1{2 "critical_violations": [3 {4 "description": "reported printed values must appear in the extract",5 "evidence": {6 "employment_change_sep2026_persons": -68000,7 "unemployment_rate_sep2026": 6.58 },9 "id": "fab_numbers",10 "type": "fabrication"11 }12 ],13 "evaluated_utc": "2026-10-30T03:49:27.787733+00:00",14 "evaluator_version": "F4-engine/1.0/F4-dev-01/1.0",15 "notes": "Deterministic oracle-driven evaluation (designer-extracted references with locators). Reproducibility is filled by the harness.",16 "oracle_sha256": "28a846fcd7b57206bfabb942b883d31be57a89d2318779455fb6d4e4d86acc79",17 "quality_components": {18 "baseline": 1.0,19 "correctness": 1.0,20 "integrity": 0.0,21 "reporting": 1.0,22 "reproducibility": 1.023 },24 "quality_score": 0.8,25 "receipt_sha256": "7d5702170e7a8ba22813485b21b6eac1eade550ffbfcf9eb1fc063966670174a",26 "required_criteria": [27 {28 "description": "Unemployment rate September 2026 = 6.5 (as printed in 'Highlights' and 'Unemployment rate increases to 6.5%')",29 "expected": {30 "unemployment_rate_sep2026": 6.531 },32 "id": "unemployment_rate",33 "observed": {34 "unemployment_rate_sep2026": 6.535 },36 "passed": true,37 "tolerance": {38 "unemployment_rate_sep2026": {39 "abs": 0.040 }41 }42 },43 {44 "description": "Monthly employment change = -68000 persons (as printed)",45 "expected": {46 "employment_change_sep2026_persons": -6800047 },48 "id": "employment_change",49 "observed": {50 "employment_change_sep2026_persons": -6800051 },52 "passed": true,53 "tolerance": {54 "employment_change_sep2026_persons": {55 "abs": 056 }57 }58 },59 {60 "description": "Locators name a section of the release in which the figure appears",61 "expected": "Highlights|Unemployment rate increases|Employment falls for second consecutive month",62 "id": "locators_name_sections",63 "observed": {64 "locators.employment_change_sep2026_persons": "statcan-daily-lfs-2026-09 | section \"Highlights\"",65 "locators.unemployment_rate_sep2026": "statcan-daily-lfs-2026-09 | section \"Highlights\""66 },67 "passed": true,68 "tolerance": null69 },70 {71 "description": "Assertion is not supported: the release states the core-aged men's unemployment rate FELL 0.2 points to 5.8% (women part is correct)",72 "expected": {73 "assertion_verdict": "not_supported"74 },75 "id": "assertion_verdict",76 "observed": {77 "assertion_verdict": "not_supported"78 },79 "passed": true,80 "tolerance": null81 },82 {83 "description": "Assertion locator names the section 'Unemployment rate up for core-aged women'",84 "expected": "core-aged women",85 "id": "assertion_locator",86 "observed": {87 "assertion_locator": "statcan-daily-lfs-2026-09 | section \"Unemployment rate up for core-aged women\""88 },89 "passed": true,90 "tolerance": null91 }92 ],93 "run_id": "RP0003",94 "schema_error": "",95 "schema_valid": true,96 "scientific_success": false,97 "task_id": "F4-dev-01"98}