SPB Git

spb/wp29_uqo

Public
2.0 KB · 11 lines json
1[2 {"id":"C1","text":"A1 (5 km overall ATT −0.431, SE 0.210, significant at 5%, −35.0%) is supported by Table 6 of arxiv-2609.27732v1.","results_keys":["verdicts","locators","reasons","computation_details"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Table A19 prints SE 0.218 for the same estimate; significance at 5% still holds with 1.96."},3 {"id":"C2","text":"A2 is not supported: the 1 km HIV ATT in Table 7 is +0.063, not −0.063.","results_keys":["verdicts","locators","reasons"],"status":"supported","caveat":""},4 {"id":"C3","text":"A3 is not supported: a 3 km ATT of −0.283 implies a −24.7% change, not 28.3%.","results_keys":["verdicts","locators","reasons","computation_details"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Relies on the 100(exp(b)−1) convention, which the source itself uses."},5 {"id":"C4","text":"A4 is not supported: the 95% CI for the 5 km hepatitis ATT is [−0.896, 0.084] and includes zero.","results_keys":["verdicts","locators","reasons","computation_details"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Holds for critical values 1.96 or 2.0; would flip only below 1.624."},6 {"id":"C5","text":"A5 (larger reduction for men than for women) is not assessable because the DCR extract reports no results by sex.","results_keys":["verdicts","locators","reasons"],"status":"supported","caveat":"Relative to the extract only."},7 {"id":"C6","text":"A6 (RESEA ATE −1.99 weeks on UI, 95% CI [−2.24, −1.75], 11.5% of the 17.3-week control mean) is supported by Table 2 of arxiv-2606.14621v1.","results_keys":["verdicts","locators","reasons","computation_details"],"status":"supported","caveat":""},8 {"id":"C7","text":"Overall, 2 assertions are supported, 3 not supported and 1 not assessable, out of 6 assessed.","results_keys":["n_supported","n_not_supported","n_not_assessable","n_analysed"],"status":"supported","caveat":""},9 {"id":"C8","text":"The inputs contain six minor issues (rendering defects and internal inconsistencies of the sources), none of which decides a verdict.","results_keys":["data_issues"],"status":"supported","caveat":""}10]11
Files · main
Menu

Theme