1{2 "runs_main": 6048,3 "runs_ablation": 584,4 "cells_main": 756,5 "seeds": 8,6 "paired_vs_none": [7 {8 "regime": "norms",9 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,10 "n_pairs": 864,11 "share_lower_bits_per_success": 0.9965,12 "share_lower_bits_incl_setup": 0.0,13 "share_higher_success": 0.9931,14 "share_higher_welfare": 0.9005,15 "mean_d_bits_per_success": -5.4536,16 "mean_d_success": 0.0315,17 "mean_d_welfare": 1.512718 },19 {20 "regime": "records",21 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,22 "n_pairs": 864,23 "share_lower_bits_per_success": 0.7118,24 "share_lower_bits_incl_setup": 0.5,25 "share_higher_success": 1.0,26 "share_higher_welfare": 1.0,27 "mean_d_bits_per_success": -43.5683,28 "mean_d_success": 0.4343,29 "mean_d_welfare": 25.670530 },31 {32 "regime": "central",33 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,34 "n_pairs": 864,35 "share_lower_bits_per_success": 0.0046,36 "share_lower_bits_incl_setup": 0.0,37 "share_higher_success": 0.0069,38 "share_higher_welfare": 0.0,39 "mean_d_bits_per_success": 145.9244,40 "mean_d_success": -0.4424,41 "mean_d_welfare": -28.015242 },43 {44 "regime": "central",45 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,46 "n_pairs": 864,47 "share_lower_bits_per_success": 0.7176,48 "share_lower_bits_incl_setup": 0.5,49 "share_higher_success": 1.0,50 "share_higher_welfare": 0.5,51 "mean_d_bits_per_success": -43.0953,52 "mean_d_success": 0.414,53 "mean_d_welfare": 11.641154 },55 {56 "regime": "federated",57 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,58 "n_pairs": 864,59 "share_lower_bits_per_success": 0.6134,60 "share_lower_bits_incl_setup": 0.4444,61 "share_higher_success": 0.8333,62 "share_higher_welfare": 0.4699,63 "mean_d_bits_per_success": -28.5584,64 "mean_d_success": 0.2723,65 "mean_d_welfare": 4.728266 },67 {68 "regime": "federated",69 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,70 "n_pairs": 864,71 "share_lower_bits_per_success": 0.7176,72 "share_lower_bits_incl_setup": 0.5,73 "share_higher_success": 1.0,74 "share_higher_welfare": 0.5,75 "mean_d_bits_per_success": -43.0953,76 "mean_d_success": 0.414,77 "mean_d_welfare": 11.641178 }79 ],80 "institution_loss_shares": [81 {82 "regime": "central",83 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,84 "welfare_loss": 1.0,85 "bits_loss": 1.0,86 "success_loss": 1.0,87 "n_cells": 10888 },89 {90 "regime": "central",91 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,92 "welfare_loss": 0.5,93 "bits_loss": 0.5,94 "success_loss": 0.0,95 "n_cells": 10896 },97 {98 "regime": "federated",99 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,100 "welfare_loss": 0.5556,101 "bits_loss": 0.5556,102 "success_loss": 0.2222,103 "n_cells": 108104 },105 {106 "regime": "federated",107 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,108 "welfare_loss": 0.5,109 "bits_loss": 0.5,110 "success_loss": 0.0,111 "n_cells": 108112 },113 {114 "regime": "norms",115 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,116 "welfare_loss": 0.0648,117 "bits_loss": 1.0,118 "success_loss": 0.0,119 "n_cells": 108120 },121 {122 "regime": "records",123 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,124 "welfare_loss": 0.0,125 "bits_loss": 0.5,126 "success_loss": 0.0,127 "n_cells": 108128 }129 ],130 "shock_effects": [131 {132 "shock_type": "distribution",133 "regime": "central",134 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,135 "d_success_mean": 0.0,136 "d_success_std": 0.0,137 "d_success_count": 288,138 "d_bits_mean": 0.5233,139 "d_bits_std": 0.5283,140 "d_bits_count": 288,141 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.5149,142 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.5158,143 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288144 },145 {146 "shock_type": "distribution",147 "regime": "central",148 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,149 "d_success_mean": 0.0,150 "d_success_std": 0.0,151 "d_success_count": 288,152 "d_bits_mean": 0.5233,153 "d_bits_std": 0.5283,154 "d_bits_count": 288,155 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.5149,156 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.5158,157 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288158 },159 {160 "shock_type": "distribution",161 "regime": "federated",162 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,163 "d_success_mean": 0.0,164 "d_success_std": 0.0,165 "d_success_count": 288,166 "d_bits_mean": 0.5233,167 "d_bits_std": 0.5283,168 "d_bits_count": 288,169 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.5149,170 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.5158,171 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288172 },173 {174 "shock_type": "distribution",175 "regime": "federated",176 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,177 "d_success_mean": 0.0,178 "d_success_std": 0.0,179 "d_success_count": 288,180 "d_bits_mean": 0.5233,181 "d_bits_std": 0.5283,182 "d_bits_count": 288,183 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.5149,184 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.5158,185 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288186 },187 {188 "shock_type": "distribution",189 "regime": "none",190 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,191 "d_success_mean": 0.0,192 "d_success_std": 0.0,193 "d_success_count": 288,194 "d_bits_mean": 0.0,195 "d_bits_std": 0.0,196 "d_bits_count": 288,197 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.5149,198 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.5158,199 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288200 },201 {202 "shock_type": "distribution",203 "regime": "norms",204 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,205 "d_success_mean": 0.0,206 "d_success_std": 0.0,207 "d_success_count": 288,208 "d_bits_mean": 0.5155,209 "d_bits_std": 0.523,210 "d_bits_count": 288,211 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.5149,212 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.5158,213 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288214 },215 {216 "shock_type": "distribution",217 "regime": "records",218 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,219 "d_success_mean": 0.0,220 "d_success_std": 0.0,221 "d_success_count": 288,222 "d_bits_mean": 0.5245,223 "d_bits_std": 0.5303,224 "d_bits_count": 288,225 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.5149,226 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.5158,227 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288228 },229 {230 "shock_type": "network",231 "regime": "central",232 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,233 "d_success_mean": 0.0,234 "d_success_std": 0.0,235 "d_success_count": 288,236 "d_bits_mean": 0.0116,237 "d_bits_std": 0.1395,238 "d_bits_count": 288,239 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.0,240 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.0,241 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288242 },243 {244 "shock_type": "network",245 "regime": "central",246 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,247 "d_success_mean": -0.0757,248 "d_success_std": 0.0989,249 "d_success_count": 288,250 "d_bits_mean": 0.0116,251 "d_bits_std": 0.1395,252 "d_bits_count": 288,253 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.0,254 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.0,255 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288256 },257 {258 "shock_type": "network",259 "regime": "federated",260 "admin_capacity_ratio": 0.5,261 "d_success_mean": -0.0799,262 "d_success_std": 0.1988,263 "d_success_count": 288,264 "d_bits_mean": 0.0116,265 "d_bits_std": 0.1395,266 "d_bits_count": 288,267 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.0,268 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.0,269 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288270 },271 {272 "shock_type": "network",273 "regime": "federated",274 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,275 "d_success_mean": -0.0757,276 "d_success_std": 0.0989,277 "d_success_count": 288,278 "d_bits_mean": 0.0116,279 "d_bits_std": 0.1395,280 "d_bits_count": 288,281 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.0,282 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.0,283 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288284 },285 {286 "shock_type": "network",287 "regime": "none",288 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,289 "d_success_mean": -0.0038,290 "d_success_std": 0.0181,291 "d_success_count": 288,292 "d_bits_mean": 0.0,293 "d_bits_std": 0.0,294 "d_bits_count": 288,295 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.0,296 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.0,297 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288298 },299 {300 "shock_type": "network",301 "regime": "norms",302 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,303 "d_success_mean": -0.004,304 "d_success_std": 0.0182,305 "d_success_count": 288,306 "d_bits_mean": 0.0013,307 "d_bits_std": 0.1344,308 "d_bits_count": 288,309 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.0,310 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.0,311 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288312 },313 {314 "shock_type": "network",315 "regime": "records",316 "admin_capacity_ratio": 2.0,317 "d_success_mean": -0.0698,318 "d_success_std": 0.0834,319 "d_success_count": 288,320 "d_bits_mean": -0.0028,321 "d_bits_std": 0.1078,322 "d_bits_count": 288,323 "kl_q_p_bits_mean": 0.0,324 "kl_q_p_bits_std": 0.0,325 "kl_q_p_bits_count": 288326 }327 ],328 "ablations": {329 "reference": {330 "central": {331 "success_rate": 1.0,332 "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 28.1329,333 "welfare_per_agent": 44.4486334 },335 "federated": {336 "success_rate": 1.0,337 "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 28.1329,338 "welfare_per_agent": 44.4486339 },340 "none": {341 "success_rate": 0.9178,342 "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 15.2547,343 "welfare_per_agent": 55.0433344 },345 "norms": {346 "success_rate": 0.9603,347 "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 23.7302,348 "welfare_per_agent": 57.2665349 },350 "records": {351 "success_rate": 1.0,352 "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 24.809,353 "welfare_per_agent": 59.3009354 }355 },356 "records_without_verification": {357 "success_rate": 0.9603,358 "bits_per_success_incl_setup": 25.8128,359 "welfare_per_agent": 57.1857360 },361 "norms_adaptation": {362 "0": {363 "d_bits": 0.0349,364 "success_post": 0.9634,365 "kl_q_p_bits": 1.9796366 },367 "10": {368 "d_bits": 1.9173,369 "success_post": 0.9634,370 "kl_q_p_bits": 1.9796371 },372 "1000": {373 "d_bits": 3.7915,374 "success_post": 0.9634,375 "kl_q_p_bits": 1.9796376 }377 },378 "breakeven_norms_wins_bits": {379 "s=16,zipf=0.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false,380 "s=64,zipf=0.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false,381 "s=64,zipf=0.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false,382 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=10,learn=0.0": true,383 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=10,learn=200.0": false,384 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=10,learn=1000.0": false,385 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=40,learn=0.0": true,386 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false,387 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=40,learn=1000.0": false,388 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=160,learn=0.0": true,389 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=160,learn=200.0": false,390 "s=64,zipf=1.0,T=160,learn=1000.0": false,391 "s=64,zipf=1.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false,392 "s=64,zipf=2.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false,393 "s=256,zipf=0.0,T=40,learn=200.0": false,394 "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=10,learn=200.0": false,395 "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=10,learn=1000.0": false,396 "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=40,learn=200.0": false,397 "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=40,learn=1000.0": false,398 "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=160,learn=200.0": true,399 "s=256,zipf=1.5,T=160,learn=1000.0": false400 },401 "heterogeneity_eps": {402 "eps=0.05,none": {403 "success_rate": 0.9835,404 "fail_decode_share": 0.0165405 },406 "eps=0.05,norms": {407 "success_rate": 0.9603,408 "fail_decode_share": 0.0397409 },410 "eps=0.25,none": {411 "success_rate": 0.9178,412 "fail_decode_share": 0.0822413 },414 "eps=0.25,norms": {415 "success_rate": 0.9603,416 "fail_decode_share": 0.0397417 },418 "eps=0.6,none": {419 "success_rate": 0.8077,420 "fail_decode_share": 0.1923421 },422 "eps=0.6,norms": {423 "success_rate": 0.9603,424 "fail_decode_share": 0.0397425 }426 },427 "federated_branching": {428 "4": {429 "success_rate": 1.0,430 "msgs_per_task": 8.8566,431 "root_load_mean": 47.6688432 },433 "8": {434 "success_rate": 1.0,435 "msgs_per_task": 6.6146,436 "root_load_mean": 41.75437 },438 "16": {439 "success_rate": 1.0,440 "msgs_per_task": 6.2688,441 "root_load_mean": 208.3938442 }443 },444 "coding_gain": {445 "s=16,zipf=0.0": {446 "H": 4.0,447 "L_code": 4.0,448 "L_raw": 4.0,449 "bits_per_task": 10.0450 },451 "s=64,zipf=0.0": {452 "H": 6.0,453 "L_code": 6.0,454 "L_raw": 6.0,455 "bits_per_task": 14.0456 },457 "s=64,zipf=0.5": {458 "H": 5.781,459 "L_code": 6.236,460 "L_raw": 6.0,461 "bits_per_task": 14.467462 },463 "s=64,zipf=1.0": {464 "H": 4.864,465 "L_code": 5.443,466 "L_raw": 6.0,467 "bits_per_task": 12.883468 },469 "s=64,zipf=1.5": {470 "H": 3.435,471 "L_code": 4.005,472 "L_raw": 6.0,473 "bits_per_task": 10.013474 },475 "s=64,zipf=2.5": {476 "H": 1.448,477 "L_code": 1.957,478 "L_raw": 6.0,479 "bits_per_task": 5.916480 },481 "s=256,zipf=0.0": {482 "H": 8.0,483 "L_code": 8.0,484 "L_raw": 8.0,485 "bits_per_task": 18.0486 },487 "s=256,zipf=1.5": {488 "H": 3.916,489 "L_code": 4.444,490 "L_raw": 8.0,491 "bits_per_task": 10.89492 }493 }494 },495 "theorem_checks": {496 "T1_code_shorter_than_raw_when_H_le_log2s_minus_1": true,497 "T1_cells_where_code_longer_than_raw": [498 {499 "s": 64,500 "zipf": 0.5,501 "H_p_bits": 5.781,502 "L_code_bits": 6.236,503 "L_raw_bits": 6.0504 }505 ],506 "T1_entropy_le_code_lt_entropy_plus_1": true,507 "T3_post_shock_extra_bits_per_recipient_norms_vs_KL": {508 "mean_extra_bits_per_recipient": 1.895726362235342,509 "mean_KL": 1.979594637192137,510 "within_KL_pm_1": true511 }512 }513}