,0.020611399936517463,6.846564545749681,7.564393555981042e-12,0.014815415541661218,8.696091789215284,0.0,0.050862015557371645,7.103680897159478,1.2148060335448463e-12,0.03246937806511903,109114C3 Grid-cell FE (~5.5 km),18.703553400119855,17.78729355112193,20.032142200057542,0.5678254955514357,1.0819376831477534,0.21901537947672517,2.308285560296583,4.3152527190345165,3.6452950369483923,5.089221243343746,2.5295453955100333,0.011421039859825566,0.01666467803275125,2.356369638453933,0.01845454380735978,0.01122317526639169,14.03126557996909,0.0,0.04691529365360543,13.706499864516653,0.0,0.0288771377898495,109115C4 Grid-cell FE (~1.1 km),20.962941599826827,20.085903076339296,21.854065484343828,0.4556213754459016,3.3413258828547256,2.8904906643605672,3.837012817774882,6.574640918741489,5.336615577939174,7.744405878759988,6.7530133957275,1.4480638910185917e-11,0.04779978332772806,7.5711644369648194,3.68594044175552e-14,0.03167663823611381,13.14987798988361,0.0,0.07805039894858226,12.025634909259105,0.0,0.049330600759571616,109116D1 OLS (muni + month FE),19.342062726308214,18.41666765136561,20.381917170225584,0.5186977109248657,1.7204470093361124,1.2291247555472724,2.4534949420758574,4.953762045222875,3.8934157966761633,6.07316437462031,5.731933731822563,9.929206790104672e-09,0.02226419942360097,6.544042648781664,5.987765838710857e-11,0.0159157064518399,9.414342745938619,0.0,0.052514815044455154,7.726539400085093,1.1102230246251565e-14,0.033569668975297715,109117D2 Ridge (cross-validated),17.684559394393904,16.768330917331383,18.6836218961783,0.5035043504152524,0.06294367742180285,-0.01676159248276264,0.1637807429146053,3.296258713308566,1.9811849496440535,4.724217428807863,2.6118019768463383,0.009006640622825302,0.0008263883012749337,2.7683584874087472,0.005633944669363622,0.0008061328148040056,3.6535115239679725,0.0002586781730240517,0.03107700392212912,3.060857865195947,0.002207038376347503,0.018460095338261817,109118D3 Random forest,14.62750218203232,13.737999221508268,16.19555708116927,0.6178221405912262,-2.994113534939782,-4.555739590156278,-1.4648756603277908,0.23920150094698123,0.0513885363794455,0.4588555165642077,-2.85524195730287,0.00430040529118747,-0.02609601208993448,-2.205886325821924,0.027391959893569684,-0.01386385906749741,4.672835254507822,2.970700491378153e-06,0.004154603530919706,6.693591526753016,2.177591440499782e-11,0.003790103455960403,109119D4 Gradient boosting,14.388300681085338,13.681350877219709,15.743536219678433,0.5263969787549507,-3.233315035886763,-4.657062294398633,-1.8746102788184382,,,,-3.5997911983137305,0.0003184728086869093,-0.030250615620854186,-3.021002919921985,0.002519389304698194,-0.017653962523457807,,,,,,,109120"D5 Gradient boosting, no coordinates",23.225090677534933,22.138529223958216,25.069137709119865,0.7566123985799357,5.603474960562831,3.9352537791374327,7.507040455957043,8.836789996449594,8.10748542572112,9.787971484731155,4.50536824487449,6.625793987247164e-06,0.07508482201019637,6.433439358856359,1.2474843380516631e-10,0.055325835758930006,10.594870291718431,0.0,0.10533543763105055,16.137980864260527,0.0,0.07297979828238782,109121D6 Spatial k-NN comparables,21.18226600985226,19.390028219965146,23.548071796694504,1.100889921651293,3.560650292880158,0.9519338843862455,5.8622156243977095,6.793965328766921,5.527326690571327,8.03181255741793,4.798111691143396,1.6016846118294126e-06,0.05941141294092833,5.960580367571443,2.513436569984151e-09,0.05253224987539075,19.297132345753973,0.0,0.08966202856178251,20.248240203175722,0.0,0.07018621239884855,109122