1# Generated by `jof250 profiles build` — do not edit by hand (see docs/DATA_DICTIONARY.md)2profile: empirical_all3ontology_version: '1.0'4built:5 timestamp: '2026-11-03T23:29:47+00:00'6 code_version: f8b9e5a-dirty7 host:8 platform: macOS-27.0-arm64-arm-64bit9 python: 3.12.1310 machine: arm6411 node: MacBookPro-de-simon-pierre-2.local12selection_rule: genre in {empirical, mixed_theory_empirical}13n_documents: 17314split: train (heldout_v1 excluded)15caveat: Observed frequencies describe what published JoF articles did in 2017–2020; they are not evidence that these choices16 are editorially superior or required.17structure:18 pages:19 n: 17320 median: 43.021 q25: 39.022 q75: 47.023 mean: 43.12724 min: 25.025 max: 65.026 median_ci95_bootstrap:27 - 42.028 - 44.029 n_words_body:30 n: 17331 median: 11009.032 q25: 10052.033 q75: 12194.034 mean: 11182.8535 min: 6623.036 max: 17025.037 median_ci95_bootstrap:38 - 10813.039 - 11343.2540 n_words_appendix:41 n: 17342 median: 0.043 q25: 0.044 q75: 510.045 mean: 442.56146 min: 0.047 max: 3991.048 median_ci95_bootstrap:49 - 0.050 - 21.051 abstract_words:52 n: 17353 median: 100.054 q25: 96.055 q75: 104.056 mean: 103.97757 min: 49.058 max: 535.059 median_ci95_bootstrap:60 - 100.061 - 101.062 n_sections:63 n: 17364 median: 5.065 q25: 5.066 q75: 6.067 mean: 5.52668 min: 3.069 max: 9.070 median_ci95_bootstrap:71 - 5.072 - 6.073 n_subsections:74 n: 17375 median: 13.076 q25: 10.077 q75: 18.078 mean: 14.32979 min: 0.080 max: 46.081 median_ci95_bootstrap:82 - 13.083 - 14.084 n_paragraphs:85 n: 17386 median: 113.087 q25: 82.088 q75: 174.089 mean: 137.19790 min: 51.091 max: 649.092 median_ci95_bootstrap:93 - 101.47594 - 127.095 n_equations:96 n: 17397 median: 7.098 q25: 2.099 q75: 15.0100 mean: 11.491101 min: 0.0102 max: 78.0103 median_ci95_bootstrap:104 - 6.0105 - 9.0106 n_tables:107 n: 173108 median: 9.0109 q25: 7.0110 q75: 11.0111 mean: 9.347112 min: 0.0113 max: 24.0114 median_ci95_bootstrap:115 - 9.0116 - 10.0117 n_figures:118 n: 173119 median: 4.0120 q25: 2.0121 q75: 6.0122 mean: 4.289123 min: 0.0124 max: 14.0125 median_ci95_bootstrap:126 - 3.0127 - 4.0128 n_footnotes:129 n: 173130 median: 36.0131 q25: 28.0132 q75: 43.0133 mean: 38.035134 min: 10.0135 max: 148.0136 median_ci95_bootstrap:137 - 35.0138 - 38.0139 n_references:140 n: 173141 median: 53.0142 q25: 43.0143 q75: 64.0144 mean: 54.809145 min: 17.0146 max: 122.0147 median_ci95_bootstrap:148 - 50.0149 - 56.0150 n_citations_in_text:151 n: 173152 median: 56.0153 q25: 41.0154 q75: 76.0155 mean: 60.977156 min: 17.0157 max: 181.0158 median_ci95_bootstrap:159 - 51.475160 - 63.0161 intro_words:162 n: 173163 median: 1804.0164 q25: 1588.0165 q75: 2116.0166 mean: 1833.809167 min: 815.0168 max: 2846.0169 median_ci95_bootstrap:170 - 1713.0171 - 1853.0172 intro_paragraphs:173 n: 173174 median: 7.0175 q25: 6.0176 q75: 9.0177 mean: 8.393178 min: 2.0179 max: 64.0180 median_ci95_bootstrap:181 - 7.0182 - 8.0183 intro_share:184 n: 173185 median: 0.165186 q25: 0.143187 q75: 0.191188 mean: 0.167189 min: 0.071190 max: 0.276191 median_ci95_bootstrap:192 - 0.159193 - 0.174194 conclusion_words:195 n: 173196 median: 363.0197 q25: 265.0198 q75: 516.0199 mean: 460.272200 min: 91.0201 max: 3986.0202 median_ci95_bootstrap:203 - 329.0204 - 394.0205 conclusion_share:206 n: 173207 median: 0.033208 q25: 0.024209 q75: 0.047210 mean: 0.043211 min: 0.008212 max: 0.427213 median_ci95_bootstrap:214 - 0.031215 - 0.036216 theory_share:217 n: 173218 median: 0.036219 q25: 0.0220 q75: 0.192221 mean: 0.116222 min: 0.0223 max: 0.714224 median_ci95_bootstrap:225 - 0.0226 - 0.103227 data_share:228 n: 173229 median: 0.076230 q25: 0.0231 q75: 0.133232 mean: 0.09233 min: 0.0234 max: 0.57235 median_ci95_bootstrap:236 - 0.046237 - 0.095238 results_share:239 n: 173240 median: 0.0241 q25: 0.0242 q75: 0.203243 mean: 0.117244 min: 0.0245 max: 0.627246 median_ci95_bootstrap:247 - 0.0248 - 0.0249 robustness_share:250 n: 173251 median: 0.0252 q25: 0.0253 q75: 0.0254 mean: 0.035255 min: 0.0256 max: 0.338257 median_ci95_bootstrap:258 - 0.0259 - 0.0260 words_per_table:261 n: 173262 median: 1197.667263 q25: 957.875264 q75: 1635.667265 mean: 1424.985266 min: 371.917267 max: 13206.0268 median_ci95_bootstrap:269 - 1115.273270 - 1265.25271 refs_per_1000_words:272 n: 173273 median: 4.819274 q25: 3.784275 q75: 5.969276 mean: 4.997277 min: 1.075278 max: 10.145279 median_ci95_bootstrap:280 - 4.6281 - 5.214282 equations_per_1000_words:283 n: 173284 median: 0.608285 q25: 0.224286 q75: 1.439287 mean: 1.018288 min: 0.0289 max: 6.711290 median_ci95_bootstrap:291 - 0.522292 - 0.839293presence:294 has_robustness_section:295 n: 173296 share: 0.243297 has_literature_section:298 n: 173299 share: 0.185300 has_appendix:301 n: 173302 share: 0.428303 has_internet_appendix:304 n: 173305 share: 0.936306by_year:307 2017:308 n: 43309 n_words_body_median: 10952.0310 n_tables_median: 10.0311 2018:312 n: 42313 n_words_body_median: 11392.5314 n_tables_median: 9.5315 2019:316 n: 46317 n_words_body_median: 10853.5318 n_tables_median: 9.0319 2020:320 n: 42321 n_words_body_median: 11062.0322 n_tables_median: 10.0323rhetoric:324 n_annotated: 173325 genre:326 n: 173327 empirical: 0.676328 mixed_theory_empirical: 0.324329 subfield:330 n: 173331 asset_pricing: 0.335332 corporate_finance: 0.162333 household_finance: 0.127334 financial_intermediation_banking: 0.121335 market_microstructure: 0.092336 behavioral_finance: 0.058337 entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity: 0.04338 international_finance: 0.035339 primary_method:340 n: 173341 reduced_form_regression: 0.468342 difference_in_differences: 0.121343 structural_estimation: 0.081344 instrumental_variables: 0.075345 other: 0.052346 theoretical_model_analytical: 0.052347 survey_or_experiment: 0.046348 natural_experiment_event_study: 0.04349 abstract_moves_present:350 question:351 n: 173352 share: 0.717353 gap:354 n: 173355 share: 0.116356 method:357 n: 173358 share: 0.832359 results:360 n: 173361 share: 1.0362 magnitude:363 n: 173364 share: 0.289365 contribution:366 n: 173367 share: 0.647368 abstract_move_order_median_sentence:369 question:370 n: 124371 median: 0.0372 q25: 0.0373 q75: 0.0374 mean: 0.161375 min: 0.0376 max: 3.0377 median_ci95_bootstrap:378 - 0.0379 - 0.0380 gap:381 n: 20382 median: 1.0383 q25: 0.0384 q75: 1.0385 mean: 0.8386 min: 0.0387 max: 4.0388 median_ci95_bootstrap:389 - 0.0390 - 1.0391 method:392 n: 144393 median: 1.0394 q25: 0.0395 q75: 2.0396 mean: 1.069397 min: 0.0398 max: 4.0399 median_ci95_bootstrap:400 - 1.0401 - 1.0402 results:403 n: 173404 median: 1.0405 q25: 1.0406 q75: 2.0407 mean: 1.538408 min: 0.0409 max: 4.0410 median_ci95_bootstrap:411 - 1.0412 - 2.0413 magnitude:414 n: 50415 median: 2.0416 q25: 1.0417 q75: 3.0418 mean: 2.12419 min: 0.0420 max: 5.0421 median_ci95_bootstrap:422 - 2.0423 - 2.262424 contribution:425 n: 112426 median: 3.0427 q25: 1.0428 q75: 4.0429 mean: 2.589430 min: 0.0431 max: 7.0432 median_ci95_bootstrap:433 - 2.0434 - 3.0435 abstract_sentences:436 n: 173437 median: 5.0438 q25: 4.0439 q75: 6.0440 mean: 5.249441 min: 2.0442 max: 16.0443 median_ci95_bootstrap:444 - 5.0445 - 5.0446 magnitude_in_abstract_regex:447 n: 173448 share: 0.197449 introduction:450 paragraphs:451 n: 173452 median: 7.0453 q25: 6.0454 q75: 9.0455 mean: 8.393456 min: 2.0457 max: 64.0458 median_ci95_bootstrap:459 - 7.0460 - 8.0461 words:462 n: 173463 median: 1105.0464 q25: 893.0465 q75: 1325.0466 mean: 1132.249467 min: 446.0468 max: 2771.0469 median_ci95_bootstrap:470 - 1021.9471 - 1166.0472 contribution_paragraph_index:473 n: 165474 median: 4.0475 q25: 1.0476 q75: 6.0477 mean: 4.794478 min: 0.0479 max: 56.0480 median_ci95_bootstrap:481 - 3.0482 - 5.0483 contribution_relative_position:484 n: 165485 median: 0.625486 q25: 0.2487 q75: 0.8488 mean: 0.516489 min: 0.0490 max: 0.941491 median_ci95_bootstrap:492 - 0.571493 - 0.667494 first_move:495 n: 173496 motivation: 0.902497 tension_or_puzzle: 0.023498 preview_of_approach: 0.023499 other: 0.023500 literature_gap: 0.012501 contribution_statement: 0.006502 related_literature_positioning: 0.006503 mechanism_or_theory_sketch: 0.006504 move_prevalence:505 n: 173506 preview_of_results:507 share: 0.983508 median_relative_position: 0.36509 motivation:510 share: 0.948511 median_relative_position: 0.0512 preview_of_approach:513 share: 0.896514 median_relative_position: 0.25515 related_literature_positioning:516 share: 0.873517 median_relative_position: 0.75518 mechanism_or_theory_sketch:519 share: 0.838520 median_relative_position: 0.33521 contribution_statement:522 share: 0.809523 median_relative_position: 0.75524 roadmap:525 share: 0.653526 median_relative_position: 1.0527 literature_gap:528 share: 0.578529 median_relative_position: 0.12530 identification_defense:531 share: 0.543532 median_relative_position: 0.5533 tension_or_puzzle:534 share: 0.497535 median_relative_position: 0.11536 robustness_mention:537 share: 0.341538 median_relative_position: 0.62539 policy_or_broader_implication:540 share: 0.335541 median_relative_position: 0.79542 other:543 share: 0.15544 median_relative_position: 0.7545 moves_per_intro:546 n: 173547 median: 12.0548 q25: 10.0549 q75: 14.0550 mean: 12.127551 min: 7.0552 max: 23.0553 median_ci95_bootstrap:554 - 12.0555 - 12.0556 common_move_sequences:557 n: 173558 ? motivation > preview_of_approach > identification_defense > mechanism_or_theory_sketch > preview_of_approach > preview_of_results559 > robustness_mention > identification_defense > contribution_statement > related_literature_positioning > other >560 policy_or_broader_implication561 : 0.006562 ? motivation > tension_or_puzzle > mechanism_or_theory_sketch > preview_of_results > related_literature_positioning563 > literature_gap > contribution_statement > policy_or_broader_implication > roadmap564 : 0.006565 ? motivation > mechanism_or_theory_sketch > preview_of_results > preview_of_approach > preview_of_results > identification_defense566 > preview_of_results > robustness_mention > related_literature_positioning > contribution_statement567 : 0.006568 ? motivation > policy_or_broader_implication > mechanism_or_theory_sketch > tension_or_puzzle > preview_of_approach569 > preview_of_results > identification_defense > related_literature_positioning > contribution_statement > related_literature_positioning570 : 0.006571 ? motivation > literature_gap > policy_or_broader_implication > preview_of_approach > preview_of_results > robustness_mention572 > preview_of_results > contribution_statement > related_literature_positioning573 : 0.006574 ? tension_or_puzzle > literature_gap > contribution_statement > preview_of_approach > mechanism_or_theory_sketch > identification_defense575 > preview_of_approach > identification_defense > preview_of_results > preview_of_approach > preview_of_results > policy_or_broader_implication576 > related_literature_positioning > roadmap577 : 0.006578 roadmap_present_llm:579 n: 173580 share: 0.653581 roadmap_present_regex:582 n: 173583 share: 0.636584 literature_positioning_location:585 n: 173586 inside_introduction: 0.884587 both: 0.087588 separate_section: 0.023589 none: 0.006590 contribution_types:591 n: 365592 new_evidence: 0.474593 new_data_or_measure: 0.189594 new_theory_or_model: 0.137595 new_identification: 0.099596 resolution_of_puzzle: 0.066597 new_method: 0.036598 identification:599 causal_language_strength:600 n: 173601 median: 3.0602 q25: 2.0603 q75: 4.0604 mean: 2.861605 min: 1.0606 max: 5.0607 median_ci95_bootstrap:608 - 3.0609 - 3.0610 uses_causal_claim:611 n: 173612 share: 0.607613 results:614 economic_significance_discussed:615 n: 173616 share: 0.925617 statistical_language:618 n: 173619 unclear: 0.757620 stars_and_tstats: 0.133621 mixed: 0.081622 p_values: 0.017623 confidence_intervals: 0.012624 magnitude_statements_in_intro:625 n: 173626 share: 0.694627 robustness:628 location:629 n: 173630 mixed: 0.422631 within_results: 0.266632 main_text_section: 0.145633 none_seen: 0.11634 appendix: 0.04635 internet_appendix: 0.017636 types:637 n: 534638 alternative_specification: 0.24639 subsample: 0.187640 alternative_measure: 0.176641 other: 0.155642 alternative_sample_period: 0.064643 placebo: 0.054644 falsification: 0.051645 sensitivity_to_parameters: 0.037646 tables:647 standard_errors:648 n: 173649 unclear: 0.78650 clustered: 0.075651 newey_west: 0.04652 mixed: 0.04653 robust: 0.035654 none: 0.023655 bootstrap: 0.006656 units_in_notes:657 n: 173658 share: 0.803659 clustered_regex:660 n: 173661 share: 0.069662 figures:663 uncertainty_shown:664 n: 173665 unclear: 0.584666 'no': 0.22667 mixed: 0.104668 no_figures: 0.069669 'yes': 0.023670 conclusion:671 bounded_claims:672 n: 173673 share: 0.827674 policy_implications:675 n: 173676 share: 0.358677 open_questions:678 n: 173679 share: 0.393680 hedging:681 n: 173682 moderate: 0.931683 low: 0.069684 claims_with_stated_evidence_share:685 n: 173686 median: 1.0687 q25: 1.0688 q75: 1.0689 mean: 0.989690 min: 0.75691 max: 1.0692 median_ci95_bootstrap:693 - 1.0694 - 1.0695 llm_vs_rule_section_role_agreement:696 n: 173697 median: 1.0698 q25: 0.8699 q75: 1.0700 mean: 0.899701 min: 0.438702 max: 1.0703 median_ci95_bootstrap:704 - 0.9705 - 1.0706 llm_confidence:707 n: 173708 median: 0.8709 q25: 0.8710 q75: 0.82711 mean: 0.809712 min: 0.75713 max: 0.85714 median_ci95_bootstrap:715 - 0.8716 - 0.8717