Repository Public MIT
1<!--2ORIX Calc3File: docs/research/competitive-analysis.md4Author: Simon-Pierre Boucher5Contact: contact@spboucher.ai6-->7# Competitive analysis89**Scope and method.** This is a desk review written in November 2026 from the publicly documented behaviour of each product10(manuals, vendor documentation, long-standing product conventions). No competitor was instrumented or benchmarked, so this11document makes **no performance or accuracy ranking**. Its purpose is to identify conventions users expect and gaps that12ORIX Calc can address. No interface, asset or source code of any product was copied.1314## 1. Products reviewed1516| Product | Kind | What it is best at | Where users hit limits |17|---|---|---|---|18| Apple Calculator (iOS / iPadOS) | Built-in | Zero-friction arithmetic, familiar layout, scientific keys in landscape, expression history and Math Notes in recent releases | No financial functions, no user-visible precision model, limited statistics, no reactive notebook of named variables |19| TI BA II Plus | Handheld financial | The classroom and CFA-exam reference: TVM row (N, I/Y, PV, PMT, FV), CPT key, P/Y and C/Y, BGN/END, CF/NPV/IRR worksheets, bond and depreciation worksheets | One line of display, hidden state (P/Y, BGN) causes classic mistakes, a single IRR is returned without warning when several exist, no explanation of results |20| HP 12C | Handheld financial | RPN speed, n / i / PV / PMT / FV keys, decades of trust in real estate and banking | RPN learning curve, tiny display, same hidden-state and single-IRR issues, compounding conventions must be handled by the user |21| TI-84 Plus family | Handheld graphing | Curriculum standard: Y= editor, window, trace, calc menu (zero, minimum, intersect, ∫), STAT lists, distributions, tests | Low-resolution plots connect across asymptotes unless the user changes mode, no symbolic algebra, menus are deep |22| Desmos | Web / app graphing | The benchmark for interactive graphing: instant sliders, implicit curves, points of interest on tap, beautiful rendering | Online-first product, no financial engine, limited statistics inference, no exact-arithmetic history |23| GeoGebra | Web / app | Geometry + CAS + graphing + 3D in one suite, strong for teaching | Several separate apps and views, dense interface for quick arithmetic |24| Wolfram Alpha | Web service | Unmatched breadth of symbolic computation and curated data, step-by-step solutions | Requires a network connection and, for steps, a subscription; natural-language input is not deterministic |25| Popular scientific apps (PCalc, Calcbot, NumWorks, HiPER…) | Apps | RPN and engineering layouts, unit conversion, customisation | Generally one domain each; finance, graphing, statistics and notebooks live in different apps |26| Popular financial apps (10bii-style, mortgage calculators) | Apps | Focused workflows for one task | Conventions are often implicit (monthly compounding assumed everywhere), Canadian mortgage compounding is frequently wrong or missing |2728## 2. Comparison by criterion2930| Criterion | What the field does | Gap ORIX Calc addresses | How (implemented) |31|---|---|---|---|32| Ease of use for `25 × 4` | Apple sets the bar: open, tap, read | Advanced apps bury arithmetic under modes | Standard is the default environment, opens on the keypad, live preview, no extra tap |33| Feature completeness | Split across 4–6 products | One engine, eight environments, shared history and variables | Eight environments in one app, one `AppModel` session |34| Accuracy model | Almost never disclosed; binary floating point shows `0.1 + 0.2` artefacts in many apps, or hides them by rounding | State the arithmetic used for each result | Exact integers and rationals where possible; every result is labelled *exact* or *≈ floating point*; Explain lists the checks run |35| Financial conventions | Hidden state (P/Y, BGN), silent single IRR, US compounding assumed | Make conventions explicit and refuse to guess | P/Y, C/Y, BGN always visible; `.multiple([rates])` / `.none` for IRR; jurisdiction-aware mortgage compounding (Canada: semi-annual) |36| Graph honesty | Many plotters join points across poles | Never connect across a discontinuity | Dedicated sampler with pole / jump detection, validated by tests on 1/x, tan x, floor x… |37| Symbolic vs numeric | Often not distinguished in the UI | Label every result | `exact / symbolic / numerical / unsupported / failed convergence` result kinds |38| Offline capability | Handhelds: full. Web tools: none or partial | Everything offline | No network code path except the optional, user-initiated ECB rate download |39| Privacy | Web tools log queries; many free apps ship ad SDKs | No account, no analytics | No third-party SDK; privacy manifest declares no collected data |40| Explanations | Step-by-step is a paid, server-side feature elsewhere | Deterministic explanations on device | ORIX Explain is generated from the algorithm's actual steps, never from generated prose |41| Notebook | Apple Math Notes (handwriting-first), spreadsheet apps | A typed, reactive sheet with named variables and a dependency graph | Workspace: incremental recalculation, cycle detection, exports |42| Accessibility | Varies widely; handheld emulations are often unlabeled images | Native controls | SwiftUI controls with labels, Dynamic Type, VoiceOver values, contrast-checked palette |4344## 3. Conventions adopted because users expect them4546- **Financial keys**: N, I/Y, PV, PMT, FV with a CPT action, P/Y and C/Y, BGN / END, cash-flow sign convention47 (money received positive, money paid negative). These are industry conventions, not anyone's design.48- **Percent key**: `A + B%` adds B percent of A — the behaviour of pocket calculators and of Apple Calculator. A strict mode49 (`B% = B/100` everywhere) is available in Settings. See [financial-conventions.md](../mathematics/financial-conventions.md).50- **Graph analysis vocabulary**: root, minimum, maximum, intersection, trace, tangent, ∫ — the TI-84 "CALC" menu vocabulary51 every student knows.52- **RPN**: X, Y, Z, T labels, ENTER, x⇄y, R↓, LASTx, with HP percent semantics (Y is kept).53- **Statistics input**: data *or* summary statistics for each test, as on graphing calculators.5455## 4. Deliberate differences5657- **Implicit multiplication has the same precedence as explicit multiplication** (`1/2x` is `(1/2)·x`, `6 ÷ 2(1+2) = 9`).58 Some calculators bind juxtaposition tighter; ORIX Calc documents its rule and shows the parsed expression before evaluating.59- **`−2² = −4`** (unary minus binds looser than the power), as in mathematics and most CAS, unlike some four-function devices.60- **Multiple IRRs are all reported.** Established calculators return the first root their iteration reaches.61- **No "live" exchange rates.** Rates are ECB reference rates with their date, or manual. The word *live* is never used.6263## 5. Capability gaps that remain (honest list)6465| Area | Leaders | ORIX Calc 1.0 |66|---|---|---|67| Breadth of symbolic integration, special functions, exact algebraic numbers | Wolfram Alpha, GeoGebra CAS | A scoped rule engine; unsupported integrals are reported as unsupported with a numerical fallback |68| Arbitrary-precision transcendental functions | Wolfram Alpha, some high-precision apps | Double precision for transcendental functions (exact arithmetic is arbitrary precision) |69| Geometry constructions | GeoGebra | Not in scope |70| Handwritten or two-dimensional math input | Apple Math Notes, Photomath-style apps | Math Camera reads printed linear expressions only (Beta) |71| Programmability | TI-84, HP, PCalc | User-defined functions and reactive workspaces, no scripting language |72| Exam approval | BA II Plus, HP 12C, TI-84 | A phone or tablet app is not an approved exam calculator |7374Claims of the form "better than X" are not made anywhere in the product or its listing: no comparative measurement was run.75