SPB Git

spb/wp29_uqo

Public
2.4 KB · 10 lines json
1[2 {"id":"C1","text":"Table 6 prints a 5 km ATT of -0.431 (**) with clustered SE 0.210, 3 km ATT -0.283 (SE 0.279), and 17,250 observations at 5 km.","results_keys":["dcr_att_5km","dcr_att_5km_se","dcr_att_3km","dcr_att_3km_se","dcr_obs_5km"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Appendix Table A19 prints SE 0.218 for the same estimate; Table 6 used as required."},3 {"id":"C2","text":"Table 7 prints narcotics 3 km ATT 0.549 (SE 0.187), fatal 1 km ATT -1.207 (SE 0.137), HIV 5 km ATT -0.340 (SE 0.294).","results_keys":["dcr_narcotics_att_3km","dcr_narcotics_att_3km_se","dcr_fatal_att_1km","dcr_fatal_att_1km_se","dcr_hiv_att_5km","dcr_hiv_att_5km_se"],"status":"supported","caveat":"JSON drops trailing zeros (-0.34 = -0.340)."},4 {"id":"C3","text":"The HIV 5 km ATT carries no significance star (not significant at 10%) and its exact p-value is not reported in the extract.","results_keys":["dcr_hiv_att_5km_significant_10pct","dcr_hiv_att_5km_p_value"],"status":"supported","caveat":"p-value left null rather than computed under a normality assumption."},5 {"id":"C4","text":"Derived 95% CI for the Table 6 5 km ATT under a normal 1.96 convention is [-0.8426, -0.0194].","results_keys":["dcr_att_5km_ci_low","dcr_att_5km_ci_high","derivation_notes"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Derived, not printed; assumes asymptotic normality and the Table 6 SE."},6 {"id":"C5","text":"RESEA Table 2 prints a wage ATE of $1,153 with 95% CI [166, 2,141], a control mean wage of $33,043, a reemployment ATE of 1.47 pp, and a weeks-on-UI ATE of -1.99 with CI [-2.24, -1.75].","results_keys":["ri_wage_ate","ri_wage_ate_ci_low","ri_wage_ate_ci_high","ri_control_mean_wage","ri_reemployment_ate_pp","ri_weeks_ui_ate","ri_weeks_ui_ate_ci_low","ri_weeks_ui_ate_ci_high"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Table 2 layout was re-set by the extract editor."},7 {"id":"C6","text":"No SE is printed for the wage ATE; the SE implied by the printed 95% CI with critical value 1.96 is 503.83 USD/yr.","results_keys":["ri_wage_ate_se_reported","ri_wage_ate_se_derived","derivation_notes"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Assumes a symmetric Wald interval; consistent with the printed p=0.022."},8 {"id":"C7","text":"The inputs contain internal inconsistencies (Table 6 vs A19 SE; 608 vs 640 controls; abstract vs text percentages; unsigned CI in text; rendering defect) that do not change any extracted value.","results_keys":["data_issues"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Inconsistencies flagged, not resolved."}9]10
Files · 4f59ed568641ceda6f39552d5cc3a441aa812088
Menu

Theme