Human-review checkpoints (protocol §P7) — items awaiting the principal investigator
| Checkpoint | What to review | Where | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| H-0 | Plan, protocol, decisions D1–D7 and amendments A-000–A-002 | RESEARCH_PLAN.md §10, protocol/PROTOCOL.md, protocol/amendments.csv |
pending |
| H-1 | Record-linkage precision sample (500 DBLP↔OpenAlex pairs, 200 reserved for the PI) | data/metadata/linkage_sample.csv (to be generated by systematic_review/linkage_sample.py) |
pending |
| H-2 | Taxonomy validation sample (2,000 works, two LLM raters; 200 for the PI) | taxonomy/validation/ |
pending |
| H-3 | Landmark list (≥ 1,000) and specialist reviews | literature_synthesis/landmarks/ |
pending |
| H-4 | Structural-change results and interpretation (no causal language) | results/econometrics/ |
pending |
| H-5 | Manuscript conclusions | manuscript/ |
pending |
Conclusions that depend on an unsigned checkpoint are labelled "pending human review" in the manuscript.
| H-3 note | 2026-11-03 20:30 | Agent H audit of the first landmark list: SSRN/reprint duplicates (Bitcoin ×3, TLS 1.3 ×2), venue records, 2026 reprints of old papers, misfiled works → landmark selection v2 adds title de-duplication, venue-record and abstract/citation filters (literature_synthesis/landmarks_v1/ keeps the first list) ; PI review still required | | |