SPB Git

Repository Public MIT

competitive-analysis.md 7.7 KB

# Competitive analysis

Scope and method. This is a desk review written in November 2026 from the publicly documented behaviour of each product (manuals, vendor documentation, long-standing product conventions). No competitor was instrumented or benchmarked, so this document makes no performance or accuracy ranking. Its purpose is to identify conventions users expect and gaps that ORIX Calc can address. No interface, asset or source code of any product was copied.

# 1. Products reviewed

Product Kind What it is best at Where users hit limits
Apple Calculator (iOS / iPadOS) Built-in Zero-friction arithmetic, familiar layout, scientific keys in landscape, expression history and Math Notes in recent releases No financial functions, no user-visible precision model, limited statistics, no reactive notebook of named variables
TI BA II Plus Handheld financial The classroom and CFA-exam reference: TVM row (N, I/Y, PV, PMT, FV), CPT key, P/Y and C/Y, BGN/END, CF/NPV/IRR worksheets, bond and depreciation worksheets One line of display, hidden state (P/Y, BGN) causes classic mistakes, a single IRR is returned without warning when several exist, no explanation of results
HP 12C Handheld financial RPN speed, n / i / PV / PMT / FV keys, decades of trust in real estate and banking RPN learning curve, tiny display, same hidden-state and single-IRR issues, compounding conventions must be handled by the user
TI-84 Plus family Handheld graphing Curriculum standard: Y= editor, window, trace, calc menu (zero, minimum, intersect, ∫), STAT lists, distributions, tests Low-resolution plots connect across asymptotes unless the user changes mode, no symbolic algebra, menus are deep
Desmos Web / app graphing The benchmark for interactive graphing: instant sliders, implicit curves, points of interest on tap, beautiful rendering Online-first product, no financial engine, limited statistics inference, no exact-arithmetic history
GeoGebra Web / app Geometry + CAS + graphing + 3D in one suite, strong for teaching Several separate apps and views, dense interface for quick arithmetic
Wolfram Alpha Web service Unmatched breadth of symbolic computation and curated data, step-by-step solutions Requires a network connection and, for steps, a subscription; natural-language input is not deterministic
Popular scientific apps (PCalc, Calcbot, NumWorks, HiPER…) Apps RPN and engineering layouts, unit conversion, customisation Generally one domain each; finance, graphing, statistics and notebooks live in different apps
Popular financial apps (10bii-style, mortgage calculators) Apps Focused workflows for one task Conventions are often implicit (monthly compounding assumed everywhere), Canadian mortgage compounding is frequently wrong or missing

# 2. Comparison by criterion

Criterion What the field does Gap ORIX Calc addresses How (implemented)
Ease of use for 25 × 4 Apple sets the bar: open, tap, read Advanced apps bury arithmetic under modes Standard is the default environment, opens on the keypad, live preview, no extra tap
Feature completeness Split across 4–6 products One engine, eight environments, shared history and variables Eight environments in one app, one AppModel session
Accuracy model Almost never disclosed; binary floating point shows 0.1 + 0.2 artefacts in many apps, or hides them by rounding State the arithmetic used for each result Exact integers and rationals where possible; every result is labelled exact or ≈ floating point; Explain lists the checks run
Financial conventions Hidden state (P/Y, BGN), silent single IRR, US compounding assumed Make conventions explicit and refuse to guess P/Y, C/Y, BGN always visible; .multiple([rates]) / .none for IRR; jurisdiction-aware mortgage compounding (Canada: semi-annual)
Graph honesty Many plotters join points across poles Never connect across a discontinuity Dedicated sampler with pole / jump detection, validated by tests on 1/x, tan x, floor x…
Symbolic vs numeric Often not distinguished in the UI Label every result exact / symbolic / numerical / unsupported / failed convergence result kinds
Offline capability Handhelds: full. Web tools: none or partial Everything offline No network code path except the optional, user-initiated ECB rate download
Privacy Web tools log queries; many free apps ship ad SDKs No account, no analytics No third-party SDK; privacy manifest declares no collected data
Explanations Step-by-step is a paid, server-side feature elsewhere Deterministic explanations on device ORIX Explain is generated from the algorithm's actual steps, never from generated prose
Notebook Apple Math Notes (handwriting-first), spreadsheet apps A typed, reactive sheet with named variables and a dependency graph Workspace: incremental recalculation, cycle detection, exports
Accessibility Varies widely; handheld emulations are often unlabeled images Native controls SwiftUI controls with labels, Dynamic Type, VoiceOver values, contrast-checked palette

# 3. Conventions adopted because users expect them

  • Financial keys: N, I/Y, PV, PMT, FV with a CPT action, P/Y and C/Y, BGN / END, cash-flow sign convention (money received positive, money paid negative). These are industry conventions, not anyone's design.
  • Percent key: A + B% adds B percent of A — the behaviour of pocket calculators and of Apple Calculator. A strict mode (B% = B/100 everywhere) is available in Settings. See financial-conventions.md.
  • Graph analysis vocabulary: root, minimum, maximum, intersection, trace, tangent, ∫ — the TI-84 "CALC" menu vocabulary every student knows.
  • RPN: X, Y, Z, T labels, ENTER, x⇄y, R↓, LASTx, with HP percent semantics (Y is kept).
  • Statistics input: data or summary statistics for each test, as on graphing calculators.

# 4. Deliberate differences

  • Implicit multiplication has the same precedence as explicit multiplication (1/2x is (1/2)·x, 6 ÷ 2(1+2) = 9). Some calculators bind juxtaposition tighter; ORIX Calc documents its rule and shows the parsed expression before evaluating.
  • −2² = −4 (unary minus binds looser than the power), as in mathematics and most CAS, unlike some four-function devices.
  • Multiple IRRs are all reported. Established calculators return the first root their iteration reaches.
  • No "live" exchange rates. Rates are ECB reference rates with their date, or manual. The word live is never used.

# 5. Capability gaps that remain (honest list)

Area Leaders ORIX Calc 1.0
Breadth of symbolic integration, special functions, exact algebraic numbers Wolfram Alpha, GeoGebra CAS A scoped rule engine; unsupported integrals are reported as unsupported with a numerical fallback
Arbitrary-precision transcendental functions Wolfram Alpha, some high-precision apps Double precision for transcendental functions (exact arithmetic is arbitrary precision)
Geometry constructions GeoGebra Not in scope
Handwritten or two-dimensional math input Apple Math Notes, Photomath-style apps Math Camera reads printed linear expressions only (Beta)
Programmability TI-84, HP, PCalc User-defined functions and reactive workspaces, no scripting language
Exam approval BA II Plus, HP 12C, TI-84 A phone or tablet app is not an approved exam calculator

Claims of the form "better than X" are not made anywhere in the product or its listing: no comparative measurement was run.

Files main
Menu

Theme