1condition,clarity,argument_logic,contribution_positioning,methodological_rigor,fidelity,usefulness,n_invented_facts,n2A_baseline,5.79,5.58,5.0,4.79,5.33,5.58,1.38,243B_strong_prompt,6.04,5.71,5.33,5.04,5.33,5.71,1.62,244C_conventional_rag,5.96,5.88,5.21,5.21,5.25,5.67,1.71,245D_profiles_retrieval,5.92,5.75,5.33,5.17,5.25,5.75,1.88,246E_full_engine,5.83,6.04,4.92,6.12,5.71,5.42,0.88,247E_no_factcheck,6.0,6.06,4.94,6.19,5.75,5.62,0.88,168E_no_profile,5.94,6.12,5.12,6.38,5.69,5.69,1.0,169E_no_referee,6.0,5.62,4.88,4.88,5.12,5.31,1.81,1610E_no_retrieval,5.88,5.94,5.19,6.19,5.62,5.56,1.5,1611