1doc_id,schema_valid,genre,subfield,primary_method,causal_strength,uses_causal_claim,abs_question,abs_gap,abs_method,abs_results,abs_magnitude,abs_contribution,abs_question_idx,abs_gap_idx,abs_method_idx,abs_results_idx,abs_magnitude_idx,abs_contribution_idx,intro_moves_seq,intro_n_moves,contribution_para_idx,contribution_types,roadmap_llm,roadmap_regex,lit_positioning,econ_signif,stat_lang,magnitude_in_intro,robust_location,robust_types,se_desc,units_in_notes,fig_uncertainty,concl_bounded,concl_policy,concl_open,hedging,n_claims,claims_with_evidence,llm_confidence,abstract_n_sent,intro_n_paragraphs,intro_n_words,magnitude_regex_abstract,contribution_regex_intro,clustered_se_regex,stars_regex,role_agreement,cost_usd,model2jof_12407,True,empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,3,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,10,-1,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,separate_section,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,True,no_figures,False,False,False,low,7,7,0.8,4,6,855,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.06673,claude-opus-5-53jof_12432,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,True,False,True,False,True,1,0,-1,2,-1,1,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,12,11,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|placebo|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no_figures,False,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,14,1227,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.080506,claude-opus-5-54jof_12434,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,2,1,-1,0,motivation|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|other|policy_or_broader_implication,13,7,new_evidence|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|subsample|falsification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,3,9,1304,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.079782,claude-opus-5-55jof_12438,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,14,0,new_data_or_measure|resolution_of_puzzle|new_evidence|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_sample_period,unclear,True,mixed,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,4,8,1290,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.082186,claude-opus-5-56jof_12439,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,2,2,2,0,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,12,0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|falsification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,6,1025,True,True,False,False,0.5,0.066598,claude-opus-5-57jof_12464,True,mixed_theory_empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,3,1,-1,5,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,6,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_specification,mixed,True,no,True,False,True,low,8,8,0.8,8,8,1160,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.107268,claude-opus-5-58jof_12465,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,4,1,-1,-1,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,11,8,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,9,1485,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.073646,claude-opus-5-59jof_12466,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,0,-1,2,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|roadmap,10,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,8,7,0.8,3,6,872,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.075834,claude-opus-5-510jof_12467,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,11,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,6,1076,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07403,claude-opus-5-511jof_12468,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,10,3,new_evidence|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,False,yes,True,False,True,moderate,6,5,0.85,4,4,752,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.062382,claude-opus-5-512jof_12469,True,empirical,household_finance,natural_experiment_event_study,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,1,tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,18,1,new_evidence|new_identification|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|falsification|subsample|other,clustered,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.85,6,15,1483,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.07947,claude-opus-5-513jof_12470,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,survey_or_experiment,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,4,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|other|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,17,0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,13,1529,False,True,False,False,0.6,0.076878,claude-opus-5-514jof_12471,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,3,-1,0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning,11,1,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,main_text_section,alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters|other,newey_west,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,6,6,936,False,True,False,False,0.9,0.086406,claude-opus-5-515jof_12472,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,0,1,2,7,motivation|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|other|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|contribution_statement|roadmap,10,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|subsample|alternative_measure,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.82,8,5,779,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.069414,claude-opus-5-516jof_12473,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,9,3,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,7,1009,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.071746,claude-opus-5-517jof_12482,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,2,-1,4,motivation|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|motivation|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|policy_or_broader_implication,12,0,new_evidence,False,False,both,True,unclear,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,False,True,True,moderate,8,8,0.8,5,6,938,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.080942,claude-opus-5-518jof_12483,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,difference_in_differences,3,True,True,False,False,True,False,False,0,-1,-1,1,-1,-1,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement,10,3,new_evidence,False,False,both,True,unclear,False,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|alternative_measure,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,4,860,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.067506,claude-opus-5-519jof_12484,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,structural_estimation,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,0,contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|literature_gap,8,0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,internet_appendix,alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,5,4,0.8,2,4,752,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.071706,claude-opus-5-520jof_12485,True,empirical,market_microstructure,natural_experiment_event_study,3,True,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,1,-1,3,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement,13,6,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,False,no,False,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,7,1343,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07733,claude-opus-5-521jof_12486,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,2,2,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|other|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,2,new_method|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,False,appendix,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,newey_west,True,mixed,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,12,2034,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.10605,claude-opus-5-522jof_12487,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|roadmap,10,-1,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,False,stars_and_tstats,False,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|placebo|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,3,6,1027,False,False,False,True,0.9,0.084146,claude-opus-5-523jof_12488,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,2,-1,1,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|roadmap,12,0,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,within_results,alternative_specification|subsample,mixed,True,unclear,False,False,True,low,7,6,0.85,3,9,1406,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.076602,claude-opus-5-524jof_12489,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,structural_estimation,3,True,True,True,True,True,True,False,0,1,2,4,3,-1,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,3,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,internet_appendix,sensitivity_to_parameters,none,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,7,1105,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.073518,claude-opus-5-525jof_12490,True,mixed_theory_empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,2,-1,2,3,1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication,14,6,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model,False,False,both,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_specification,unclear,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,8,8,0.8,6,8,1027,True,False,False,False,1.0,0.08025,claude-opus-5-526jof_12492,True,empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,1,2,2,-1,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|other,11,6,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,9,9,0.8,6,12,1457,False,True,False,False,0.667,0.088078,claude-opus-5-527jof_12493,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|motivation|motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,1,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,9,1642,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06903,claude-opus-5-528jof_12494,True,mixed_theory_empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,instrumental_variables,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense,11,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,no,False,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,4,761,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.069382,claude-opus-5-529jof_12495,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,True,True,True,False,False,1,0,1,2,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,1,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_sample_period|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,8,8,0.8,5,7,1049,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.072966,claude-opus-5-530jof_12496,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,2,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,10,2,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,6,800,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.073094,claude-opus-5-531jof_12497,True,mixed_theory_empirical,international_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,1,1,3,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,10,3,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,False,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,4,5,831,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.07177,claude-opus-5-532jof_12498,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,2,2,-1,-1,motivation|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|roadmap,10,45,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.72,6,46,1247,False,True,False,False,0.5,0.062926,claude-opus-5-533jof_12499,True,mixed_theory_empirical,international_finance,natural_experiment_event_study,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,2,0,-1,2,motivation|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,16,6,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_measure|falsification|other|alternative_specification,unclear,True,mixed,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,4,9,1341,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08645,claude-opus-5-534jof_12500,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,3,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,13,1,new_evidence|new_identification|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|sensitivity_to_parameters|other,unclear,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,7,1045,True,True,False,False,0.923,0.073714,claude-opus-5-535jof_12501,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,17,9,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,confidence_intervals,True,appendix,alternative_specification,none,True,yes,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,11,1501,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08133,claude-opus-5-536jof_12504,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,2,1,1,0,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,1,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,False,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters|subsample,unclear,True,no,False,False,True,low,7,7,0.8,5,11,1440,True,True,False,False,0.778,0.09952,claude-opus-5-537jof_12505,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,True,True,-1,-1,-1,0,0,2,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement,12,16,new_evidence,False,False,both,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_sample_period|falsification|alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,False,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,6,5,0.8,3,17,947,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.065374,claude-opus-5-538jof_12506,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,False,True,True,False,3,-1,-1,2,2,-1,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,11,-1,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_measure,unclear,True,no,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,6,8,956,True,False,False,False,1.0,0.076298,claude-opus-5-539jof_12507,True,empirical,market_microstructure,regression_discontinuity,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,3,-1,1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|roadmap,11,0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|placebo|sensitivity_to_parameters,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,5,5,831,False,False,False,False,0.8,0.066786,claude-opus-5-540jof_12508,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,3,True,False,True,True,True,False,True,-1,4,4,0,-1,1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|other|roadmap,16,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,newey_west,False,mixed,False,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,9,1270,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.082302,claude-opus-5-541jof_12509,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,0,2,-1,-1,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,6,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period,unclear,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,8,10,1171,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.076466,claude-opus-5-542jof_12510,True,empirical,market_microstructure,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,2,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,falsification|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,5,5,0.8,5,5,849,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.06787,claude-opus-5-543jof_12511,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,2,1,1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,12,5,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,False,no,True,True,True,moderate,5,5,0.82,4,6,909,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.069882,claude-opus-5-544jof_12512,True,mixed_theory_empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1,-1,3,1,0,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|identification_defense|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,14,6,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,5,8,1343,True,True,False,False,0.857,0.089202,claude-opus-5-545jof_12513,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,4,preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|motivation|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,13,8,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,unclear,False,mixed,False,False,False,low,7,7,0.8,6,10,781,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.064622,claude-opus-5-546jof_12514,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1,-1,0,1,4,-1,motivation|literature_gap|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|other|identification_defense|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,other,unclear,True,mixed,False,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,6,797,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.068798,claude-opus-5-547jof_12518,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,1,False,True,True,False,True,False,True,0,0,-1,0,-1,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|other|other|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,8,4,new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,main_text_section,alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification,mixed,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,3,5,757,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08846,claude-opus-5-548jof_12519,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,3,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|policy_or_broader_implication|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap,12,8,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,appendix,other,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,7,9,1552,False,True,False,False,0.9,0.069166,claude-opus-5-549jof_12520,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,1,-1,5,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|other|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,16,6,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,8,1384,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.084218,claude-opus-5-550jof_12521,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning,10,1,new_evidence|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period|other,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.82,6,5,746,False,False,False,False,0.667,0.08409,claude-opus-5-551jof_12522,True,empirical,household_finance,regression_discontinuity,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,1,1,3,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,13,4,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,within_results,placebo|alternative_specification|falsification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.85,6,8,1114,True,False,False,True,1.0,0.074438,claude-opus-5-552jof_12523,True,empirical,household_finance,structural_estimation,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,1,-1,1,1,-1,4,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|literature_gap|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|robustness_mention|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,14,1,new_evidence|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,10,1349,False,False,False,False,0.75,0.077334,claude-opus-5-553jof_12524,True,empirical,asset_pricing,other,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,1,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,9,2,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,appendix,alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,low,6,6,0.8,5,5,646,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.065194,claude-opus-5-554jof_12525,True,theoretical,market_microstructure,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,4,1,-1,0,motivation|preview_of_approach|motivation|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,0,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.88,5,10,978,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.064646,claude-opus-5-555jof_12526,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,2,-1,0,2,-1,0,preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results,3,0,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,other,none,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,5,4,0.8,4,1,228,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.052926,claude-opus-5-556jof_12530,True,survey_or_address,financial_econometrics,other,2,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,4,3,5,1,-1,6,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,6,2,new_method|synthesis,True,False,both,False,mixed,True,none_seen,,none,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,16,3,600,True,True,False,False,0.75,0.072698,claude-opus-5-557jof_12539,True,theoretical,macro_finance,calibration_simulation,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,4,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|other|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,16,0,new_theory_or_model,True,True,separate_section,True,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,False,True,True,low,8,8,0.85,6,9,1288,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.076238,claude-opus-5-558jof_12540,True,theoretical,macro_finance,calibration_simulation,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,2,-1,4,motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|motivation|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|robustness_mention,15,9,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,internet_appendix,other,none,False,no,False,True,False,low,7,7,0.85,5,10,1468,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.082542,claude-opus-5-559jof_12541,True,theoretical,market_microstructure,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,1,-1,4,motivation|preview_of_approach,2,-1,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,appendix,other,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,6,5,0.75,5,1,234,False,False,False,False,0.778,0.06161,claude-opus-5-560jof_12542,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,0,1,1,0,contribution_statement|motivation|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|other|roadmap,8,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,4,658,True,False,False,False,1.0,0.07305,claude-opus-5-561jof_12544,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,3,-1,6,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,10,0,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,False,stars_and_tstats,False,none_seen,,mixed,False,mixed,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,8,6,870,False,False,False,True,1.0,0.065926,claude-opus-5-562jof_12545,True,empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,True,True,True,True,False,0,1,2,3,3,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,10,5,new_identification|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|subsample|falsification|other,unclear,True,no,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,6,1248,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.070834,claude-opus-5-563jof_12546,True,mixed_theory_empirical,international_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,2,3,-1,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning,7,0,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,7,4,708,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07009,claude-opus-5-564jof_12547,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,10,-1,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,appendix,subsample|alternative_specification,robust,False,no,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,7,1115,False,True,False,True,0.692,0.078794,claude-opus-5-565jof_12548,True,replication_or_correction,market_microstructure,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,True,False,True,False,True,-1,1,-1,0,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|roadmap,5,0,replication_or_correction,True,False,none,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,False,False,False,low,4,3,0.88,4,1,188,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.042282,claude-opus-5-566jof_12583,True,mixed_theory_empirical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,2,-1,1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,14,6,new_theory_or_model|new_method|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.85,5,8,1506,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.075218,claude-opus-5-567jof_12584,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,4,motivation|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results,6,2,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,both,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,3,624,False,False,False,False,0.9,0.062194,claude-opus-5-568jof_12585,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,4,1,2,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,13,2,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|falsification|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,6,974,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.080458,claude-opus-5-569jof_12586,True,mixed_theory_empirical,macro_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,4,-1,3,motivation|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap,11,3,new_theory_or_model|synthesis|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,6,6,966,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.063046,claude-opus-5-570jof_12587,True,mixed_theory_empirical,international_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,True,True,True,True,-1,-1,0,1,3,4,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,11,2,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_sample_period|subsample|alternative_measure|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,7,1230,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.071482,claude-opus-5-571jof_12588,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,1,-1,3,contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|policy_or_broader_implication,8,0,new_theory_or_model,False,False,both,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,True,False,low,6,6,0.85,5,5,830,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.064122,claude-opus-5-572jof_12589,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,0,1,1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,6,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|other,unclear,False,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,9,1408,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.09826,claude-opus-5-573jof_12590,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,3,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|roadmap,13,0,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,other,none,False,no,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.88,5,8,1553,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.078502,claude-opus-5-574jof_12591,True,mixed_theory_empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,1,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,0,3,1,4,motivation|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|roadmap,11,3,new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_sample_period,unclear,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,7,5,884,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.070734,claude-opus-5-575jof_12592,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,5,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,6,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure|subsample|falsification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,8,8,0.8,9,9,1320,False,True,False,False,0.833,0.082222,claude-opus-5-576jof_12593,True,empirical,household_finance,survey_or_experiment,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,1,-1,5,motivation|motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|policy_or_broader_implication|literature_gap|motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,20,14,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period|other,robust,False,mixed,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.85,9,18,1855,True,False,False,True,0.714,0.088026,claude-opus-5-577jof_12600,True,replication_or_correction,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,3,True,False,True,True,True,False,True,-1,1,3,3,-1,0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|roadmap|policy_or_broader_implication,11,2,replication_or_correction|new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,True,True,both,True,unclear,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,6,5,0.8,4,8,1255,False,False,False,False,0.75,0.083442,claude-opus-5-578jof_12601,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,False,True,False,True,1,-1,-1,2,-1,1,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results,11,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,both,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.78,3,8,638,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07053,claude-opus-5-579jof_12602,True,empirical,household_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,2,4,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|roadmap,9,0,new_evidence|new_identification|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,placebo|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,5,1014,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.07731,claude-opus-5-580jof_12603,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,0,-1,2,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,7,new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period,newey_west,True,yes,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,4,12,1329,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.075274,claude-opus-5-581jof_12604,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,1,-1,2,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|other|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,12,5,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,3,6,979,False,True,False,False,0.8,0.071398,claude-opus-5-582jof_12605,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1,-1,0,2,1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,12,2,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_specification|other,robust,True,mixed,True,True,False,moderate,6,5,0.85,4,7,930,True,True,False,True,1.0,0.067546,claude-opus-5-583jof_12606,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,3,-1,0,preview_of_approach|motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,4,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,appendix,other,none,False,mixed,False,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,9,828,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.060654,claude-opus-5-584jof_12607,True,methodological_econometric,asset_pricing,other,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,2,-1,1,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results,10,0,new_method|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_sample_period|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,7,6,0.8,3,5,964,False,False,False,False,0.75,0.080822,claude-opus-5-585jof_12609,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,2,-1,1,3,-1,3,motivation|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,12,3,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.82,4,6,1024,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.067874,claude-opus-5-586jof_12610,True,mixed_theory_empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,1,-1,1,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication,13,4,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,9,9,0.8,6,6,1139,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07587,claude-opus-5-587jof_12611,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,True,False,True,False,False,1,1,-1,2,-1,-1,literature_gap|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,13,7,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,8,7,0.8,5,8,1529,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.079906,claude-opus-5-588jof_12612,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,8,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,alternative_sample_period|alternative_measure,newey_west,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,16,1543,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.080594,claude-opus-5-589jof_12613,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,natural_experiment_event_study,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,3,-1,0,motivation|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,15,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|subsample|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,False,True,False,low,8,6,0.82,8,7,1198,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.079778,claude-opus-5-590jof_12614,True,theoretical,macro_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|preview_of_approach|motivation|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|roadmap,12,6,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,8,1188,False,False,False,False,0.714,0.068854,claude-opus-5-591jof_12615,True,methodological_econometric,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,1,False,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,0,-1,0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,12,0,new_evidence|replication_or_correction,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification|other,none,True,no,True,False,False,low,6,6,0.8,4,4,717,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.100634,claude-opus-5-592jof_12616,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,1,-1,0,2,-1,3,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,1,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.82,5,6,901,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.074482,claude-opus-5-593jof_12617,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,12,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.82,5,7,1325,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08487,claude-opus-5-594jof_12618,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,3,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,2,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement,5,0,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,other,none,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,1,229,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.061754,claude-opus-5-595jof_12619,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,survey_or_experiment,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,4,-1,-1,motivation|related_literature_positioning|motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|roadmap,10,2,new_evidence,True,True,both,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,clustered,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,7,775,False,False,True,False,1.0,0.061318,claude-opus-5-596jof_12620,True,empirical,international_finance,reduced_form_regression,4,True,False,True,False,True,False,True,-1,1,-1,0,-1,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap,14,0,new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,8,1295,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.080938,claude-opus-5-597jof_12684,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,3,4,4,2,motivation|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|roadmap|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,12,0,new_theory_or_model|new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,low,6,6,0.8,5,8,1245,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.06673,claude-opus-5-598jof_12685,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,3,2,-1,1,other|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,9,13,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification|falsification|placebo,clustered,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,14,1315,False,True,True,True,1.0,0.093224,claude-opus-5-599jof_12687,True,empirical,household_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1,-1,2,2,3,-1,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,10,0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,appendix,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,5,7,1063,True,True,False,False,0.9,0.080826,claude-opus-5-5100jof_12688,True,methodological_econometric,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,structural_estimation,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,3,-1,1,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,10,1,new_method|new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,False,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,mixed,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,4,5,520,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06077,claude-opus-5-5101jof_12689,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,15,5,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,True,False,False,low,6,6,0.85,6,8,1174,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06273,claude-opus-5-5102jof_12690,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,difference_in_differences,3,True,True,True,True,True,True,True,1,0,3,3,3,4,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|identification_defense|robustness_mention|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,14,8,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_sample_period|subsample|alternative_specification|placebo|other,clustered,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,10,1250,True,True,True,True,0.75,0.075822,claude-opus-5-5103jof_12691,True,mixed_theory_empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,1,2,2,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,12,8,new_evidence|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,8,8,0.85,5,9,1366,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08721,claude-opus-5-5104jof_12692,True,empirical,corporate_finance,regression_discontinuity,4,True,False,False,False,True,True,True,-1,-1,-1,0,0,3,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|other|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,11,4,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|placebo|alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters|falsification,unclear,False,mixed,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,5,808,True,True,False,False,0.889,0.074722,claude-opus-5-5105jof_12694,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,10,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,both,True,p_values,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|other,newey_west,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,5,5,0.82,6,7,948,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.076454,claude-opus-5-5106jof_12695,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,survey_or_experiment,2,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,2,3,4,6,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,7,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,p_values,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,True,moderate,4,4,0.8,7,5,1046,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.066766,claude-opus-5-5107jof_12696,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,7,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,appendix,other,none,False,no,False,False,False,low,6,6,0.85,4,9,1121,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.066666,claude-opus-5-5108jof_12697,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,calibration_simulation,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,2,1,3,-1,motivation|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention,10,0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,5,5,0.8,5,4,852,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.07425,claude-opus-5-5109jof_12698,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,True,True,-1,-1,2,2,1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|identification_defense|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,12,-1,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,separate_section,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|placebo|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,16,6,907,False,False,False,False,0.714,0.08379,claude-opus-5-5110jof_12699,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,True,True,True,True,-1,-1,1,0,2,1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|alternative_specification,unclear,True,no_figures,False,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.82,5,8,1205,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.075354,claude-opus-5-5111jof_12700,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,other,1,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,1,-1,0,2,2,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,8,1,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.75,6,4,622,True,True,False,False,0.75,0.07601,claude-opus-5-5112jof_12701,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,survey_or_experiment,4,True,True,True,True,True,False,False,1,0,1,2,-1,-1,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication,13,5,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,8,16,1330,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.070982,claude-opus-5-5113jof_12702,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,0,2,1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning,11,-1,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure|placebo|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,9,9,0.8,7,4,710,True,False,False,False,0.857,0.07619,claude-opus-5-5114jof_12703,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,3,-1,-1,motivation|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,10,4,new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,7,1249,False,True,False,False,0.5,0.070314,claude-opus-5-5115jof_12704,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,True,False,-1,-1,-1,1,0,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|roadmap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication,17,15,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.82,4,17,1216,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.079654,claude-opus-5-5116jof_12705,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,3,3,-1,-1,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication,11,4,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification,none,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.82,4,5,869,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.072306,claude-opus-5-5117jof_12706,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,False,False,-1,-1,-1,0,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,13,6,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_specification|alternative_measure,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,3,8,1391,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.077806,claude-opus-5-5118jof_12710,True,mixed_theory_empirical,macro_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,3,-1,2,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,8,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,False,stars_and_tstats,False,main_text_section,alternative_specification|other,robust,True,yes,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,10,1315,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.082902,claude-opus-5-5119jof_12717,True,theoretical,market_microstructure,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,1,-1,1,4,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,10,6,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,False,False,False,low,4,4,0.85,6,7,891,False,True,False,False,0.833,0.05727,claude-opus-5-5120jof_12718,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,1,-1,2,3,0,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|roadmap,19,10,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|subsample|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,8,8,0.85,4,14,1713,True,False,False,False,0.8,0.08015,claude-opus-5-5121jof_12719,True,mixed_theory_empirical,macro_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,True,False,True,False,True,0,3,-1,2,-1,4,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|robustness_mention|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|other|roadmap,11,4,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,other,none,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,6,917,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.067898,claude-opus-5-5122jof_12720,True,mixed_theory_empirical,international_finance,calibration_simulation,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,3,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning,11,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,False,mixed,alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,mixed,True,False,True,moderate,5,5,0.8,4,6,840,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.066438,claude-opus-5-5123jof_12721,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,2,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,7,3,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,5,0.8,4,4,808,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.068346,claude-opus-5-5124jof_12722,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,survey_or_experiment,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,1,2,4,-1,motivation|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|roadmap,8,-1,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,p_values,False,within_results,subsample|sensitivity_to_parameters,none,False,no,False,False,False,low,7,7,0.85,5,4,724,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07691,claude-opus-5-5125jof_12723,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,0,0,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,13,10,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,subsample|falsification|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no_figures,False,True,False,low,7,7,0.8,4,11,1286,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.074842,claude-opus-5-5126jof_12724,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,1,-1,3,motivation|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|other|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,5,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,main_text_section,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|other,clustered,True,mixed,True,True,False,moderate,9,9,0.82,4,8,1267,False,True,True,False,0.8,0.097166,claude-opus-5-5127jof_12725,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,True,False,-1,-1,-1,1,2,-1,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|robustness_mention|roadmap,8,3,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,placebo|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|subsample|falsification,unclear,False,no_figures,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,5,809,False,True,False,False,0.8,0.072706,claude-opus-5-5128jof_12726,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1,-1,1,0,2,-1,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,5,new_evidence,True,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,falsification|alternative_measure|other,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,6,1071,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.078954,claude-opus-5-5129jof_12727,True,empirical,asset_pricing,instrumental_variables,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,1,-1,2,2,4,-1,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,5,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,7,999,True,True,False,False,0.8,0.071978,claude-opus-5-5130jof_12728,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,2,4,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|other|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,13,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,both,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|falsification|other,unclear,True,no,False,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,6,1281,False,True,False,False,0.889,0.086522,claude-opus-5-5131jof_12729,True,theoretical,behavioral_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning,12,1,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,5,8,1109,False,False,False,False,0.667,0.058134,claude-opus-5-5132jof_12730,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,2,False,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1,-1,1,0,1,-1,motivation|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|other|roadmap,15,8,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,none,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,3,13,1123,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.077994,claude-opus-5-5133jof_12731,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,False,False,True,True,True,True,-1,-1,0,1,0,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results,7,-1,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|new_method,False,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|other,mixed,False,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,3,3,607,True,True,False,False,0.9,0.079402,claude-opus-5-5134jof_12732,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach,10,4,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period,robust,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,5,938,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07557,claude-opus-5-5135jof_12733,True,empirical,asset_pricing,machine_learning_textual,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|other|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|other,15,10,new_evidence|new_method,False,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|subsample|other,clustered,True,mixed,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,14,1536,False,False,True,False,0.833,0.082154,claude-opus-5-5136jof_12734,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,3,3,-1,0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,7,2,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,main_text_section,placebo|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,4,3,624,False,False,False,False,0.857,0.068098,claude-opus-5-5137jof_12735,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,2,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,7,new_identification|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period,unclear,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,6,5,0.8,7,9,1393,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07699,claude-opus-5-5138jof_12736,True,empirical,asset_pricing,survey_or_experiment,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,1,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|contribution_statement,12,5,new_evidence,False,False,both,True,mixed,False,main_text_section,other,mixed,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,6,822,False,True,False,True,0.857,0.09151,claude-opus-5-5139jof_12737,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,other,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|roadmap,12,1,new_method|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|falsification,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.72,3,8,970,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.079714,claude-opus-5-5140jof_12738,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,0,preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement,14,1,new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,internet_appendix,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|other,unclear,False,no_figures,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.85,5,5,888,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07219,claude-opus-5-5141jof_12739,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,1,-1,5,preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,11,4,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters,none,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,8,8,0.82,6,7,797,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.084754,claude-opus-5-5142jof_12740,True,empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,1,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,15,10,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_specification|placebo,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,4,11,1419,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.080978,claude-opus-5-5143jof_12743,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,5,new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,5,5,0.8,5,8,1148,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.074502,claude-opus-5-5144jof_12744,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,3,-1,1,motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,5,new_theory_or_model|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|other,none,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,16,9,1265,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.09693,claude-opus-5-5145jof_12745,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,1,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,14,7,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,8,1334,False,True,False,False,0.8,0.071142,claude-opus-5-5146jof_12746,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|policy_or_broader_implication,7,2,new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,within_results,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no,False,False,False,low,6,6,0.8,7,4,510,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.064662,claude-opus-5-5147jof_12747,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,True,True,True,False,True,-1,0,2,1,-1,2,tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|robustness_mention|identification_defense|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,20,16,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,19,2771,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.095538,claude-opus-5-5148jof_12748,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,0,1,2,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,1,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|falsification,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,10,1622,True,True,False,False,0.778,0.085154,claude-opus-5-5149jof_12749,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,2,-1,1,motivation|literature_gap|other|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle,12,6,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,placebo|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,7,8,1332,False,True,False,False,0.833,0.07761,claude-opus-5-5150jof_12750,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,2,4,-1,1,motivation|preview_of_approach|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|subsample|falsification,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,7,7,1096,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07187,claude-opus-5-5151jof_12751,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,2,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,14,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,placebo|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|falsification|other,unclear,True,no,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,6,1128,False,True,False,False,0.833,0.07623,claude-opus-5-5152jof_12752,True,empirical,corporate_finance,structural_estimation,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,2,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|roadmap,6,0,new_method|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,separate_section,True,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,no_figures,False,False,False,low,6,6,0.75,5,2,328,True,False,False,False,0.857,0.062994,claude-opus-5-5153jof_12753,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,3,-1,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|roadmap,8,1,new_evidence|new_identification|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,False,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,6,0.8,7,4,570,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.074014,claude-opus-5-5154jof_12754,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|policy_or_broader_implication|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning,9,0,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,p_values,False,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,3,5,910,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06587,claude-opus-5-5155jof_12755,True,mixed_theory_empirical,international_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,1,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,5,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,appendix,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,False,low,6,6,0.8,5,8,1165,False,True,False,False,0.438,0.080014,claude-opus-5-5156jof_12756,True,theoretical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,0,-1,0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|other|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,8,2,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,none,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,3,700,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.064618,claude-opus-5-5157jof_12757,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,0,2,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,10,0,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,6,1204,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.063122,claude-opus-5-5158jof_12758,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|robustness_mention,7,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,False,main_text_section,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,2,446,False,False,False,False,0.857,0.068698,claude-opus-5-5159jof_12759,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,False,1,-1,-1,3,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|other,13,20,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,internet_appendix,alternative_measure|placebo|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.82,6,24,1757,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.083134,claude-opus-5-5160jof_12760,True,theoretical,macro_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|policy_or_broader_implication|other|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,6,new_theory_or_model,True,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification,none,False,no_figures,False,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,7,9,1101,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.064086,claude-opus-5-5161jof_12761,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,4,-1,2,motivation|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,19,0,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,main_text_section,sensitivity_to_parameters|other,none,True,no,True,False,True,low,6,6,0.85,7,14,1815,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.093426,claude-opus-5-5162jof_12762,True,replication_or_correction,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,True,True,True,False,True,-1,0,1,2,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,5,0,replication_or_correction|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,True,True,False,low,5,5,0.85,5,1,241,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.047762,claude-opus-5-5163jof_12763,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,structural_estimation,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,3,1,2,-1,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14,7,new_data_or_measure|new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,10,1608,False,True,False,True,0.667,0.080046,claude-opus-5-5164jof_12764,True,theoretical,macro_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch,4,0,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,True,low,4,4,0.8,4,1,216,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.053138,claude-opus-5-5165jof_12765,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,0,1,2,-1,3,tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,10,1,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,7,1034,False,True,False,False,0.875,0.072226,claude-opus-5-5166jof_12766,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,4,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,9,3,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,5,744,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.070214,claude-opus-5-5167jof_12768,True,empirical,asset_pricing,survey_or_experiment,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning,9,1,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,none_seen,,clustered,True,mixed,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.82,4,5,792,False,False,True,False,0.75,0.06493,claude-opus-5-5168jof_12769,True,empirical,market_microstructure,other,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,False,0,-1,-1,2,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|roadmap,14,1,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure,unclear,True,no_figures,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,11,1643,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.076742,claude-opus-5-5169jof_12770,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,5,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,3,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,8,1265,False,False,False,False,0.857,0.07281,claude-opus-5-5170jof_12771,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|motivation|robustness_mention|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,15,4,new_theory_or_model|new_method|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,confidence_intervals,True,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,mixed,True,True,True,moderate,8,7,0.8,4,7,1140,False,True,False,False,0.92,0.097342,claude-opus-5-5171jof_12772,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,0,-1,1,motivation|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|other|roadmap,10,2,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,False,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample,mixed,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,6,0.8,2,7,956,False,False,False,True,0.8,0.068262,claude-opus-5-5172jof_12773,True,mixed_theory_empirical,macro_finance,calibration_simulation,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,2,3,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,10,6,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,appendix,alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,7,7,1292,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.078122,claude-opus-5-5173jof_12775,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,4,0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|identification_defense|identification_defense|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,17,12,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|falsification|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,14,1618,True,True,False,False,0.875,0.100474,claude-opus-5-5174jof_12776,True,empirical,asset_pricing,other,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,6,new_evidence|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,False,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period|subsample|alternative_measure|other,mixed,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,15,1472,False,False,False,True,0.75,0.078554,claude-opus-5-5175jof_12777,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,0,1,1,3,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results,8,-1,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_sample_period|other,clustered,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,6,870,True,False,True,True,1.0,0.072766,claude-opus-5-5176jof_12778,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,2,-1,3,preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|roadmap|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,14,2,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_specification|other,bootstrap,False,unclear,False,False,False,low,5,5,0.8,4,11,1371,False,False,False,False,0.714,0.078242,claude-opus-5-5177jof_12779,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,9,6,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,mixed,other,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,7,1238,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06739,claude-opus-5-5178jof_12780,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,2,5,motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,18,9,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,mixed,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,14,1887,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.082926,claude-opus-5-5179jof_12782,True,survey_or_address,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,True,False,True,False,True,0,1,-1,2,-1,3,tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|roadmap,14,1,new_theory_or_model|synthesis,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.85,6,23,1452,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.076034,claude-opus-5-5180jof_12783,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,other,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,2,1,2,-1,motivation|literature_gap|motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,9,5,new_evidence|new_method,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_sample_period|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,6,933,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.089882,claude-opus-5-5181jof_12784,True,replication_or_correction,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,1,2,4,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach,8,0,replication_or_correction|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,confidence_intervals,True,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification,none,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,4,599,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.056774,claude-opus-5-5182jof_12785,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,False,0,-1,-1,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,9,11,new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,13,1306,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.074822,claude-opus-5-5183jof_12786,True,replication_or_correction,asset_pricing,none,1,False,False,False,False,False,False,False,-1,-1,-1,-1,-1,-1,motivation|other|other|preview_of_results|other,5,-1,replication_or_correction,False,False,none,False,unclear,True,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,True,False,False,low,4,2,0.85,0,13,342,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.032674,claude-opus-5-5184jof_12817,True,empirical,asset_pricing,other,2,False,False,True,True,True,False,True,-1,1,2,3,-1,4,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,11,2,new_method|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample,unclear,False,no,False,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,8,1179,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07297,claude-opus-5-5185jof_12818,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,1,0,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results,10,0,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,False,within_results,alternative_sample_period|subsample|other,robust,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,4,5,818,False,False,False,True,0.5,0.077002,claude-opus-5-5186jof_12819,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication,10,3,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,clustered,True,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,4,755,False,True,True,True,1.0,0.083918,claude-opus-5-5187jof_12820,True,mixed_theory_empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,True,False,True,False,True,-1,0,-1,1,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning,13,9,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,10,1556,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08271,claude-opus-5-5188jof_12821,True,empirical,household_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1,-1,0,1,1,-1,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,17,1,new_identification|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|subsample|falsification|alternative_measure,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,4,12,1773,True,True,False,False,0.667,0.092546,claude-opus-5-5189jof_12822,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|preview_of_approach|other|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,18,9,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,16,1610,False,True,False,False,0.667,0.074258,claude-opus-5-5190jof_12823,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,mixed,placebo|alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,False,no_figures,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,7,953,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.069442,claude-opus-5-5191jof_12824,True,replication_or_correction,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,True,False,False,False,True,-1,0,-1,-1,-1,0,related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|contribution_statement|other|other|policy_or_broader_implication,6,0,replication_or_correction,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,True,False,False,low,4,4,0.85,2,58,2132,False,False,False,False,0.0,0.059086,claude-opus-5-5192jof_12827,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,True,True,True,True,True,0,0,1,1,1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|alternative_measure,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,7,7,1121,True,False,False,False,0.75,0.067482,claude-opus-5-5193jof_12828,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,calibration_simulation,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,2,1,3,-1,motivation|motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,15,9,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,11,1279,True,True,False,False,0.75,0.075002,claude-opus-5-5194jof_12829,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,2,-1,3,other|motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,9,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|subsample|falsification,clustered,True,unclear,False,True,False,low,6,6,0.8,5,11,1017,False,False,True,True,1.0,0.070658,claude-opus-5-5195jof_12830,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,1,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,14,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,7,1269,False,True,False,False,0.667,0.071222,claude-opus-5-5196jof_12831,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,1,tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,11,3,new_theory_or_model,True,True,both,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,sensitivity_to_parameters|other,none,False,no,True,False,True,moderate,5,5,0.85,6,7,1071,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.065526,claude-opus-5-5197jof_12832,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|literature_gap|identification_defense|roadmap,11,3,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,6,6,1120,False,True,False,False,0.667,0.06629,claude-opus-5-5198jof_12833,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,3,-1,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|roadmap|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,11,1,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,6,791,False,False,False,True,1.0,0.06987,claude-opus-5-5199jof_12834,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,1,-1,1,2,-1,4,other|motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach,6,1,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,other,none,False,no,False,True,False,low,5,5,0.85,5,2,231,False,False,False,False,0.75,0.047858,claude-opus-5-5200jof_12835,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,survey_or_experiment,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,1,-1,2,3,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,8,0,new_evidence,True,True,none,True,mixed,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|other,clustered,True,mixed,False,True,True,low,6,6,0.8,6,4,653,False,True,True,False,1.0,0.08355,claude-opus-5-5201jof_12836,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|other|roadmap,18,1,new_evidence,True,True,both,True,mixed,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,9,9,0.85,5,15,1777,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.086042,claude-opus-5-5202jof_12837,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,2,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,1,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,8,950,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07049,claude-opus-5-5203jof_12838,True,empirical,market_microstructure,other,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,2,3,-1,-1,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|roadmap,11,1,new_evidence|new_method|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,5,5,0.75,7,5,860,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08897,claude-opus-5-5204jof_12839,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,calibration_simulation,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|other|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,0,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,none,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,4,14,919,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07523,claude-opus-5-5205jof_12840,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,3,4,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|identification_defense|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,12,5,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|placebo|other,unclear,True,mixed,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,6,1087,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.071218,claude-opus-5-5206jof_12841,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,natural_experiment_event_study,5,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,0,0,0,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,17,5,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,placebo|alternative_specification|alternative_measure,unclear,False,mixed,False,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,4,8,1311,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.079458,claude-opus-5-5207jof_12842,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,structural_estimation,3,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification,newey_west,True,no,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,7,1035,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.076254,claude-opus-5-5208jof_12843,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,2,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,12,5,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|subsample|other,clustered,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.82,6,6,881,False,True,True,True,1.0,0.07253,claude-opus-5-5209jof_12844,True,mixed_theory_empirical,market_microstructure,natural_experiment_event_study,3,True,True,True,True,True,False,True,1,1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,10,4,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,6,1015,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.061738,claude-opus-5-5210jof_12845,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,False,True,False,False,0,-1,-1,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,4,new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,main_text_section,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.82,4,6,943,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.071982,claude-opus-5-5211jof_12846,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,1,1,-1,-1,other|motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,15,9,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|falsification|subsample|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no,False,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,16,11,1282,False,True,False,False,0.8,0.108242,claude-opus-5-5212jof_12847,True,empirical,household_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,1,1,4,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,6,new_evidence|new_identification|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_specification|placebo|subsample|other,clustered,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,7,8,1137,True,False,True,True,0.8,0.075346,claude-opus-5-5213jof_12848,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,13,4,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|other,none,False,no,True,True,False,low,6,6,0.85,5,7,1227,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.06361,claude-opus-5-5214jof_12849,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,structural_estimation,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,3,4,related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|policy_or_broader_implication|other|roadmap,14,0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters|falsification|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,9,1336,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.075526,claude-opus-5-5215jof_12851,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,difference_in_differences,5,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,1,2,2,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,10,3,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|placebo|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|subsample|other,clustered,True,unclear,False,False,False,low,8,8,0.85,5,5,671,True,True,True,False,0.8,0.070878,claude-opus-5-5216jof_12852,True,empirical,behavioral_finance,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,12,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,4,6,1197,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.075798,claude-opus-5-5217jof_12853,True,empirical,asset_pricing,machine_learning_textual,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,6,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,7,1038,False,False,False,False,0.9,0.077478,claude-opus-5-5218jof_12854,True,replication_or_correction,financial_econometrics,calibration_simulation,1,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,3,2,-1,4,contribution_statement|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach,3,0,replication_or_correction|new_method,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|other,none,True,no_figures,False,False,False,low,5,4,0.8,5,1,236,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.068406,claude-opus-5-5219jof_12855,True,methodological_econometric,asset_pricing,other,1,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,2,3,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|other|roadmap,13,6,new_method|new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,mixed,False,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification,mixed,False,mixed,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,8,1286,True,False,False,False,0.6,0.078374,claude-opus-5-5220jof_12856,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,5,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,14,0,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,other,none,False,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,9,1659,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.074054,claude-opus-5-5221jof_12857,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,3,-1,1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch,6,0,new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,True,False,True,low,4,4,0.85,5,1,213,False,False,False,False,0.8,0.04359,claude-opus-5-5222jof_12862,True,methodological_econometric,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,False,False,True,True,True,True,-1,-1,0,1,2,3,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,14,6,new_theory_or_model|new_method|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,none,True,no,False,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,7,12,1591,True,False,False,False,1.0,0.103098,claude-opus-5-5223jof_12863,True,empirical,market_microstructure,natural_experiment_event_study,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,3,literature_gap|motivation|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,12,0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,separate_section,True,mixed,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,mixed,True,False,True,moderate,8,8,0.82,5,5,833,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.073118,claude-opus-5-5224jof_12864,True,mixed_theory_empirical,market_microstructure,structural_estimation,2,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,3,2,1,4,motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|literature_gap|policy_or_broader_implication|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,5,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,mixed,True,mixed,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,8,1196,False,False,True,True,0.857,0.074786,claude-opus-5-5225jof_12865,True,replication_or_correction,market_microstructure,none,1,False,False,False,False,False,False,False,-1,-1,-1,-1,-1,-1,other,1,-1,replication_or_correction,False,False,none,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no_figures,False,False,False,low,1,0,0.95,0,2,25,False,False,False,False,0.0,0.020102,claude-opus-5-5226jof_12866,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,3,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication,7,-1,new_theory_or_model,False,False,separate_section,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,4,4,651,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.062698,claude-opus-5-5227jof_12867,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,0,1,1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning,14,3,new_evidence|new_identification|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,7,1096,True,True,False,False,0.75,0.07329,claude-opus-5-5228jof_12868,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,1,-1,5,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|roadmap,13,0,new_evidence|new_identification|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,7,974,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.075338,claude-opus-5-5229jof_12869,True,empirical,macro_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|identification_defense|robustness_mention|identification_defense|preview_of_results|roadmap,13,0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_method,True,True,both,False,mixed,False,mixed,alternative_specification|placebo|subsample|alternative_measure,robust,True,mixed,True,False,False,moderate,10,10,0.8,5,6,881,False,False,False,True,0.857,0.10301,claude-opus-5-5230jof_12870,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,3,mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|preview_of_results|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,10,4,new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,False,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_sample_period|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.85,4,5,779,False,False,False,True,0.8,0.067146,claude-opus-5-5231jof_12871,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,False,True,True,True,False,True,-1,0,2,3,-1,4,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11,1,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,appendix,alternative_specification|other,none,False,no_figures,True,True,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,6,8,1357,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.069062,claude-opus-5-5232jof_12876,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,2,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,5,new_evidence|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,8,1122,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07539,claude-opus-5-5233jof_12877,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,3,0,-1,2,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,15,1,new_theory_or_model|new_method,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters|other,none,True,no,True,False,True,low,5,5,0.85,6,17,1764,False,True,False,False,0.833,0.077022,claude-opus-5-5234jof_12878,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,False,0,-1,-1,2,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,12,7,new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|other,unclear,False,no,True,True,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,8,1401,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.080282,claude-opus-5-5235jof_12879,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,True,True,True,True,False,1,0,3,3,0,-1,tension_or_puzzle|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,6,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,8,1412,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.077842,claude-opus-5-5236jof_12880,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0,-1,1,2,5,6,other|other|motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,13,5,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7,6,0.85,7,7,770,False,True,False,False,0.833,0.074078,claude-opus-5-5237jof_12882,True,theoretical,market_microstructure,theoretical_model_analytical,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,3,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication,10,2,new_theory_or_model,False,False,both,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,other,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,4,807,False,False,False,False,0.8,0.05785,claude-opus-5-5238jof_12883,True,methodological_econometric,financial_econometrics,machine_learning_textual,1,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,0,3,-1,1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|robustness_mention|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|other|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,17,6,new_method|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,False,stars_and_tstats,False,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample,unclear,False,mixed,True,False,False,moderate,6,5,0.8,4,12,1777,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06979,claude-opus-5-5239jof_12884,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,3,True,False,True,True,True,False,True,-1,0,1,1,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|identification_defense|identification_defense|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,23,17,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|placebo|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,5,21,2129,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.087454,claude-opus-5-5240jof_12885,True,empirical,asset_pricing,machine_learning_textual,2,False,False,False,True,True,True,True,-1,-1,0,0,1,3,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|motivation|other|other|other|other|other|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|robustness_mention|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|roadmap,20,2,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,both,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,8,8,0.85,14,20,2701,True,False,False,False,0.8,0.096634,claude-opus-5-5241jof_12888,True,theoretical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,4,-1,0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,6,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,6,8,1325,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.063894,claude-opus-5-5242jof_12889,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,7,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,12,56,new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|subsample|alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,9,64,1177,False,True,False,False,0.8,0.084382,claude-opus-5-5243jof_12890,True,empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,0,0,-1,-1,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,15,6,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_sample_period,unclear,False,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,7,9,1525,False,True,False,False,0.8,0.08155,claude-opus-5-5244jof_12893,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,True,True,-1,-1,-1,1,2,1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,19,19,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,alternative_specification|other,clustered,False,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6,6,0.85,3,22,2477,False,True,True,True,1.0,0.088154,claude-opus-5-5245jof_12894,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,2,-1,0,other|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,11,3,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,False,none_seen,,newey_west,True,unclear,True,False,True,low,6,6,0.8,3,10,1416,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.076654,claude-opus-5-5246jof_12895,True,empirical,household_finance,survey_or_experiment,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,0,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,11,0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,no_figures,False,False,False,moderate,5,5,0.82,5,7,948,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.070646,claude-opus-5-5247jof_12896,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,6,motivation|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|identification_defense|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|policy_or_broader_implication,10,0,new_evidence,False,False,separate_section,True,stars_and_tstats,True,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|other,clustered,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.82,8,4,769,False,False,True,True,0.9,0.09503,claude-opus-5-5248jof_12897,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,2,-1,5,preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|identification_defense|identification_defense|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|other|roadmap,12,7,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|subsample|placebo|falsification|alternative_measure,unclear,True,mixed,False,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,6,11,1183,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.076398,claude-opus-5-5249jof_12898,True,empirical,asset_pricing,other,1,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,2,-1,-1,motivation|other|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|roadmap,9,3,new_evidence|new_method|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|sensitivity_to_parameters,none,True,unclear,True,False,False,low,5,5,0.8,5,5,637,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.066314,claude-opus-5-5250jof_12899,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,13,7,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,separate_section,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|falsification|placebo|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,9,1349,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.075254,claude-opus-5-5251jof_12900,True,mixed_theory_empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,structural_estimation,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,3,-1,2,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,13,1,new_evidence|new_identification|new_method|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,confidence_intervals,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|other,bootstrap,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,9,1297,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.074746,claude-opus-5-5252jof_12901,True,empirical,asset_pricing,other,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|roadmap|robustness_mention,10,-1,new_method|new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,False,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,False,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.75,5,15,893,False,False,False,False,0.75,0.103042,claude-opus-5-5253jof_12902,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,2,2,-1,-1,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|identification_defense|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results,9,1,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,5,5,0.8,6,5,918,False,True,False,False,0.6,0.065058,claude-opus-5-5254jof_12903,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,1,-1,3,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|identification_defense|roadmap,11,-1,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,separate_section,True,unclear,True,within_results,placebo|falsification|other,unclear,True,mixed,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,9,1401,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.082834,claude-opus-5-5255jof_12906,True,survey_or_address,behavioral_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,2,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,2,3,4,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,12,5,new_theory_or_model|synthesis,True,False,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,True,moderate,6,5,0.8,5,10,966,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.057706,claude-opus-5-5256jof_12908,True,empirical,corporate_finance,regression_discontinuity,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,2,1,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|other|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,13,0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,7,1105,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07211,claude-opus-5-5257jof_12909,True,empirical,macro_finance,other,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,0,1,-1,0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention,9,1,new_data_or_measure|new_evidence,False,False,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_measure|subsample|other,clustered,True,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,4,6,1015,False,True,True,False,1.0,0.071354,claude-opus-5-5258jof_12910,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,0,motivation|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning,9,0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,17,5,1055,False,False,False,False,0.667,0.096066,claude-opus-5-5259jof_12947,True,empirical,asset_pricing,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,0,1,2,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|identification_defense,16,9,new_evidence|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_sample_period|placebo|falsification|subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.82,4,10,1364,True,True,False,False,0.778,0.088466,claude-opus-5-5260jof_12948,True,mixed_theory_empirical,macro_finance,calibration_simulation,2,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,1,-1,2,3,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|other|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,16,6,new_theory_or_model|synthesis,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_sample_period,none,True,mixed,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.82,6,12,1472,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08181,claude-opus-5-5261jof_12949,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2,False,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,0,-1,1,motivation|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,12,12,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7,7,0.8,5,14,889,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.068794,claude-opus-5-5262jof_12950,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3,True,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,0,-1,3,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13,5,new_evidence|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,appendix,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,7,0.82,4,8,1176,False,True,False,False,0.9,0.082114,claude-opus-5-5263jof_12951,True,methodological_econometric,financial_econometrics,calibration_simulation,1,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,0,2,4,-1,1,motivation|literature_gap|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results,7,2,new_method|new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,sensitivity_to_parameters|subsample|other,none,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,4,4,0.8,5,5,910,True,False,False,False,1.0,0.061198,claude-opus-5-5264jof_12952,True,empirical,household_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,2,3,-1,4,motivation|literature_gap|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,11,4,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_specification|subsample,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,5,5,0.82,6,6,1168,False,True,False,False,0.6,0.070362,claude-opus-5-5265jof_12953,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,2,False,True,False,False,True,False,True,0,-1,-1,1,-1,4,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning,12,9,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,5,10,1455,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.08019,claude-opus-5-5266jof_12954,True,empirical,household_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,1,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results,9,-1,new_evidence,False,False,separate_section,True,mixed,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_specification|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,True,True,moderate,7,6,0.85,4,8,1429,False,False,False,False,0.833,0.074294,claude-opus-5-5267jof_12955,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,1,-1,4,motivation|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,9,3,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,falsification|alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.8,6,7,926,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.060726,claude-opus-5-5268jof_12958,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1,False,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1,-1,-1,3,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|contribution_statement|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|other|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,15,5,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,sensitivity_to_parameters|alternative_specification,none,False,no,True,True,False,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,11,1050,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.071414,claude-opus-5-5269jof_12959,True,mixed_theory_empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,True,True,True,False,False,0,1,3,2,-1,-1,motivation|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|roadmap,9,3,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,False,False,False,low,5,5,0.8,4,5,833,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06227,claude-opus-5-5270jof_12961,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,3,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,0,3,-1,4,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,9,5,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,mixed,other,none,False,no,True,True,True,moderate,6,6,0.85,5,8,1573,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.069038,claude-opus-5-5271jof_12962,True,replication_or_correction,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,True,True,True,False,True,0,1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|other|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,11,8,replication_or_correction|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,False,none_seen,,mixed,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,5,5,0.8,4,10,1171,False,False,True,False,1.0,0.061086,claude-opus-5-5272jof_12964,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0,-1,1,2,-1,3,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|identification_defense|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,14,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period|other,clustered,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6,6,0.82,6,7,994,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07131,claude-opus-5-5273jof_12965,True,mixed_theory_empirical,international_finance,calibration_simulation,2,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1,-1,1,0,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,12,5,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,5,5,0.8,4,9,1280,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.069258,claude-opus-5-5274jof_12966,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,4,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1,-1,1,0,-1,1,motivation|preview_of_results|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,12,4,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,4,5,829,False,True,False,False,0.6,0.076042,claude-opus-5-5275jof_12967,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,3,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0,-1,1,3,-1,-1,motivation|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,10,0,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,True,True,moderate,5,5,0.85,5,6,1030,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.058382,claude-opus-5-5276jof_12968,True,empirical,household_finance,instrumental_variables,4,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0,-1,1,2,2,-1,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|literature_gap|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|roadmap,13,6,new_evidence|new_identification|new_data_or_measure,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_measure|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,8,8,0.8,5,7,1166,True,True,False,False,0.6,0.085874,claude-opus-5-5277jof_12969,True,empirical,market_microstructure,natural_experiment_event_study,3,True,True,True,True,True,False,False,1,1,2,3,-1,-1,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|other|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|identification_defense|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,14,5,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,7,6,0.8,5,7,1020,False,True,False,False,0.8,0.069154,claude-opus-5-5278