1doc_id,schema_valid,genre,subfield,primary_method,causal_strength,uses_causal_claim,abs_question,abs_gap,abs_method,abs_results,abs_magnitude,abs_contribution,abs_question_idx,abs_gap_idx,abs_method_idx,abs_results_idx,abs_magnitude_idx,abs_contribution_idx,intro_moves_seq,intro_n_moves,contribution_para_idx,contribution_types,roadmap_llm,roadmap_regex,lit_positioning,econ_signif,stat_lang,magnitude_in_intro,robust_location,robust_types,se_desc,units_in_notes,fig_uncertainty,concl_bounded,concl_policy,concl_open,hedging,n_claims,claims_with_evidence,llm_confidence,abstract_n_sent,intro_n_paragraphs,intro_n_words,magnitude_regex_abstract,contribution_regex_intro,clustered_se_regex,stars_regex,role_agreement,cost_usd,model,validation_errors2jof_12407,True,empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,4.0,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,1.0,0.0,-1.0,3.0,motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|roadmap,10.0,-1.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,True,True,separate_section,True,stars_and_tstats,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,True,no_figures,False,False,False,low,7.0,7.0,0.8,4.0,6.0,855.0,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.06673,claude-opus-5-5,3jof_12432,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,3.0,True,True,True,False,True,False,True,1.0,0.0,-1.0,2.0,-1.0,1.0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,12.0,11.0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|placebo|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no_figures,False,False,True,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,5.0,14.0,1227.0,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.080506,claude-opus-5-5,4jof_12434,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4.0,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,2.0,1.0,-1.0,0.0,motivation|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|other|policy_or_broader_implication,13.0,7.0,new_evidence|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|subsample|falsification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.85,3.0,9.0,1304.0,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.079782,claude-opus-5-5,5jof_12438,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2.0,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,1.0,2.0,-1.0,0.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|contribution_statement|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,14.0,0.0,new_data_or_measure|resolution_of_puzzle|new_evidence|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_sample_period,unclear,True,mixed,True,False,False,moderate,5.0,5.0,0.8,4.0,8.0,1290.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.082186,claude-opus-5-5,6jof_12439,True,empirical,corporate_finance,difference_in_differences,4.0,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0.0,-1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,12.0,0.0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|falsification,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.85,6.0,6.0,1025.0,True,True,False,False,0.5,0.066598,claude-opus-5-5,7jof_12464,False,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,"'causal_language_strength' is a required property @ identification; 'uses_causal_claim' is a required property @ identification; [""Causal language strength rated 4: the abstract says booms 'form in response to' and the conclusion says the risk premium 'explains' waves, but the evidence is @ notes"8jof_12465,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3.0,True,True,False,True,True,False,False,0.0,-1.0,4.0,1.0,-1.0,-1.0,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement,11.0,8.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.8,5.0,9.0,1485.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.073646,claude-opus-5-5,9jof_12466,True,empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,3.0,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,0.0,0.0,-1.0,2.0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|roadmap,10.0,4.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,8.0,7.0,0.8,3.0,6.0,872.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.075834,claude-opus-5-5,10jof_12467,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,reduced_form_regression,3.0,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,1.0,2.0,-1.0,0.0,motivation|policy_or_broader_implication|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,11.0,4.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.8,5.0,6.0,1076.0,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.07403,claude-opus-5-5,11jof_12468,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,difference_in_differences,4.0,True,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,1.0,2.0,-1.0,0.0,motivation|literature_gap|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning,10.0,3.0,new_evidence|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,subsample|alternative_specification,unclear,False,yes,True,False,True,moderate,6.0,5.0,0.85,4.0,4.0,752.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.062382,claude-opus-5-5,12jof_12469,True,empirical,household_finance,natural_experiment_event_study,4.0,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,1.0,2.0,-1.0,1.0,tension_or_puzzle|literature_gap|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,18.0,1.0,new_evidence|new_identification|new_method,True,True,inside_introduction,True,stars_and_tstats,True,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|falsification|subsample|other,clustered,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.85,6.0,15.0,1483.0,False,True,False,False,0.75,0.07947,claude-opus-5-5,13jof_12470,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,survey_or_experiment,4.0,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,1.0,2.0,-1.0,4.0,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|other|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,17.0,0.0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,5.0,5.0,0.85,5.0,13.0,1529.0,False,True,False,False,0.6,0.076878,claude-opus-5-5,14jof_12471,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2.0,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,1.0,3.0,-1.0,0.0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning,11.0,1.0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,False,False,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,main_text_section,alternative_sample_period|alternative_specification|sensitivity_to_parameters|other,newey_west,False,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,8.0,8.0,0.8,6.0,6.0,936.0,False,True,False,False,0.9,0.086406,claude-opus-5-5,15jof_12472,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,2.0,False,True,False,True,True,True,True,0.0,-1.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,7.0,motivation|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|other|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|contribution_statement|roadmap,10.0,4.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|subsample|alternative_measure,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.82,8.0,5.0,779.0,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.069414,claude-opus-5-5,16jof_12473,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,2.0,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,0.0,1.0,-1.0,3.0,motivation|literature_gap|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|identification_defense|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,9.0,3.0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,both,True,unclear,True,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|other,unclear,False,unclear,True,False,True,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.8,4.0,7.0,1009.0,False,True,False,False,0.857,0.071746,claude-opus-5-5,17jof_12482,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,3.0,True,True,False,False,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,-1.0,2.0,-1.0,4.0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|motivation|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|identification_defense|robustness_mention|policy_or_broader_implication,12.0,0.0,new_evidence,False,False,both,True,unclear,False,mixed,subsample|alternative_measure|alternative_specification|falsification|other,unclear,True,unclear,False,True,True,moderate,8.0,8.0,0.8,5.0,6.0,938.0,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.080942,claude-opus-5-5,18jof_12483,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,difference_in_differences,3.0,True,True,False,False,True,False,False,0.0,-1.0,-1.0,1.0,-1.0,-1.0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|contribution_statement,10.0,3.0,new_evidence,False,False,both,True,unclear,False,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|alternative_measure,unclear,True,no_figures,True,False,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,6.0,4.0,860.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.067506,claude-opus-5-5,19jof_12484,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,structural_estimation,2.0,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,1.0,0.0,-1.0,0.0,contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|literature_gap,8.0,0.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,internet_appendix,alternative_specification,unclear,True,unclear,True,False,False,moderate,5.0,4.0,0.8,2.0,4.0,752.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.071706,claude-opus-5-5,20jof_12485,True,empirical,market_microstructure,natural_experiment_event_study,3.0,True,True,False,False,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,-1.0,1.0,-1.0,3.0,motivation|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|contribution_statement,13.0,6.0,new_evidence,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|subsample|other,unclear,False,no,False,True,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,6.0,7.0,1343.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.07733,claude-opus-5-5,21jof_12486,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2.0,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,0.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,-1.0,3.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|identification_defense|other|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14.0,2.0,new_method|new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,False,appendix,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|other,newey_west,True,mixed,True,False,True,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,4.0,12.0,2034.0,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.10605,claude-opus-5-5,22jof_12487,True,empirical,corporate_finance,reduced_form_regression,2.0,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1.0,-1.0,0.0,1.0,-1.0,-1.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|roadmap,10.0,-1.0,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,False,stars_and_tstats,False,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|placebo|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,3.0,6.0,1027.0,False,False,False,True,0.9,0.084146,claude-opus-5-5,23jof_12488,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,1.0,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,0.0,2.0,-1.0,1.0,motivation|literature_gap|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|roadmap,12.0,0.0,new_theory_or_model|new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,mixed,True,within_results,alternative_specification|subsample,mixed,True,unclear,False,False,True,low,7.0,6.0,0.85,3.0,9.0,1406.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.076602,claude-opus-5-5,24jof_12489,False,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Additional properties are not allowed ('figures_note_placeholder' was unexpected) @ figures25jof_12490,True,mixed_theory_empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,3.0,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,2.0,-1.0,2.0,3.0,1.0,4.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|robustness_mention|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication,14.0,6.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_theory_or_model,False,False,both,True,unclear,True,within_results,alternative_measure|alternative_specification,unclear,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,8.0,8.0,0.8,6.0,8.0,1027.0,True,False,False,False,1.0,0.08025,claude-opus-5-5,26jof_12492,True,empirical,corporate_finance,instrumental_variables,3.0,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0.0,-1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,-1.0,motivation|motivation|literature_gap|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|other,11.0,6.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification,False,False,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|other,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,9.0,9.0,0.8,6.0,12.0,1457.0,False,True,False,False,0.667,0.088078,claude-opus-5-5,27jof_12493,True,theoretical,financial_intermediation_banking,theoretical_model_analytical,1.0,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,1.0,0.0,-1.0,0.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|motivation|motivation|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14.0,1.0,new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,none_seen,,none,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,5.0,5.0,0.85,5.0,9.0,1642.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.06903,claude-opus-5-5,28jof_12494,False,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Additional properties are not allowed ('figures_note_placeholder_removed' was unexpected) @ figures29jof_12495,True,empirical,entrepreneurial_finance_private_equity,instrumental_variables,4.0,True,True,True,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,-1.0,-1.0,motivation|literature_gap|motivation|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|robustness_mention|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,11.0,1.0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,mixed,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|subsample|alternative_sample_period|other,unclear,True,no,True,False,True,moderate,8.0,8.0,0.8,5.0,7.0,1049.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.072966,claude-opus-5-5,30jof_12496,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,3.0,True,False,False,False,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,-1.0,2.0,-1.0,3.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,10.0,2.0,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,5.0,6.0,800.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.073094,claude-opus-5-5,31jof_12498,True,empirical,market_microstructure,reduced_form_regression,2.0,False,True,False,True,True,False,False,0.0,-1.0,2.0,2.0,-1.0,-1.0,motivation|motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|roadmap,10.0,45.0,new_evidence,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,none_seen,,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.72,6.0,46.0,1247.0,False,True,False,False,0.5,0.062926,claude-opus-5-5,32jof_12499,False,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Additional properties are not allowed ('convention_notes_placeholder_removed' was unexpected) @ figures33jof_12500,True,mixed_theory_empirical,household_finance,instrumental_variables,4.0,True,True,False,True,True,True,True,0.0,-1.0,1.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|contribution_statement|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,13.0,1.0,new_evidence|new_identification|new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,alternative_specification|subsample|sensitivity_to_parameters|other,unclear,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.8,4.0,7.0,1045.0,True,True,False,False,0.923,0.073714,claude-opus-5-5,34jof_12501,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,structural_estimation,2.0,False,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,0.0,1.0,-1.0,4.0,motivation|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,17.0,9.0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,confidence_intervals,True,appendix,alternative_specification,none,True,yes,True,False,False,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.8,6.0,11.0,1501.0,False,True,False,False,1.0,0.08133,claude-opus-5-5,35jof_12507,True,empirical,market_microstructure,regression_discontinuity,4.0,True,True,False,True,True,False,True,0.0,-1.0,2.0,3.0,-1.0,1.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_results|identification_defense|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|related_literature_positioning|literature_gap|roadmap,11.0,0.0,new_evidence|new_identification,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,False,within_results,alternative_specification|alternative_measure|placebo|sensitivity_to_parameters,unclear,True,unclear,True,True,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.85,5.0,5.0,831.0,False,False,False,False,0.8,0.066786,claude-opus-5-5,36jof_12509,True,mixed_theory_empirical,asset_pricing,reduced_form_regression,2.0,False,False,False,True,True,False,False,-1.0,-1.0,0.0,2.0,-1.0,-1.0,motivation|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,13.0,6.0,new_evidence|new_theory_or_model,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,main_text_section,alternative_measure|alternative_specification|alternative_sample_period,unclear,False,no,True,False,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.85,8.0,10.0,1171.0,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.076466,claude-opus-5-5,37jof_12514,True,empirical,household_finance,reduced_form_regression,3.0,True,False,False,True,True,True,False,-1.0,-1.0,0.0,1.0,4.0,-1.0,motivation|literature_gap|tension_or_puzzle|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|other|identification_defense|preview_of_results|contribution_statement|roadmap,11.0,4.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,within_results,other,unclear,True,mixed,False,False,False,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,5.0,6.0,797.0,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.068798,claude-opus-5-5,38jof_12530,True,survey_or_address,financial_econometrics,other,2.0,False,True,True,True,True,False,True,4.0,3.0,5.0,1.0,-1.0,6.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|related_literature_positioning|policy_or_broader_implication|roadmap,6.0,2.0,new_method|synthesis,True,False,both,False,mixed,True,none_seen,,none,True,no,True,True,True,moderate,7.0,7.0,0.8,16.0,3.0,600.0,True,True,False,False,0.75,0.072698,claude-opus-5-5,39jof_12589,True,empirical,financial_intermediation_banking,instrumental_variables,4.0,True,True,False,True,True,True,False,0.0,-1.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,-1.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_approach|identification_defense|preview_of_results|identification_defense|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|preview_of_results|policy_or_broader_implication|contribution_statement|related_literature_positioning|roadmap,14.0,6.0,new_evidence|new_data_or_measure|new_identification|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,True,unclear,True,mixed,placebo|alternative_specification|other,unclear,False,unclear,False,False,False,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.8,4.0,9.0,1408.0,True,True,False,False,1.0,0.09826,claude-opus-5-5,40jof_12590,True,theoretical,corporate_finance,theoretical_model_analytical,1.0,False,False,False,True,True,False,True,-1.0,-1.0,0.0,3.0,-1.0,4.0,motivation|tension_or_puzzle|related_literature_positioning|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_approach|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|mechanism_or_theory_sketch|preview_of_results|roadmap,13.0,0.0,new_theory_or_model|resolution_of_puzzle,True,True,inside_introduction,False,unclear,False,main_text_section,other,none,False,no,True,False,True,moderate,6.0,6.0,0.88,5.0,8.0,1553.0,False,False,False,False,1.0,0.078502,claude-opus-5-5,41