spb/wp20_uqo

1# Final checklist — WP20 (2026-10-20)23## Completed45- [x] Gate 1 — repository/data audit: `docs/implementation_audit.md` (Vrai Prix data substrate verified from local copies; no inspectable cost-approach component; style audit reused from WP18).6- [x] Gate 2 — literature: 104 references verified against Crossref/arXiv (`docs/verification/`), `paper/references.bib` generated, `docs/literature_matrix.csv`, synthesis in `paper/sections/literature.tex` (gap stated as a positioning claim).7- [x] Gate 3 — theory: cost identity with scope statements, five evidence classes, aggregation/reconciliation rules, schedule mapping, depreciation, uncertainty taxonomy, two propositions with proofs (`framework.tex`, appendix).8- [x] Gate 4 — implementation: `src/` modules, `configs/`, `Makefile`, 10 unit tests passing, raw responses persisted, prompts/schemas/models versioned.9- [x] Gate 5 — experiments: 14 of 16 pre-registered experiments executed (`docs/experiment_plan.md`); outputs in `results/` with `manifest.json`; cluster bootstrap; geographic hold-out; MNAR analysis and simulation; Monte Carlo; recorded-sales test.10- [x] Gate 6 — manuscript: `paper/main.pdf` compiled with latexmk (UQO WP template, No. 20), 15 vector figures, 23 generated table fragments, ≈ 1,180 numeric macros; no undefined references or citations.11- [x] Gate 7 — integrity: `docs/results_validation.md` (independent recomputation of headline numbers), citation metadata verified, numbers traceable to result files.12- [x] Data rights: `docs/data_rights.md`; robots-disallowing host excluded (R10); prices/assessments masked; no image stored or reproduced.13- [x] Research log: `docs/research_log.md` (decisions, evidence, spend ≈ US$98–110).1415## Blocked (external access) — stated in the manuscript1617- [ ] Vrai Prix production repository (`M3U96a`) and `cost.db` not re-inspected: laptop off the cluster LAN, Tailscale logged out → described from local copies and internal notes only.18- [x] spbgit remote `wp20_uqo.git` created and `main` pushed on 2026-10-20 via the BHS64 tunnel (M1M32 = 10.67.0.2).19- [ ] MEFQ Part 3E (cost method schedules) full text not retrieved; OEAQ standards edition not confirmed; Altus guide itself gated (secondary source used).20- [ ] Human expert annotations: no raters available in-session → protocol written (`docs/annotation_protocol.md`), Experiments 4 and 16 marked not feasible; substitutes (cross-extractor agreement; review-load analysis) reported.21- [ ] Opus 5.5 image batch (1,994 requests) still processing at the time of writing; Opus text batch collected. The pipeline is tier-dynamic: `make collect aggregate experiments figures tables paper` will incorporate it (version 1.1).2223## Proposed (future work, not done)2425- Expert annotation study (300 listings, 3 raters, α/κ/ICC, adjudication) and human-in-the-loop gain measurement.26- Depreciation schedule estimated (condition-driven, slower than straight-line) against assessor values and transactions with explicit error models.27- Professional cost manual (MEFQ 3E or licensed) replacing the two industry anchors; measured regional levels.28- Economic model of sellers' photograph selection from the room-by-position evidence.29- Cross-family extractor comparison and conformal calibration of intervals once a labelled calibration set exists.30